
The Triangle has discovered that The Standard, the 802-bed student apartment building at 119 South 31st Street, operated without a rental license for nine months beginning last June.
Without a rental license issued by Philadelphia’s Department of Licenses & Inspections, “[n]o person shall collect rent with respect to any property required to be licensed,” according to local law.
The Standard’s renewed license took effect on April 10. Unfortunately for tenants, they are still on the hook for rent paid during those nine months, as well as moving forward.
While rent should not have been collected at the time, there are no legal provisions for tenants to withhold rent unless the property is declared uninhabitable. There is also no explicit mechanism for the return of rent paid to an unlicensed landlord, either.
This means withholding rent from an unlicensed landlord, even with the money set aside in escrow, could open up tenants to eviction proceedings.
Philadelphia Legal Assistance, a legal aid organization, notes that a court order is necessary to evict a tenant. However, according to the website of real estate law firm Nochumson, P.C., the Philadelphia Municipal Court will not hear landlord-tenant cases where the landlord does not have a license, meaning it is unlikely to grant an eviction notice. Instead, landlords would head to the higher Court of Common Pleas, beginning a process that could take several months to resolve.
For the time being, unless tenants are open to a civil court case, they may be better off paying. However, as the Safe Healthy Homes Act goes before City Council on April 16, that legal ambiguity may be resolved moving forward: if passed, tenants would be able to seek rent paid for unlicensed units.
The bill has been hotly contested by landlords, who have fought it on principle and procedural grounds. They argue that even good-faith efforts to comply with the law are stymied by delays on L&I’s end, and that harsher enforcement would be a disaster for small-time landlords.
In function and form, securing a Philadelphia rental license is like getting a driver’s license: just as prospective drivers must compile a stack of paperwork including their physical exam, proof of residency, learner’s permit, completed exam, and more, landlords must present a series of basic certifications before getting the go-ahead to rent a property.
Those forms include proof of property ownership, a certificate of occupancy indicating the property has been inspected, business license and tax information, a lead safety certification, and more. In sum, these certifications aim to ensure the property is safe for occupancy, and that the landlord can be identified and located. An annual renewal process also ensures that the books are kept up to date.
One critical requirement for a rental license is that the property must not have outstanding L&I violations — a criterion not met by The Standard during the time its license had lapsed. According to inspectors, the property had not conducted tests of fire alarm systems, a violation which went unresolved for months.
In fact, the violation was not resolved until The Triangle had contacted L&I and Landmark Properties on March 5. It appears that the expired rental license went unnoticed by city inspectors and The Standard beforehand.
“We are aware of the license status at The Standard at Philadelphia and have been working with multiple City departments to complete the renewal process,” a representative for Landmark Properties responded to The Triangle. “During this process, several additional inspections and administrative steps were identified that required coordination across departments, which has made the process take longer than initially anticipated.”
“Our focus throughout this process has been supporting our residents and maintaining a safe, well-operated community. We take compliance seriously and are working with the City to finalize the renewal as quickly as possible,” the statement concluded.
With the posted fine of $300, in addition to a renewal cost of $69 per unit, The Standard likely owed the city over $19,000 for its annual multi-family apartment license. If the license was renewed on time, that fine would be waived. If that fine were paid on time, it would be halved to $150. It is unclear whether L&I sought any additional late fees, which could be up to 1.5 percent of the renewal fee per expired month; detailed information about specific cases and fines is not typically made public.
It is unclear how much rent was collected with the expired license. With the lowest monthly rent starting at over $1,000 for this September, and assuming 75 percent occupancy for the 802 bed spaces, a conservative estimate is several hundred thousand dollars per month.