
American philosopher John Dewey believed that education was essential to the development of the self; while learning, students could develop individuality. That individuality, he believed, was crucial for true democracy. Albert C. Barnes was a true believer of Dewey’s philosophy, and he saw his extensive collection of paintings and namesake foundation as an opportunity to provide this type of education.
In 1927, when the segregation of the US armed forces, schools, public facilities, and businesses was still legal, Barnes established a scholarship program for young Black creatives to further their educations so that they could contribute to the democracy he dreamed of.
It is no surprise, then, that when considering the fast-approaching and highly anticipated 250th anniversary of America, the Barnes Foundation chose to present an exhibition focusing on what freedom means to those who have not always been free: “Freedom Dreams.” As historian Robin D. G. Kelley, author of the book that inspired the title of the exhibit, explains, “Rather than treating liberty as a universal constant, the exhibition presents freedom as a precarious concept, one produced, managed, and often secured through unfreedom, gratuitous violence, and extreme duress.”
“Freedom Dreams,” curated by James Claiborne and Maori Karmael Holmes, features the work of five artists who utilized film, video, and installation to explore what freedom has historically meant to Black people. Holmes, the Chief Executive and Artistic Officer of BlackStar Projects, spoke to the significance of the exhibit being in film: “In 2026, most of us are ingesting most of our culture through moving image…and so I think that when we’re reflecting on the semiquincentennial as this major landmark in time, to me, to do it in a very contemporary medium makes a lot of sense. It is how we take in culture.”
A standout work in “Freedom Dreams” is Arthur Jafa’s digital video, “Love is the Message, The Message is Death” (2016). Throughout, Jafa highlights many of the types of moving images through which culture is consumed. Claiborne — the Fleischner Family Vice President for Engagement at the Barnes — noted that Jafa’s work “speaks towards…matters of history, democracy, liberation so clearly. And a decade later, it still seems as though it is as resonant as when it was first released.” Set to Kanye West’s “Ultralight Beam,” Jafa expertly harnesses the moments in these clips that exude joy and pride, as well as those that convey pain and suffering, throughout the video, illustrating the tension between joy and suffering that defines both the historical and present-day Black experience.
The four additional artists’ works expand this exploration of freedom. Garrett Bradley’s “America” (2019) explores Blackness on film between 1915 and 1926, including “The Lime Kiln Field Day” (1913) — the oldest existing film featuring Black actors. What is most striking is how rare the film documentation of the unassuming and ordinary parts of Black life feels, stressing how frequently these moments are overlooked or excluded. Claiborne shared that “while Philly is a perfect backdrop to have a very formal, straight-ahead dialogue around matters of history and democracy, it seemed perhaps there was an opportunity to take a path of interrogation.” By showcasing ignored narratives, Bradley deftly interrogates history and democracy in “America” (2019).
Ja’Tovia Gary’s “Quiet as It’s Kept” (2023) similarly engages with memory, drawing on both personal and collective histories to examine Black girlhood and interiority. Inspired in part by Toni Morrison’s “The Bluest Eye,” the work combines layered imagery and sound to explore how identity is shaped by both lived experience and imposed narratives. Gary’s use of fragmentation allows past and present to coexist, creating a space in which memory is not static, but continuously reinterpreted. In doing so, the film reflects on freedom not only as a political condition, but as an internal and personal pursuit.
In “On Exactitude in Science (Watts)” (2021), David Hartt turns toward landscape and architecture to explore how space itself holds memory. Filmed in Los Angeles’ Watts neighborhood, the work subtly references “Killer of Sheep,” drawing a connection between past and present depictions of Black life. Through deliberate imagery, Hartt maps a geography shaped by history, suggesting that environments carry the weight of constraint and possibility. As Claiborne noted, the exhibition fosters an “intergenerational dialogue,” and Hartt’s work exemplifies this by positioning contemporary experience in conversation with earlier cultural expressions.
Tourmaline’s “Pollinator” (2022) offers a vibrant meditation on Black trans life, centering joy, care, and visibility. Inspired by the legacy of Marsha P. Johnson, the film imagines a world in which trans bodies exist freely and abundantly, moving through lush, dreamlike environments. In contrast to narratives that focus on marginalization, Tourmaline puts pleasure and affirmation at the foreground of her work, reframing freedom as both a present practice and a future possibility.
As the United States approaches its 250th anniversary, “Freedom Dreams” resists offering a singular or celebratory definition of freedom. Instead, the exhibition invites viewers to reconsider it as something unfinished — something that must be continuously questioned, reimagined, and fought for. Holmes reflected that the show “offers us an opportunity to examine the possibilities that Black artists and cultural workers have dared to imagine…in the face of the most impossible circumstances to dare to imagine themselves free, dare to imagine themselves liberated and thriving.” In this way, the works on view do not simply document history, but actively participate in shaping what freedom can look like moving forward.
At the same time, “Freedom Dreams” leaves space for uncertainty and inquiry. Holmes shared that she hopes “people actually leave [the exhibition] with more questions…that people are curious and they leave wanting to go deeper into the things that are presented,” emphasizing that engagement with the work should extend beyond the gallery walls. This sentiment is echoed by Claiborne, who noted the importance of understanding that “memory and history are active and living spaces that we all have a collective responsibility to wrestle with and to shape.” Together, these perspectives position the exhibition not as a conclusion, but as an invitation that challenges viewers to imagine, question, and participate in the ongoing pursuit of freedom.