U. California librarians urge professors to boycott publishing company

By Allie Bidwell

Librarians throughout the U. California system are urging professors not to submit articles to 67 journals in Nature Publishing Group, in of protest of a 400 percent increase in subscription prices.

UC librarians and representatives from the California Digital Library and the University Committee on Library and Scholarly Communication drafted a letter June 4 condemning a new contract with the publishing group, which the letter states will raise the university’s subscription costs by more than $1 million.

However, in a June 9 response, the publishing group states the “implication that (Nature Publishing Group) is increasing its list prices by massive amounts is entirely untrue” and claims the UC system has been paying an unfair rate. According to the publishing group, the university has been given a large discount that is subsidized by other subscribers’ payments.

This is because the university, according to the statement, is one institution with multiple campuses, making its definition as a subscriber complicated and producing a lower subscription price.

Brian Schottlaender, university librarian for UC San Diego, said in an e-mail that the publishing group’s response is misleading.

“That claim is completely without merit,” he said in the e-mail. “It’s based on ‘list price,’ which no one pays anyhow. When UC’s price was renegotiated in 2008, there was no reference to its being ‘unfair.’ Why is it unfair now?”

He added that the proposed increase would make the average cost of the group’s journals three to four times more expensive than most other scientific journals to which the UC subscribes.

In the statement, the publishing group said its content merits the extra price.

“It is our belief (our) titles represent excellent value for money, whether measured by cost per download, or perhaps more accurately, cost per local citation,” the statement said.

Richard Schneider, chair of the university committee on library and scholarly communication, said because UC professors contribute a large number of articles to Nature, one of the publishing group’s major journals, it is as if the publishing group is “repackaging and delivering” their work. He added that UC professors contributed 12 percent of all articles printed last year in Nature and the next highest contributing university was Harvard University, at 9 percent.

Although many professors rely on publishing their research in journals produced by the group, many UC Berkeley faculty have endorsed the boycott, according to UC Berkeley university librarian Tom Leonard.

Professors will have other opportunities to publish their articles, according to Laine Farley, executive director of the UC’s California Digital Library, which manages most of the university’s journal subscriptions. The service eScholarship would give professors the opportunity to publish their articles in journals elsewhere.

According to Schneider, boycotting the publishing group will not leave students at a disadvantage. He said if students need access to journals the library does not subscribe to, they can contact corresponding authors with e-mail addresses provided in the journals and request a full copy of the article.

“The rest of the world sees UC as the premier research university in the world,” he said. “We hope Nature sees the light and recognizes that UC provides a valuable service to them and that we can achieve a mutually rewarding and sustainable relationship with Nature.”

Read more here: http://www.dailycal.org/article/109651/uc_librarians_urge_professors_to_boycott_publishin
Copyright 2026 Daily Californian