UMN professors concerned about AI faculty reviews

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

Some University of Minnesota professors feel discomfort after a policy drafted by the Faculty and Academic Affairs department changed guidelines regarding the acceptable usage of AI for faculty members’ annual reviews. 

The drafted policy read AI can be used to help assist the review process for University faculty members, such as developing ideas, grammar and looking for their CVs. 

Michael Gallope, a professor and chair of the University’s Department of Cultural Studies and Comparative Literature, said AI should not be used when it comes to reviewing faculty, as it lessens the transparency within the University community. 

Machines can not evaluate with the same clarity that humans can, Gallope said.

“In order to evaluate faculty, they must be evaluated by other human experts,” Gallope said. “That must be done by human beings in order for the system to maintain trust.” 

Gallope said he wants the University to decide to promote faculty members because of their accomplishments, as the potential usage of AI in reviewing affects the credibility of the review. 

“We work at a public university, I want the public to believe that when we give somebody tenure to promote them, the basis is the excellence of their thinking, teaching and research,” Gallope said. “If we’re phoning in reviews with AI assistants, that’s a potential question of public trust at stake.”  

Recently, the University announced Galin Jones as the inaugural Vice Provost and the launch of the AI hub, an action that has reflected a greater lean into AI integration across the institution. This effort, Eric Van Wyk, the chair of the University’s Faculty Senate committee on academic freedom and tenure, said, is following a trend among other universities. 

“It feels like this is a bandwagon all Universities feel they have to jump on,” Wyk said. “There’s a sense that sometimes that these are fascinating and novel products, but we sometimes chase the novelty and aren’t sure of the substance behind them yet.” 

Wyk said the policy shows the clear and transparent uses faculty members could potentially have. 

Nathaniel Mills, the chair of the English department and a professor at the University, said reviews should be left to department leaders, as faculty members are reviewed annually. 

Leaving this decision to AI, Mills said, could limit the room for interpretation that human interactions and examinations offer. 

“To me, knowing how to review a faculty member and knowing which areas to include in a faculty member’s review is something like this kind of an essential job of the chair,” Mills said. “Not something that should be outsourced to AI for assistance.” 

Mills said while the University is implementing AI into its institution, they attempted to reduce funds for different University departments in 2023. 

“What we’re really seeing is the University really investing in AI technology at the same time that budgetary decisions are forcing cuts to instruction in the College of Liberal Arts,” Mills said. “A lot of departments in CLA are having to consider laying off non-tenure track faculty members.” 

V.V. Ganeshananthan, an English professor, said she felt disregarded after talking to the University about the usage of AI. She feels her complaints haven’t been heard.

“When I have provided feedback to the institution before about the use of AI, I have not necessarily felt that I was being heard,” Ganeshananthan said. ”It’s important that feedback be solicited in a substantive way that makes faculty members feel heard.”

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/campus/umn-professors-concerned-about-ai-faculty-reviews/04/08/2026/eicmndaily-com/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily