I never really believed in the notion of Minnesota nice. Somewhere along the line, we come to different conclusions about what it actually means, and “nice” as a word comes with some ambiguity. While I don’t think Minnesota nice means Minnesota friendly, I do think it means Minnesota considerate, in that we look out for each other, especially this time of year.
It’s evident in the way we’ve risen to the occasion as community members, as well as in the small gestures of kindness and compassion we share in harsh winters. We have a unique culture as a state that is downplayed when we chalk it up to simply being nice.
The Twin Cities have a reputation for being tough to break into socially, and our reserved nature can make finding friends difficult for people new to the state.
Will Sogge was born and raised in Baltimore, but has lived in Bloomington, Indiana, Seattle and San Francisco. Sogge works as a case manager in the Twin Cities and said it’s harder to build close friendships here.
“I personally felt like Minnesota nice has implied a degree of politeness and kindness, but then something that, at times, keeps people at a bit of a distance, almost like a formality,” Sogge said.
Having grown up in Duluth, University of Minnesota third-year student Jazin Majchrzak said he’s observed a reservation in social dynamics partially rooted in the state’s Scandinavian influence.
“There’s a heavy emphasis on manners, and you never want to impose on other people,”
Majchrzak said.
There’s a consideration for others in this strict, sometimes cold adherence to manners.
“You don’t even want to impose on others by having the arrogance to talk to them,” Majchrzak said. “Oh, that’s too much. I’m imposing on them. They have their day. I don’t want to mess with them.”
Maybe Minnesota nice presents itself from a distance. After all, it’s not Minnesota-friendly.
At the tail end of spring break, there was a severe winter storm warning. I trekked over and through feet-high snowpiles on my way to class and work for the next few days.
I’m no stranger to subzero temperatures and winters that stretch on way past their welcome, at times to the tune of nearly six months. Many of my college social experiences so far have revolved around these harsh conditions in some way, whether that’s been holing up with a group of floor neighbors on a Friday night to commiserate over being snowed in or huddling around with friends to keep from face-planting into the freshly fallen snow — because we didn’t check the forecast.
University first-year student Ky Farmen said there’s a bond shared through commiseration over the weather.
“When you complain about something, you find community,” Farmen said.
Sometimes this weather lets us share misery at how much it sucks to wear two layers of pants and three shirts just to go to an hour-long lecture. I’ve grown reverent of it. I think it makes us kinder. I’m not a 100% believer in Minnesota nice, but I see glimmers of it in the consideration we lend one another, even if it goes unspoken.
Third-year student Dylan Pekay said he experienced what he considers Minnesota nice firsthand this past winter during a severe storm, when he and some friends wound up driving into a ditch following a ski trip.
“Not within five minutes, some guy with a tow truck — not even a tow truck, but just a truck and a big enough chain — was able to pull us out, and he just did that out of the kindness of his heart,” Pekay said.
First-year student Salina Poynton has worked all kinds of customer service jobs from Target, Starbucks and Caribou to Menards.
“People are a lot nicer in the winter than the summer, at least with customer service jobs that I’ve worked,” Poynton said. “I don’t know, people are just nicer and they tip more, which is pretty nice.”
Katt Karttova works as a dominatrix in the Twin Cities and has observed regional differences in her travels through the southern half of the country.
“I would say people are way, way more considerate of other people than down south,” Karttova said. “And I think a big part of that is because half the year, again, we’re slipping and sliding.”
On Saturday, more than 200,000 protesters attended the “No Kings” rally in St. Paul, according to organizers who said the event was estimated to be the largest in the state’s history. This comes after weeks of historic turnouts protesting the actions of federal agents in the peak of winter, often in subzero temperatures. We’ve also held a national spotlight as a protest city placed in a state with a history of strong social policy.
Majchrzak is a member of the Young Democratic Socialists of America at the University. When discussing Minnesota exceptionalism, he said it isn’t something we can rest on our laurels about because Minnesota nice is a process of becoming.
“I think every state, I think every group of people can do this,” Majchrzak said.
It’s supposed to snow on Thursday, again. Keep an extra pair of gloves, and try to start a conversation on your next awkward elevator ride, for Minnesota’s sake.