When Rep. Erin Koegel tried to buy tickets to a small concert in Minneapolis at 7th St Entry, they were listed online for $231, far above their $18 face value.
“That’s insane,” Koegel said. “You either don’t go to the show or spend a whole lot of money to see a band.”
Local concertgoer Bethany Rhea said she has personally benefited from the current resale system and noted how profitable it can be.
“I once got two tickets to see Tate McRae a few years ago, and it was before she was a megastar,” Rhea said. “I resold them for around $400 per ticket, which was enough to pay for my laptop at the time. It’s crazy how much you can mark up tickets, and it’s totally legal to do so.”
Koegel’s experience with ticket price gouging inspired her to introduce a bill limiting ticket resale price gouging in Minnesota earlier this month. The bill would require ticket resellers to disclose the original price and cap resale prices at 115% of face value, she said.
The bill also targets practices like bulk purchasing through bots, which can quickly buy up tickets and resell them at inflated prices.
“What happens is these bots or people go in and buy up all the tickets to artificially inflate demand,” Koegel said. “You can’t even get tickets on the primary market.”
However, this bill is drawing criticism from the ticketing industry, which argues the proposal could have unintended consequences for consumers.
Jack Sterne, StubHub’s head of policy communications, said the bill focuses too narrowly on one part of the ticketing market.
“At the end of the day, tickets are only resold about 9% of the time,” Sterne said. “While price caps might sound like a good idea, they hurt fans by increasing fraud and empowering Ticketmaster’s monopoly.”
Sterne added it would not address the larger issue of ticket pricing. He pointed to ongoing legal challenges against Ticketmaster.
“At a time when a bipartisan group of 30+ state Attorneys General, including the Minnesota Attorney General, are suing Ticketmaster for antitrust violations,” Sterne said. “The legislature shouldn’t give this monopoly a gift.”
Ticket resale at significantly higher prices is currently legal in Minnesota. Koegel said that was not always the case.
“I remember going to baseball games when I was young and seeing people selling tickets, and they weren’t allowed to sell them over face value,” Koegel said. “We need to have anti-speculative laws again.”
Beyond consumer costs, Koegel said the current system also affects artists and venues.
“The markups are not going to the venues or the artists,” Koegel said. “They’re going strictly to the person who was able to buy up tickets.”
Koegel said the bill was developed in collaboration with industry and advocacy groups, including the National Independent Venue Association and The Fan Alliance.
Sterne pointed to countries like France and Australia, where resale restrictions have been linked to higher levels of ticket fraud.
Paris Olympics, for example, France’s face-value cap contributed to a surge in ticket scams, the national police identifying 338 fraudulent ticket websites but shutting down only 51. In Australia, regulators reported fans lost up to $260,000 to ticket scams on social media before Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour shows in early 2024.
“When you don’t have a trusted marketplace, scammers fill that gap,” Sterne said. “Studies have shown that price caps don’t actually bring ticket prices down.”