
Amid accounts of unlawful actions by federal immigration agents in Massachusetts, Gov. Maura Healey and Attorney General Andrea Campbell last Friday introduced the “ICE Misconduct Portal,” a website aimed at gathering, tracking and analyzing reports of abuse by agents.
While student Democrat leaders said they support the idea behind the portal, they expressed hesitation about its use and effectiveness.
The portal allows Massachusetts residents to submit photos, videos and written reports of unlawful encounters with ICE agents to identify patterns of misconduct and inform policy actions, according to the release.
“The people of Massachusetts deserve to know that their rights will be respected, their safety protected and their concerns about misconduct taken seriously,” Healey wrote in a press release announcing the initiative.
Mandy Zhang, chair of the College Democrats of Massachusetts and former president of the Harvard College Democrats, said she is glad Healey and Campbell “are doing what the federal government refuses to do, which is prioritize the safety and rights of Massachusetts residents.”
But Zhang said she is concerned about the security of reporters’ personal information, as people must submit their name and email address to the portal to file a complaint.
“I would want just more information,” she said. “I don’t know if the system is safe yet.”
If the portal proves effective, Zhang said the College Democrats of Massachusetts would be open to “utilizing this to keep our community safe.”
Akram Mchiti, outreach director for College Democrats of Massachusetts, said he thinks Healey and Campbell’s “number one priority” should be protecting the identities of the people who submit reports to the ICE portal.
Mchiti said he thinks sharing evidence of unlawful ICE behavior with the state — especially as videos documenting such incidents continue to circulate widely on social media — “is a positive for everybody.”
“This is just one of those pieces in the machine that hopefully will make an impact in keeping people in Massachusetts safe from ICE agents, and [set] the precedent for the whole country on how states can still have some say in what the federal government’s doing,” Mchiti said.
Prior to launching the portal, Healey made other efforts to hold ICE accountable, including filing legislation to prevent ICE from staging operations in “sensitive locations” such as courthouses, schools and hospitals, and signing an executive order requiring judicial warrants for entry into non-public areas of state facilities.
Alpha Barry, president of the conservative Boston University club Young Americans for Freedom, said he believes the portal won’t effectively “stymie the levels of … deportation,” but is rather a strategy by Healey to appease her voting base.
Barry said he is also concerned the public will abuse the ICE portal by submitting false reports or reporting agents for being present or “just doing their jobs,” which could impede their work.
“The idea in theory is good. Holding any group of government officials accountable is always important, so in that regard, I think it is effective,” Barry said. “Unfortunately, I know it will be abused in ways that it probably shouldn’t be.”
Peter Levine, associate dean for academic affairs at Tufts University and a professor of political science and philosophy, raised similar concerns about people misusing the public portal, but said it was “too early to tell.”
Levine said the primary purpose of the portal is most likely to document examples of ICE misconduct for Massachusetts to use in litigation against the federal government.
“The way to assess it is to ask whether the information collected there is useful to the state and politically against the Trump administration,” Levine said. “That’s what matters. It’s not the existence of the portal, it’s the litigation.”
Levine said he believes the portal is part of a broader effort by Democratic-led states to monitor federal immigration agents and reflects a trend toward federalism, where states assert more power in place of the federal government.
While doubtful that Massachusetts residents will see “changes next week or next month,” Mchiti said he is ultimately hopeful about its potential to be used in court to hold federal agents liable.
“Hopefully, after midterms this year, we can see some accountability starting in Congress,” Mchiti said. “The evidence that’s brought up through this tip line that they just released will help in those lawsuits and help in those proceedings in Congress.”