Faculty Senate Votes No Confidence in ODU President Hemphill in 41-7 Vote

On Mar. 10, 76% of the Faculty Senate voted in a show of no confidence in President Brian Hemphill, Provost Brian Payne, and Vice President for Digital Transformation and Technology Nina Rodriguez Gonser. The vote resulted in an overwhelming 41-7 majority against the selected members of staff, with six voters abstaining.

 

However, the Board of Visitors (BOV), a governing body of the university appointed by the governor, maintains confidence in ODU’s leadership, claiming in an email sent to the student body that same day that the vote merely represents the views of some faculty members, the result of which is that the vote of no confidence has no explicit outcome.

 

This vote occurred after months of the Faculty Senate attempting to communicate their concerns with the Forward-Focused Digital Transformation Initiative (FFDTI), chief among them the fact that faculty were not asked for their input on these changes.

 

After the vote occurred, the BOV sent out an email to ODU’s student body, saying that “a vote of no confidence was passed associated with the implementation of eight-week accelerated online courses,” adding that “this vote reflects the views expressed by some members of the Faculty Senate present at that meeting.” Ultimately, the Board of Visitors affirms their support of President Brian Hemphill.

 

The Board of Visitors claims that “the vote taken today represents one viewpoint within the broader University community.” Hemphill’s statement, sent to the student body an hour after the BOV’s statement, makes no mention of the fact that the vote was one of no confidence, simply calling it “a Faculty Senate vote related to the implementation of a component of Forward-Focused Digital Transformation.”

 

However, according to an email sent out to faculty members by Faculty Senate Chair Corrin Allen, the numbers surrounding the vote of no confidence are significantly higher than the Board of Visitors made it seem. Of 55 total senators, 54 participated in the vote, with 41 voting to do a show of no confidence, 6 abstaining, and 7 who voted to keep the president, provost, and vice president. It is clear to see that the vast majority of the Faculty Senate do not have the confidence in the president, provost, and vice president to lead the school.

 

Hemphill and the BOV both mention that the Faculty Senate’s vote was simply a response to a component of FFDTI, framing this as an issue with the implementation of 8-week accelerated courses. While it is true that the faculty has their concerns, this vote was not just about those courses. In the Faculty Senate’s resolution of the no confidence vote, they confirm that the larger issue is the rushed enactment of changes, writing “faculty are not categorically opposed to the FFDTI but are instead opposed to a rushed and peremptory implementation that jeopardizes the quality of an ODU education.”

 

The resolution also acknowledges that the Faculty Senate’s attempts to communicate their concerns in October 2025 were dismissed by the administration.

 

The critical failures in leadership that the Faculty Senate alleges were failure to protect academic freedom and discipline-specific expertise, erosion and misdefinition of shared governance, failure of communication, dismissive tenor of communication, hostility and lack of engagement from the BOV, and failure to respond to national governance inquiries. The Faculty Senate criticizes the administration’s “one-size-fits-all” academic mandate, their development of FFDTI without faculty input, and their inconsistent and contradictory communication. 

 

The BOV, on the other hand, have been supportive of FFDTI from the beginning. In an email to Corrin Allen sent on Dec. 2, 2025, Rector Murry Pitts affirms the Board’s support of the initiative. He writes, “the Board was immediately drawn to the merits of the effort, while also being undoubtedly aware that there would be concerns, questions, and pushback. Being aware of those barriers, the Board directed the President to move forward with all due speed, thereby reducing the roll-out from three years to 18 months.”

 

It seems that the Board of Visitors’ support was a factor in Hemphill’s speedy execution of FFDTI. The Board of Visitors similarly dismissed faculty concerns, with Pitts writing, “a great deal of your narrative is taken out of context and seems to be inflated in order to insinuate that the President is unwilling to meet with the faculty.” This correspondence occurred a week after Hemphill backed out of a Faculty Senate meeting he had been planning to attend.

 

In addition to the no confidence vote, the Faculty Senate calls for the administration to acknowledge and respect shared governance, as well as delay the implementation of FFDTI. 

 

Faculty concerns about FFDTI have been publicly available for months. The Faculty Senate’s website includes a press release from Jan. 21 that details ample amounts of faculty concerns, gathered from university-wide polls and surveys. 

 

The results of these polls and the survey are available on the same page. Both had strong response rates. The polls received responses from 507 faculty members (out of an estimated total of 1,172 full-time ODU faculty members). The survey received responses from 558 faculty members, and noted that the 43% response rate is a much higher engagement rate than is typical for faculty surveys at other U.S. four-year institutions. The only known acknowledgement of the survey is a message from the provost, which can be read here.

 

It appears Hemphill and the BOV are attempting to obscure the results of the Faculty Senate’s vote of no confidence. Given that the vote has no explicit outcome, it is difficult to tell what the next step will be. The Faculty Senate has requested to delay the implementation of FFDTI, but it is clear that the BOV will not allow that to happen.

Read more here: https://maceandcrown.com/5815/news/faculty-senate-votes-no-confidence-in-odu-president-hemphill-in-41-7-vote/
Copyright 2026