Review of tenure policy sparks concern among teaching faculty

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

GRACE AIGNER: Hi everyone! I’m Grace Aigner from the Minnesota Daily. Welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota.

Whether you noticed it or not, you’ve most likely been in a class taught by someone who is not technically a full professor. In more casual classroom settings, you probably still call that person a professor, like I do, but instructor titles can vary widely—from teaching professor to lecturer or adjunct professor. Although it may not matter much in the classroom, one of the key differences among instructors is whether they are on a tenure track or not.

In today’s episode, we’ll dive into concerns about the future of non-tenure faculty roles, also known as teaching faculty or teaching professors, as university administrators review those roles and how to align them with university policy.

The story starts in 2023, when a Faculty Senate subcommittee shared a report with recommendations to improve job security for non-tenure track faculty members. For example, the subcommittee recommended the university change its policy to create clearer pathways to promotion and longer contract options for non-tenure track faculty.

But, the report also noted that the way non-tenure track roles, specifically teaching professors, have been functioning does not align with the university code that describes their purpose. 

Now, administrators in the provost’s office are responding to the subcommittee’s recommendations. Associate Vice Provost Ole Gram said they are trying to figure out how to allow departments to continue hiring people to these positions while also ensuring faculty structure follows university policy.

OLE GRAM: For many years the university has not really over-complied with the provisions in the policy that says, OK, you are not really supposed to appoint people as teaching professors or research professors. And we even have job codes that says there is a job code that says teaching professor, it is a number and then it has a suffix that is a “T” to indicate it’s teaching.

So there is that incongruence between the policy and, and the practice. And that has caused a bit of a conflict. When that came out and, and came to light the administration sort of had to say, look, we have to, we have to follow our policy. 

But we also know it’s at an impasse because departments and colleges really are eager to appoint people in these categories. It’s important for next year to be able to have people delivering the curriculum. And that’s a little bit the impasse we’re at right now.

AIGNER: The main difference between faculty who are tenured versus those who are not is the amount of time they spend teaching in the classroom. The majority of a tenured faculty member’s time is typically spent doing research, about a quarter is spent teaching students and the rest is spent on service. 

Teaching faculty have their duties flipped. They spend almost all of their time in the classroom teaching, and the rest of it doing service work or clinical work. If they do research, they usually spend only a small portion of their time on it, and it is often research about how to improve education. The odds that you’ve been taught by a teaching faculty member are high as they teach many intro-level courses.

In the university’s tenure code, reasons for appointing non-tenure, or “term” faculty, are fairly limited and are supposed to be for temporary periods. But David Kirkpatrick, head of the College of Biological Sciences’ Biology Teaching and Learning Department, said the university has not followed the limitations of non-tenure roles for decades.

DAVID KIRKPATRICK: It would be great if the policies align with the practices. That’s, I think the final goal here is to do that. My personal preference would be that we align the historical use with the policy and change the policies to reflect the historical use. The historical use has been excellent.

There’s been no issues with it until it was pointed out that we’re not in compliance. So I think it makes a lot of sense to modify the policies to continue the use that we’re allowing for these positions. And the positions themselves have a huge level of positive outcomes. 

So it would, to my mind, it would be really problematic to not allow them anymore, given how effective the people in those positions have been and how well the position itself aligns with the greater university instructional and teaching mission.

AIGNER: Anna Mosser, a teaching professor in the College of Biological Sciences and faculty senator, said the discussion about the disconnect between university tenure policy and her job feels like a rug is being pulled out from under her. 

ANNA MOSSER: A lot of us have been talking about when we were hired we were told this is a career position. This is not a temporary thing. You will be here, you know, first as long as you wanna be, as long as you’re doing a good job. Don’t think of this as temporary. 

And I was so excited. I was like, oh my gosh, I wanna focus on teaching. I’m so happy that the University of Minnesota, my home, has these teaching professor roles that I can make a career of and I can stay and there’s job stability. And that was the sort of impression that we had when we were hired. 

And now that seems like that’s kind of being questioned. And if there are problems with the policy, they’re not talking about changing the tenure policy, the tenure code, they’re talking about moving us to a less secure, less certain sort of career building type of job path. 

AIGNER: Mosser has been a faculty member at the university for over a decade. She recently won the Morse-Alumni award for outstanding undergraduate education, the highest honor awarded to faculty.

Susan LoRusso, an associate teaching professor in the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication and a faculty senator, said teaching faculty are bound to be concerned about the future of their jobs when administrators question their roles.

SUSAN LORUSSO: Some of it is not that someone is doing anything wrong or that has ill intentions, but I think a lot of people have those concerns or those that aren’t really aware this is going on whenever they are, that will be a concern. 

I hope that whatever is decided creates a better situation, a more equitable situation for people. But certainly that’s always in the back of people’s minds. And you’re talking about faculty who we do not have tenure. We will not, we will not have tenure. And so that’s always a concern from non-tenure line faculty. 

It’s like, will I have a job? And so then when like, OK, they’re going to do something with these positions, then it’s not unusual for that concern to be even heightened. 

AIGNER: Teaching faculty are in the minority of instructors. But they are often involved with curriculum development and teach large classes every semester. Kirkpatrick said teaching professors are an invaluable part of the quality of education departments can offer students.

KIRKPATRICK: They’re not a huge cohort, but they’re highly effective. So, not too surprisingly this issue has raised a lot of concern in that group. I would love to have the university basically make a statement saying that they intend to make the policy align with our historical practice.

Barring that, and since that hasn’t happened yet, everyone’s nervous. You always get nervous when people are talking about what your job is and so, given all the other types of things going on in the Twin Cities right now, it’s a level of stress and angst that I would prefer not to inflict on my faculty members. 

They’ve had enough to deal with, with all of the federal issues at the beginning of the semester and everything. So this just kind of compounds things in an unfortunate manner.

AIGNER: Mosser said communication from administrators about the review process has been vague. She hasn’t felt that the administration intends to adjust policy to match how jobs like hers function.

MOSSER: I think the first thing that I feel is a lack of respect for the work that I do and. The intellectual effort that goes into our classes, improving them every year. I mean, it’s not autopilot. Like we are changing things all the time. Responding to our students and how they change, getting through the pandemic, all of these things.

And it is not an easy job. It takes a ton of intellectual input and sort of saying that “Oh, no, no, no, you shouldn’t be amongst the faculty. You should be over in this category.” And not that I’m demeaning like the other category of jobs, but like just not recognizing that as one of the first things I feel it also makes me feel much less certain of the future of my position. 

And so, you get to the point you’re like, “Oh, OK, do I need to start looking for work elsewhere?” Because I don’t know, you know, if they’re gonna decide that these jobs are not gonna be supported anymore.

AIGNER: Gram said that he understands the anxiety among faculty, and wants to assure that these roles are not going to go away and no one is going to lose their job. While he isn’t certain about the outcome, he expects the review process to lead to policy changes that allow these roles to continue to exist as they are.

GRAM: Absolutely no cause for concern, right? There is a need to be careful that whatever we do meets those criteria in the tenure policy, right? Which is sort of like foundational policy for regulating these, these jobs the best we can. 

But there’s no, there’s absolutely no need to think about these jobs sort of going away. But there is a need for clarification and I think that’s really what this boils down to. I don’t know where it will go. I think it probably will require some changes to policy to allow these kinds of appointments in one form or the other to continue to exist.

AIGNER: Gram is also a member of a focus group that plans to speak with as many people as possible to understand who will be affected by this process. 

And while administrators like Gram don’t seem to intend to change or get rid of teaching roles, faculty like Fitzpatrick and Mosser in the Biology Teaching and Learning department are dealing with the effects of the bureaucratic process right now.

FITZPATRICK: We found out about this working group because we put in a request to hire a new teaching professor because a teaching associate professor was retiring after 40 years at the university. And we needed to be able to fill her instructional responsibilities.

She normally teaches two classes each semester of about 250 students, so pretty big teaching responsibilities. And our dean had agreed to let us hire two other teaching profs who would be 75% in one of the other College of Biological Sciences departments, and 25% in mine to act as connecting bridges between departments. We’ve used that model and with two other college departments in the past, and it’s been very effective. 

But we were told that they were freezing hires for the teaching prof positions until all of this was worked out. So at this point, we are scrambling to fill in the short term teaching holes that we will have for the next academic year. So that’s going to add to the stress of all of this for me at least, and certainly for the many of my people in my department. 

MOSSER: The teaching professor role is much more attractive. It comes with stability, it comes with the title, it comes with being able to participate in faculty. So we’re gonna have a hard time recruiting, you know, because of course we’re competing with other places who potentially have these types of roles and will have a hard time recruiting the best candidates for those.

And we desperately need to hire, we do not have enough people right now to fill the teaching positions. I think we’re OK for the fall, but starting next spring, we’re gonna be short. 

AIGNER: Teaching faculty in CBS often teach biology courses for students outside of the college. For example, College of Liberal Arts students like myself have to take a course that fulfills their “Biological Sciences” liberal education requirement. Mosser added that being short-staffed could affect the availability of these courses as well as major-specific courses.

The next step in the review process is for Gram and the rest of the focus group to talk with as many stakeholders as possible—from department heads to part time staff.

GRAM: The goal is to have something by May, I believe, is indicated in the, in the charge, to help move things forward. But there is really a collective desire to move forward, to improve conditions, right? For the groups outside the tenure system.

What are my paths for promotion? Job guarantees, contract lengths, everyone I think is eager to, to see that improved, quite frankly. These are people, employees who are absolutely crucial to the university, right? They are the teachers in the classroom, they deliver the curriculum. So it, it’s critical to the mission of the university.

AIGNER: Bureaucratic processes take a lot of time at the university. Fitzpatrick and LoRusso are aware of the meticulous, potentially years-long, road ahead. They said they hope to come out on the other side of it with clarity and support for non-tenure teaching roles. 

FITZPATRICK: I don’t think there’s any ill will in any of these discussions. I think it’s just a matter of practicality and what is possible. So I don’t know what Beth Lewis’, the Vice Provost for Faculty and Academic Affairs, office is thinking because they really haven’t said much, but I expect that they also want to make sure that there’s an alignment with what we’re doing, with what we’re told we’re supposed to be doing by our tenure code.

I would hope that they would understand and recognize the value that the teaching profs bring to the university. And even if it’s a harder lift to change the tenure code, that the outcomes would be broad enough and worthwhile enough that they would be willing to make that effort. 

LORUSSO: These positions were never intended to be career positions. But they have become career positions. You have people five, 10 plus years like that, those are, those are careers, right. And so yeah, “term” is like the best way to describe it. 

I think a lot of term faculty do have, like, have PhDs, I have a PhD, it is nice to have, we do have like professor titles, right? I’m an associate teaching associate professor. I think people would like to hang on to those types of titles. What could be nice is to make, to change that, right? So that they do become in alignment with that. 

That was pointed out to me. It did feel a little, I don’t know. It impacted me a little bit. Like, “Oh, I’m not supposed to be here or something.” And I’m here and I’ve been, I was a graduate student too, so I’ve been here for 14 years. And so, you know, I, I, I feel like I should be here and it’d be nice if it was reflected in that as well.

AIGNER: Mosser said she and other teaching faculty simply want to continue doing the work they love without having the institution they’ve been loyal to question their purpose and impact.

MOSSER: I love my job. I love working with students and I am so happy that that’s what I get to do every day. But then all this other stuff swirling around the outside just makes it very hard to focus on what we wanna do, helping the students learn. 

AIGNER: Members of the Faculty Senate will have the opportunity to vote on any decisions about non-tenure faculty roles that administrators suggest, but what those decisions will be is uncertain for now.

I came away from reporting this episode with a better understanding of the lives of the professors who’ve been teaching me for the last three years. The biggest lesson I learned was that our professors deal with stress and responsibilities both inside and outside the classroom, and I appreciate their investment in wanting to teach students like me.

That’s all I’ve got for you today, folks! This episode was written by Grace Aigner and produced by Ceci Heinen. Thanks for listening and if you have any questions, comments or concerns, don’t be afraid to send us an email at podcasting@mndaily.com. I’d love to hear from you.

My name is Grace Aigner, be safe, be well and I’ll talk to you next time on In The Know.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/podcasts/review-of-tenure-policy-sparks-concern-among-teaching-faculty/03/06/2026/shill/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily