Summer 2024 was one for the books. I can’t stop hearing about our collective yearning for 2016’s popular culture. Now that I’ve lived through both of these highly consequential years, I can confidently predict that we will pine for 2024 equally as hard.
Both years were defined by deeply contentious elections, but they managed to produce pop cultural unity and leave their respective marks through music. These years are flashes in the pan, but by examining what made them so special, we can further understand what our generation has to contend with to foster real unity and joy.
Two weeks ago, I was on a nearly three-hour commute back and forth from campus to Eden Prairie that involved four separate bus lines, two detours, an impromptu Culver’s run and a lost lighter. During this pandemonium, I couldn’t help but sort through the archives of old summer Spotify playlists, looking for an earworm to help warm the intervals I spent waiting between buses in single-digit temperatures.
Lo and behold my summer playlist from 2024, which might as well have been a beacon. Not to overly glaze my personal selection or taste, which was, and still is, pedestrian.
To pass the time, I listened to the entirety of Chappell Roan’s freshman album “The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess” as well as tracks here and there from Charli xcx’s famed “Brat” album, released less than a year later.
Roan’s album especially struck me. In hindsight, it amazed me that an openly lesbian pop star hailing from the Midwest could have had the universalized appeal that she did. Her blend of reverence for middle America and celebration of queer identity was remarkable in a time of transgender moral panic and fallout from “Don’t Say Gay” bills.
Her star rose right on the heels of President Donald Trump’s second term, no less. I remember opening my phone and seeing the hordes of crowdgoers attending Roan’s sets at various festivals, including Iowa-based Hinterland that summer.
Both years involved witnessing the re-emergence of music genres and the real-time rises of generational talents on the come-up.
Co-host of Radio K’s morning show “Rock and Roll Over,” Téo Lecoustre said 2016 in particular was a big year for hip-hop.
“It was just this turning point of the old guard kind of seceding and the new guard kind of coming forward,” Lecoustre said. “I think of Kendrick Lamar as the biggest example. We stopped seeing the prevalence of artists like Eminem and rappers who had held these really high cultural positions, and we started to see younger people taking their place.”
This extends to 2024 as well — far beyond Roan’s reach and appeal, but with a different genre. Mother Jones went as far as to crown pop music the Hero of 2024, thanks to releases from Sabrina Carpenter, Beyoncé, Charli xcx and of course Chappell Roan.
Juliet Murphy, a front desk worker at Radio K, said starpower in pop music influenced a lot of the soundscape behind summer 2024 in particular.
“I think it was a year really defined by the re-emergence of pop music,” Murphy said. “Especially the rise of like, the idea of a pop girl or a pop female artist kind of rising back into the scene.”
These genre-reviving musical acts coincided with their respective years’ social issues and hot-button topics.
Lamar’s album released in 2016, “untitled unmastered,” preceded a summer marked by Black Lives Matter protests after the murders of Philando Castile and Alton Sterling by police officers. The album deals heavily with Lamar’s racialized experience growing up in California. His album “To Pimp a Butterfly” also won a Grammy in February that same year.
As aforementioned, the queerness behind Roan’s appeal and drag persona was rebellious in an era where legal restrictions on drag performances were being passed. In 2023, a law was passed in Tennessee threatening to target these performances. Roan sang in “Pink Pony Club” about leaving the state by name.
These years were marked politically by Trump’s victories in their respective presidential elections as well. The president has a history of bringing out divisiveness and intentionally shocking the press in a routine and methodical manner.
Lecoustre said election years often foster interesting sonic innovations.
“There’s cultural booms, there’s cries for rallying,” Lecoustre said. “Music is a political tool to some extent or another, and using your music to empower people is especially important in times like that, no matter what side you’re on and no matter what you think about the other side’s music.”
Music is powerful, and so is culture. This is surprising to nobody.
This unity in pop culture, not despite but because of politics, seems to be the secret sauce behind such fervent nostalgia. I’m writing with the most profound heartsickness because just two years ago, we didn’t know what we had.
Good art that comes from a meaningful place has the potential to shape generations, as well as our perceptions and recollection of history. Our collective fixations on these years are indicative.
We should listen to our guts and turn the radio up.