
Both the good and the bad that fans have come to expect from controversial director, Emerald Fennel, went full-frontal in “Wuthering Heights” (2026).
Fennell’s third film, “Wuthering Heights” is a disgusting movie, or one that is absolutely moving, especially if the viewer happens to be 14. It has no sense of historical accuracy, cultural sensitivity, or faithfulness to its source material. Instead it has something else, something movies rarely have anymore: absolute earnestness.
The movie makes its plans to violate the original story known from the very first scene with Fennell’s own touch of perverse self-destruction. “Wuthering Heights” makes no attempt to be faithful to the novel it is based on. Instead, it dedicates itself to capturing the experience Fennell had reading it for the first time as a young teenager.
For fans of movies like “Twilight,” this is one of those rare blends of sincerity and camp that catches viewers off guard. For viewers who are fans of costume, incredible set design, and Charli XCX, “Wuthering Heights” has all they can ask for. For fans of the novel “Wuthering Heights,” this is not for you.
Just like Kathy and Heathcliff, the movie was doomed as soon as it began, and for good reason. Along with the movie’s announcement, Fennel revealed her insensitive decision to cast Heathcliff as the white actor, Jacob Elordi, only to follow up with a slough of unredeeming interviews — enough so that the controversy would overshadow the movie’s legacy alongside its release.
It is not the same kind of story that Emily Bronte made and, in theory, Fennell should be able to make any change she wants for her own adaptation, but the reality is she is adding this film to the existing problem of Hollywood’s ancient practice of whitewashing — one that had actually been broken by the 2011 adaptation featuring actor James Howson as Heathcliff.
Upon closer inspection, the decision seemed to be ignorant. She wanted Elordi to play Heathcliff because she cared more about having Elordi in a role she deeply fantasized about than she did about respecting the original story.
As that pertains to the relationship between the actor and director, Elordi’s characters have not been dehumanized by these scripts, and Elordi seems to be making a name for himself in these weird, hypersexual roles. But anything can, and will, happen in Hollywood.
For the version of the movie released, one where Heathcliff and Cathy are positioned as dog and owner, white Heathcliff is much more palatable. But still, why adapt a story where you have to change the race of the main character to make it work? People may even ask: why does this movie exist? For that, the answer seems to lie in Fennell’s own perversion.
The movie is unapologetically fetishistic, but not necessarily tasteless. The fetishistic tones and language lends itself to the psychological distortion that comes from repression and sexuality in a Gothic landscape, something that is often explored in new Gothic fiction such as “Nosferatu” (2024).
According to SparkNotes, the love shared by Cathy and Heathcliff is tragic, for neither of them can outgrow the past. Cathy, grieving her childhood, regresses to a time she remembers as safe between her and Heathcliff. The movie captures this specific aspect heartbreakingly well. It aligns closely with Fennell’s own flawed production and script choices, not being able to grow past her fourteen-year-old self’s experience with the novel. A loneliness permeates the screen whenever they are not on screen together, and a sense of incoming dread when they are.
Casting the two most significant characters aside from the leads as minorities is poor compensation for the white-washing one of the leads. However, the film delivered in a lot of unexpected ways that Fennell’s unapologetic style was able to achieve. A problem with many portrayals of characters of color in secondary roles, especially modern roles, are reduced for the sake of not depicting stereotypes. Non-white characters are often seen as unrecognized straight men, or are generally flaccid. This practice erases chances for non-white audiences to have characters they can hold onto. These decisions prioritize the comfort of white audiences while having the insidious quality of being harder to critique. In having the passive character of Edgar Lipton be played by Shazad Latif, it actually invents this problem for itself while already having committed the cardinal sin of Heathcliff Elordi.
However, Hong Chau, who plays Kathy’s servant, Nelly, is the unsung star of this film.
Robbie and Elordi’s overindulgent (but fitting) performances would have become unbearable if it was not for the refreshing ice-cold chill given by Chau’s performance. She dominates every scene she is in with an enigmatic vindictiveness that makes her next moves unpredictable but empathetic. She is the daunting voice of reason that is the antithesis to the indulgences the rest of the story takes.
Directors need to be less afraid of humiliating themselves in a world where online dialogue is attached to success. A director who is unafraid of making bad movies will always be appreciated by certain movie-goers. Film is Fennell’s freedom to make her shameless art, a quality that produces the most dynamic artists. It is what has the power to turn the passive experience of watching a movie into experiencing a confessional.
Those who want a movie like Fennell’s debut film, “Promising Young Woman”, will have mixed feelings. “Promising Young Woman” was clinical and heavy. “Wuthering Heights” is the levity in her career, one that allows herself to lean into the fantasies that “Promising Young Woman” and “Saltburn” rejected.
For all its political incorrectness, it is well-meaning and devoted to making the audience love Cathy and Heathcliff as much as Fennell does. It is a tender and frustrating ode to the stories that inspired teenage fanfiction careers.