
As Clint Bentley’s newest film, “Train Dreams,” was flung onto Netflix only a couple of weeks after only a short theatrical release, even many frequent moviegoers missed out on the Oscar nominee, and some did not even know it existed for a while. For a film that follows the entire life of its protagonist, it feels like the contrastingly abrupt move of the movie to Netflix highlighted how much the growth of streaming has killed the theater experience.
A quiet film that slipped through the cracks
Based on Denis Johnson’s acclaimed novella by the same title, “Train Dreams” traces the life of a logger and railroad laborer living in the rapidly changing American Northwest of the early twentieth century. It plays on the silences that grow even louder in a theater. Stephanie Zacharek of TIME Magazine describes it as “the kind of film where each blade of grass, each jagged tree branch, each mini ripple of a rushing river, seems to sing out as an individual,” yet one that artfully avoids feeling “overdone.”
The movie opens with the narrator laying out the life of the protagonist, Robert Granier (Joel Edgerton), how he lost his parents at a very young age and was never told how, how he never knew exactly when he was born, and how this set him up for a life of loneliness, living a large part of his early life as a hermit. Eventually, in this drifting state, he meets a young woman named Gladys Olding (Felicity Jones), and the two soon fall in love and have a daughter named Kate in their newly built cabin.
To afford this new life, he begins working as a laborer on railroads. However, after witnessing a Chinese worker, Fu Sheng (Alfred Hsing), being thrown from a bridge for no apparent reason by white workers on the site, he resolves to find new work, traumatized by the sight of such violence and wracked with guilt for not doing anything. He soon starts anew as a logger, stuck on long stretches of seasonal jobs that pull him further away from the family that he always wished to have.
In the course of his work, he remains largely detached from connections with his fellow laborers, aside from Arn Peeples (William H. Macy), an eccentric older man who brings some life to the otherwise lifeless work. As the movie goes on, we see how this work shapes him, his relationship with his family, how he deals with tragedy and loss, and how he manages to find fulfillment in moving forward no matter what hand life deals him.
Critics widely praised the film upon release. “Train Dreams” holds a 95 percent critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, with reviewers describing it as “haunting,” “meditative,” and “beautiful.” On Metacritic, the film earned a “universal acclaim” score, placing it among the most highly regarded films of the year.
Joel Edgerton’s performance, in particular, was singled out. Alissa Wilkinson of The New York Times praised how “he’s capable of doing so much with so little.” The restraint he shows in this role is impressive; his emotions only come to the forefront in short bursts. The wonderful scene where his good friend Ignatius Jack (Nathaniel Arcand) helps encourage him to keep moving forward, reminds us as viewers why this film in particular feels so ill-suited to a rushed, barely-advertised theatrical window.
A film made for theaters, reduced to a thumbnail
Despite its critical acclaim and the attention it has received during this year’s round of awards season (including nominations for Academy Awards for Best Picture and Edgerton for Best Actor), “Train Dreams” received only a very limited theatrical release, playing in select theaters for roughly two weeks, starting on Nov. 7, before debuting on Netflix on Nov. 21.
For many viewers, this window was effectively nonexistent. Moviegoers who were not actively tracking festival films or awards contenders, which the average person frankly does not have the time or energy to do, there was a strong chance it was never seen listed at your local theater at all. “Train Dreams” simply arrived quietly on Netflix, flattened into a single thumbnail image competing with dozens of true crime documentaries and old sitcoms.
Unfortunately, the way this brilliant movie was treated like just another piece of content for the streaming giant to monopolize on is part of a broader trend in which streaming platforms prioritize speed and accessibility over longevity in theaters. Due to decisions by the companies that hold power over these films, with no respect for what the creators intended, many films now receive theatrical runs simply to qualify for awards before quickly moving online, a practice that has become increasingly common since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Theatrical windows that once lasted months have, in many cases, shrunk to a matter of weeks — or even days — especially for films distributed by streaming services. While this model allows films to reach wider audiences faster, it also changes how audiences engage with them.
Streaming encourages passive viewing. Films are paused, resumed, half-watched while multitasking, or abandoned entirely. There is no obligation to sit with discomfort or slowness, while “Train Dreams” demands exactly that.
Why theatrical viewing still matters
Of course, the amazing visual quality and sound systems add a lot, but the commitment viewers are forced to give when sitting down in one of those seats is what makes it more worth it than anything. That ticket purchase is one that demands spectators give a film their full attention. In a theater, viewers cannot scroll. They cannot pause. They cannot leave without acknowledging that they are leaving, which forces them to immerse themselves in an entire world.
That commitment is essential for movies like “Train Dreams.” The story’s emotional weight builds slowly, almost imperceptibly, until moments of tragedy land with devastating force, moments that have weight that can easily be softened by the distractions of watching at home, but are unavoidable when moviegoers have signed the silent contract of sitting in a theater.
There is also a cultural cost to losing theatrical experiences. Films that never truly live in theaters rarely become communal reference points; they are consumed individually, talked about briefly online, and then buried under the next week’s releases. As streaming platforms continue to dominate distribution, quieter, more contemplative films like “Train Dreams” are especially vulnerable because they are not designed to “go viral” and avoid relying on simple twists or spectacle; rather, they focus on a specific mood, something theaters uniquely provide and amplify.
Choosing how to watch
“Train Dreams” is a reminder that meaningful cinema still exists, even as the spaces built to honor it disappear. Its critical success proves audiences and critics still value films that take risks, slow down, and trust viewers to sit with silence, but also how fragile the theatrical experience has become.
None of this is to say that streaming is the “enemy” and has ruined movies as a whole. It has done wonders in preserving many experiences that would otherwise be inaccessible. Many people even discover their favorite films from the comfort of their own homes. But even then, that convenience should not come at the cost of intentionality. When films like “Train Dreams” are rushed out of theaters, society is losing a shared cultural experience.
The death of the theater has not been sudden. It has been very, very quiet — one shorter theatrical run at a time — until films that deserve to be seen together will soon be watched only alone, if they are even noticed at all. “Train Dreams” deserved better, and if viewers care about the future of cinema, so do many films yet to come.