How much less is ‘less than lethal?’ Still dangerous, UMN researchers say

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

“Think about eating the hottest pepper you can imagine, but then you’re feeling that in your lungs, in your stomach,” Dr. Jennifer Brown, an attorney and doctor in neuroscience, said, describing what it feels like to be tear-gassed. “It’s not a perfect analogy, but hot peppers activate some of the same receptors that these crowd-control agents do.”

University of Minnesota researchers have shown concern about the lack of research on what is inside irritant canisters.

“It’s not a perfect analogy, but hot peppers activate some of the same receptors that these crowd-controlled agents do,” Brown said.

During Operation Metro Surge, the Twin Cities have absorbed months of tear gas plumes, pepper spray, rubber bullets and flash grenades chucked by federal agents. Minnesotans have voiced fear about long and short-term consequences of these seemingly ominous irritants, with a limited scope of research at hand.

Riot control agents such as tear gas were originally used as weapons to immobilize or even kill combatants, according to Brown’s literature review. Tear gas is banned in international warfare under the Chemical Weapons Convention, and many U.S. cities have restricted or banned it for protest use. 

Despite this, tear gas is a widely used domestic policing tactic.

There are four main types of riot control agents commonly used by federal agents: rubber bullets; OC, more commonly known as pepper spray; CS, also known as tear gas, and flash grenades. 

These “less-than-lethal” deterrents can still have immediate and significant bodily impacts.

On Jan. 14, a tear gas canister rolled under the car of a family caught in the crossfire of a Minneapolis protest. Because of the gas, the family’s 6-month-old infant experienced significant breathing difficulties and was brought to the hospital, alongside three other family members, CNN reported. 

In June, a police officer shot a protester in Los Angeles with a rubber bullet, shattering his testicle and requiring groin surgery from the impact of the bullet, according to KTLA5.

Even with recent protester injuries, regulation is still limited. The canisters have no ingredients listed.

Riot control agents are neither a food nor a drug, so agencies such as the FDA have no discretion over their production. They are, however, required to produce a Public Safety Data Sheet. 

Even then, the reporting on the contents of these agents is not reliable. Brown said there is no certainty whether the manufacturer is accurately reporting on these sheets.

“A lot of the information that they’re using for the SDS [Safety Data Sheet] is probably coming from either their own studies, which could be proprietary and not published or the existing peer review research, which is coming out of the late 1900s,” Brown said.

A common misconception arose after Gregory Bovino, former commander-at-large of the United States Border Patrol, and a troupe of federal agents appeared at Powderhorn Park and threw canisters emitting bright green smoke at the crowd of protesters. The gas’s hue drew accusations that agents were using HC, or Hexachloroethane, a controversial riot control method that has been rumored to be carcinogenic and cause long-term health effects.

However, the color of the smoke is not an indicator of what is in it, nor an indication that it is carcinogenic, Brown said. In fact, the use of HC has only been reported in Portland, according to Brown.

“These are military items,” Brown said. “The color of the smoke is usually a way to communicate information from far away.”

Rumors quickly spread that agents were now using this controversial agent to control protests, but Brown is not as sold on those claims. According to Brown, the canister itself is what is needed to know for certain. 

Still, once you have been hit with one of these agents, it is important to remove the chemicals from your body and clothes as best you can. If you feel symptoms the next day, go to the hospital, Brown said.

Once you have been hit with one of these agents, Brown said that splashing your orifices with milk should not be your go-to, contrary to widespread belief. The best antidote for pepper spray and tear gas is soap and water, but anything is better than nothing and the sooner, the better.

Minnesota Star Tribune reporter Susan Du recalled the behavioral push and pull of protester-law enforcement standoffs the day federal agents shot and killed Pretti. While agents seemed to hesitate from launching more canisters after a chunk of ice or a water bottle was thrown at the brigade, the agents’ rounds of fire were indiscriminate.

“Anytime that someone in the crowd did that [throw ice or water bottles], they would immediately take it as license to shoot into the crowd these chemical weapons and less lethal projectiles that would go back and forth,” Du said.

Du said the federal agent intended to scatter the crowd, but protesters stood their ground.

In her career, research specialist Madeline Peyton has sought to dig deeper into the effects of tear gas on women and children, after hearing anecdotal reports about people with uteri experiencing negative reproductive symptoms following exposure to tear gas. Even today, much current data on tear gas was mostly done in a military setting with healthy adult men in the 1950s and ‘70s, she said.

Following her studies, Peyton and her colleagues found that 83% of participants experienced at least one negative reproductive health outcome after tear gas exposure, such as early bleeding, breast tenderness and cramping. They also found that people who were exposed to tear gas more frequently experienced more negative health outcomes. 

Peyton felt the limited amount of information traced back to issues of a lack of diversity and representation.

“I think there should be a lot more transparency on the chemicals that are being used on civilians in this setting,” Peyton said. “I think it’s concerning that we don’t have a lot of information on what chemical agents are using and we don’t have a lot of information on the long-term health impacts in a diverse population.”

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/city/how-much-less-is-less-than-lethal-still-dangerous-umn-researchers-say/02/11/2026/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily