Opinion: The crackdown on Minneapolis is political retribution

Originally Posted on The Minnesota Daily via UWIRE

With everything that happened in the past few months, it’s not a stretch to say that Minneapolis and Minnesota are under siege. 

Tensions are running high as the Trump administration continues Operation Metro Surge, with a total of 3,000 agents from Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection now operating in the Minneapolis area. That’s about five times the number of officers in the city’s police department.

Two citizens were killed by federal agents in the streets of Minneapolis in just a few weeks, sending shockwaves through our communities. Protestors have been arrested, hotels have been vandalized and journalists have been pushed and sprayed with chemical irritants despite following the instructions of federal officers. 

Amidst the chaos, one question sticks out: Why is the federal government cracking down on Minnesota?

The initial surge began after national attention turned to fraud allegations in Minnesota’s welfare system, from the Feeding Our Future scandal to a viral video by Nick Shirley about alleged daycare fraud. 

Most of this attention originally centered around the Somali community. However, the vast majority of Somali Minnesotans are American citizens, with 87% of the foreign-born Somali Minnesotans having become naturalized citizens.

The fraud excuse for sending thousands of immigration enforcement officers here falls apart fairly quickly. While cases like the Feeding Our Future scandal involved serious instances of fraud, many of the claims from Shirley’s video were misleading, and the Trump administration’s claims about fraud have drastically overstated the amount defrauded.

The reasoning for the surge is further undermined by the fact that our state is home to just 1.1% of immigrants in the United States as of 2023, a fact that should put Minnesota further down on ICE’s priority list.

As we have not heard any rational explanation for sending additional immigration enforcement officers to Minnesota, we are forced to look for political explanations for the crackdown. 

We don’t need to look far to find them.

University of Minnesota political science lecturer Tim Collins said Gov. Tim Walz became a major target for retribution from President Donald Trump and his advisors due to fraud allegations, his connection with Trump’s opponent Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election and his efforts to support people of color in Minnesota. Walz’s withdrawal from the state gubernatorial race made him an even bigger target for the administration’s ire.

“The fact that [Walz] decided to drop out of the race, I think, made Trump feel like ‘Okay, now he’s weak and we can go after him,’” Collins said.

Even with a simple glance through Trump’s social media pages, it’s clear his fury toward Walz has not abated — even with the 2024 election season long since over. In his frequent attacks on the governor, Trump even promoted conspiracy theories that suggested Walz was behind the death of Speaker Emerita Melissa Hortman last summer.

Collins said a large part of the crackdown on Minnesota could also be due to the influence of Trump’s advisors, like Stephen Miller, who are in denial over any dissent or resistance to the administration’s policies, exemplified by protests in Minnesota.

“Miller really seems to be fully trying to exert whatever will he possibly can to make people fall in line and doesn’t really care about the parallels to previous authoritarian and dictatorial movements,” Collins said. “In his mind, it’s the protestors that are the bad ones.”

ICE agents’ actions against protestors illustrate a new level of federal targeting of perceived dissent, with two Minnesotans shot dead and dozens arrested in the first month of 2026. Locals and journalists who have attempted to follow ICE agents and observe their actions have been detained or hit with projectiles and chemical irritants.

University political science professor Tim Johnson, who specializes in legal and judicial politics, said while interfering with lawful detentions made by ICE is illegal, many of the moves made against protestors infringe on First Amendment rights.

“If I’m standing just with my phone, sign or whistle, or chanting or banging a drum or whatever it might be, then that is absolutely protected within the confines of the First Amendment’s freedom of speech clause,” Johnson said. “What we have seen is absolutely a violation of protestors’ or watchers’ constitutional rights.”

Journalists covering protests and detentions have also been increasingly targeted by ICE in the past few months. 

Johnson said while it’s hard to prevent journalists from being accidentally affected by things like tear gas, they have broad-based legal protections that federal officers have violated. 

“Very certainly there has been clear overstep on the part of the federal government in dealing with the press,” Johnson said.

These increasing escalations and civil rights violations on the part of federal officers bring the idea that law enforcement is the goal of the crackdown into question. Arresting protestors and assaulting journalists is not upholding the law, but trampling on it.

In reality, much of the motivation behind Operation Metro Surge is political, either to stoke fear in blue areas or coerce the government of a blue state to bend to the administration’s wishes.

According to Collins, Attorney General Pam Bondi’s demand that Walz and Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon turn over state voter rolls undermines the Trump administration’s justification for the increase in immigration enforcement officers in Minnesota.

“If all they want is voter rolls, then it’s clearly not about migrants or crime,” Collins said.

What is happening on our streets is horrific. For an administration that prides itself on restoring law and order, federal officers’ violations of Minnesotans’ civil rights and chaotic crowd control methods are nothing short of hypocritical.

Furthermore, the use of fraud to justify this atrocious crackdown is a pathetic strawman. If there is fraud, why not send in the FBI? Why send in immigration enforcement to handle other criminal issues?

Operation Metro Surge is not about law enforcement. It’s about political retribution on Walz and his supporters. Right before our eyes, ICE is quickly becoming the Trump administration’s most effective way to stoke fear and terror in areas that don’t side with its political agenda.

It is up to us to decide whether these tactics of fear and law enforcement weaponization will succeed or fail. We must demand greater accountability and action from our leaders before it is too late.

Read more here: https://mndaily.com/opinion/opinion-the-crackdown-on-minneapolis-is-political-retribution/02/02/2026/
Copyright 2026 The Minnesota Daily