United States District Court Judge Ann Aiken issued an injunction order Wednesday on a rule from the Department of Homeland Security that has resulted in at least two November arrests in the name of protecting federal property.
The case the injunction is based on was brought to the court by plaintiffs Chloe Longworth and Anna Lardner on Dec. 5. Longworth was arrested on Nov. 18 for protesting Immigration and Customs Enforcement action using a megaphone on a city-owned sidewalk near the Lane County Federal Courthouse, and Lardner was threatened with arrest for very similar activities a week later.
DHS’ rule, issued in June and effective this November, bans “creating a loud or unusual noise, noxious odor or other nuisance” not only in federal buildings but in the vicinity of the property.
According to Aiken’s order, the plaintiffs met the burden of proving that “irreparable harm” is likely caused by the DHS rule because of its limits on free speech.
“The Ninth Circuit has repeatedly held that ‘the loss of First Amendment freedoms, for even minimal periods of time, unquestionably constitutes irreparable injury,’” the order read.
Aiken concluded that “equities and the public interest” caused the case to weigh “sharply in favor” with the plaintiffs.
Aiken also said she issued the injunction because there was no evidence that it was necessary for the federal government to limit free speech on the sidewalk, and she took issue with the “vagueness” of the rule.
“Plaintiffs have made a compelling showing that [the] Unusual Noise provision has the unconstitutional effect of chilling speech through either vagueness, overbreadth, or both. Upholding free speech — a fundamental right — is of ‘significant public interest.’ Klein 584 F.3d at 120,” the order read.
Attorney Marianne Dugan, who helped represent Longworth and Lardner through the Civil Liberties Defense Center, said she was “very heartened” by the judge’s decision, which she saw as a win for freedom of speech.
“We’ve seen this kind of thing in other countries and what happens is that other people are very afraid to speak and it shuts down the public discourse and we don’t get to bring out the things the government is doing wrong; we don’t get to shine the light on the misbehavior of government employees,” Dugan said. “We all get less free.”
The current injunction lasts 14 days, and after it expires there is a possibility of a further undermining of the DHS rule, including a permanent injunction.
“This is just the beginning,” Dugan said.
The post Federal judge pauses ruling limiting “loud or unusual” speech near federal property appeared first on Daily Emerald.
