We want to believe our communities are safe, and we are all generally fighting for the mutual benefit of one another. But when that illusion fades, and it is revealed that members of our community are actually welcoming terrorism into our space, it is natural to feel defensive. We feel the impulse to “do something” that often manifests in “naming and shaming” the target of our disapproval.
These campaigns have a long history and can be effective — but only when used correctly. When we misuse this tool, we risk feeding into fascist social ideology.

The justification for these campaigns typically falls into two categories. The first is retribution — the belief that a person who causes extreme harm deserves to be harmed in return. While the yearning for vengeance is a profoundly human emotion, as an abolitionist materialist, I see it as an impulse we must move beyond. Justifying harm as a moral good creates a cycle of violence, causing more damage to the social fabric without addressing root causes.
The second, more salient, is social deterrence. This is the pragmatic argument: Publicly calling out bad behavior sets a societal marker, signaling what is unacceptable and, ideally, deterring others. The goal here isn’t revenge but strategic action for a better future. The logic is that by exposing cruelty, we raise awareness, build sympathy for our movements and cultivate a community where bigotry cannot thrive.
In theory, it’s a sound strategy. In practice, its success is inconsistent. The difference lies not in the severity of the transgression, but in the transgressor’s psychology and social position.
Naming and shaming is effective under one crucial condition — when the person has something to lose.
Consider the executive, the local politician or the community leader who espouses progressive values in public but harbors bigoted views or actions in private. For them, exposure is a direct threat. Their power and influence depends on a carefully constructed reputation.
A successful shaming campaign can dismantle that facade, leading to tangible consequences like a lost job, a revoked platform or a public reckoning. Here, social pressure acts as a powerful check, using the fear of ostracization to enforce community standards.
But this strategy becomes ineffective and counterproductive when aimed at “the attention grifter.”
For the pundit, the provocateur or the online “influencer” whose entire brand is built on performative bigotry, your outrage is their oxygen. Their names are public, and they have no shame. They are not hiding their ideology — they are monetizing it. Calling them a bigot is not an exposé, it’s free advertisement.
This feeds into fascist rhetoric around “cancel culture” and the left trying to “silence discourse.
These campaigns can materially benefit the grifters. Kyle Rittenhouse turned getting away with a triple homicide into a national speaking tour. Within academia, public figures like Bret Weinstein turned being forced to resign for his bigotry into a podcasting career.
Within the neo-Nazi social media sphere, being a “victim” of the “radical left” is the tinder for a successful career as a propagandist.
In reflection, these losers quite simply aren’t worth our time. White supremacist teenagers who cry themselves to sleep because romantic interests won’t talk to them are not worth our energy as rage. That energy could be used so much more productively towards making material change in our communities.
We must move beyond a one-size-fits-all approach to accountability.
Before launching a public campaign, we must determine if we are exposing a hidden hypocrisy or providing fuel for performance.
Further, we need to situate ourselves within our privilege and turn to impacted communities to understand what matters most to them. Wasting community synergy attacking an individual while people are desperate for volunteers and resources is the peak of performative outrage.
To build resilient communities and deliver our world from the grasp of fascism, we need to focus on bolstering mutual aid networks, organizing our workplaces, developing popular education materials and creating the structures of care and support that make our movements strong from the ground up.
Instead of raging against individuals who support racial cleansing in our communities, that energy could much more pragmatically be used towards investing in community aid organizations like LUCE, an immigration justice network or donating to GoFundMe campaigns — here’s one for the victims of the ICE raid in Allston.
We can and should also act by engaging in local politics and putting tangible pressure on our institutions to provide protections, like making BU a sanctuary campus.
Yes, public shaming has its place, but it is a small tool in a large toolbox. We need to be strategic enough to know when and how to use it.