Payoff Pitch: These outside-the-box offseason trade ideas might just make sense

The World Series has come and gone, and it’s time for an all-too-long winter of waiting for next year. But it’s a terrible time to stop paying attention to baseball.

Emma Clement

Free agency and offseason trades have only just begun. 

Here are three trade ideas that just might make sense for everyone involved.

The Detroit Tigers’ Tarik Skubal — who just won the American League Cy Young Award for the second consecutive year— has found himself at the epicenter of recent trade rumors. 

Despite his accolades, the Tigers may still trade Skubal. 2026 will be his final season before he hits free agency, and Jon Heyman of the New York Post reported in October that Skubal and his team were about $250 million apart in their ideas of what an extension would look like. 

If Skubal can’t return to Detroit long term, the team should trade him now.

The idea of a Skubal trade would be for a potential suitor to gain an advantage in extension negotiations with the star starter. Skubal’s possible landing spots are big-market teams with the financial ability to sign him long-term.

Bob Nightengale of USA Today wrote the Tigers would have to be “overwhelmed” by a Skubal trade package to let their Cy Young winner go. 

The San Francisco Giants could have an answer.

Bryce Eldridge is the Giants’ top prospect – a potential future franchise player. He’s a first baseman with 70-grade power potential, and could certainly headline a package for Skubal. Though he’s been touted as “untouchable” in trade talks, San Francisco general manager Zack Minasian hinted otherwise.

San Francisco would have financial room to extend Skubal. In 2024, the Giants pulled in the eighth-highest revenue among MLB teams and are right in the middle of the pack in terms of percentage of revenue spent on payroll. San Francisco has not hit the luxury tax threshold.

Eldridge remains a prospect with much to prove. If the Giants are confident they can extend Skubal, they should pull the trigger – especially with new acquisition Rafael Devers signed long term and playing first base.

The shocking acquisition of Devers from the Boston Red Sox proved Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey clearly isn’t afraid to make unexpected moves. 

Although trading a potentially franchise-defining prospect for a player on a one-year contract might seem to be folly, today’s baseball world is wackier than ever: the San Diego Padres traded baseball’s No. 3-overall prospect, Leo De Vries, for a reliever. 

That’s where the trade market is right now.

On the topic of former Red Sox third basemen, the Sox may need to find a replacement for 2025 All-Star Alex Bregman, who has opted out of his contract and will test free agency. Boston could approach the St. Louis Cardinals and inquire about Nolan Arenado.

Bregman will command a king’s ransom – one the Red Sox may want to spend elsewhere, given they’ve been linked to star free agents, first baseman Pete Alonso and National League MVP finalist and former Red Sox left fielder Kyle Schwarber.

Reuniting Arenado with his former Colorado Rockies teammate, shortstop Trevor Story, would be an exciting prospect. The two were the talk of the town at Coors Field, manning the left side of the infield together from 2016 to 2020.

The Sox could offer first baseman Triston Casas or outfielder and designated hitter Masataka Yoshida, one of whom will be on the move if the Sox get Alonso or Schwarber.

Cardinals president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom knows the Red Sox organization well — he led Boston’s baseball operations department from 2020 to 2023. Bloom drafted many of Boston’s current prospects, oversaw Casas’s development and debut, and signed Yoshida as an international free agent.

The Red Sox were one of five teams Arenado was reportedly willing to be traded to last offseason.

Back in Northern California, the Athletics have an elite young position player core led by outfielder Lawrence Butler, catcher Shea Langeliers, shortstop Jacob Wilson and first baseman and reigning AL Rookie of the Year Nick Kurtz, with the aforementioned shortstop De Vries on the way. 

The A’s can afford to trade from their area of strength in this deep offensive core. On the other hand, they desperately need help to supplement up-and-coming pitcher Luis Morales in the rotation: The A’s had the fourth-highest team earned run average in 2025 at 4.70.

The Tampa Bay Rays have the exact opposite problem. Starting pitcher Drew Rasmussen earned his first career All-Star appearance in 2025 and went on to pitch to a 2.76 earned run average in 150 innings, but Tampa Bay’s outfield hit a shockingly low 29 combined home runs.

Perhaps the A’s could interest their Eastern small-market counterpart in Tyler Soderstrom, who posted 4.3 wins above replacement and hit 25 home runs this season while playing over 100 games in the outfield.

Rasmussen will be a free agent relatively soon, and the contract he’ll sign may be more than the low-spending Rays can muster up. On the other hand, Soderstrom is young, under team control and quite cheap.

Tampa Bay’s top-10 farm system could help it sweeten the pot for the A’s.

The A’s and Rays are seldom in the national spotlight, but trading these players could shake up the offseason in a big way.

Expect none of this to come to fruition. But if it does, you heard it here first.

Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/11/18/21/216469/payoff-pitch-these-outside-the-box-offseason-trade-ideas-might-just-make-sense/
Copyright 2026