The University of Minnesota’s Twin Cities chapter of the American Association of University Professors released a statement on Sept. 30 regarding concerns of academic freedom surrounding a resolution from the Board of Regents, which limits institutional statements that was adopted on March 14.
According to the Board’s docket materials, the resolution said some public concern statements could affect the University’s mission.
“The board shares the task force’s recognition that statements on matters of public concern carry risks that could undermine the University’s mission and its dedication to an inclusive climate and community,” the resolution read.
William Jones, the president of the University’s AAUP chapter, said he’s seen universities facing the impacts of academic freedom from the Trump administration as faculty members get terminated.
“We’re seeing attacks on academic freedom coming from the White House and from state legislators,” Jones said. “Faculty are being fired for their teaching and their research.”
Jones said he hopes to see the University’s administration issue a statement to support academic freedom, as it is important for the University to maintain itself even with the controversies surrounding it.
“I would like to see the administration make an affirmative statement of their support for academic freedom and for shared governance,” Jones said. “And an understanding that those two are really critical to the ability of the Universities to just thrive and to survive these attacks.”
The AAUP statement said as the resolution limits institutional statements, it also includes removal of statements on departmental websites and the cancellation of events on campus.
“That pattern includes administrators removing statements from websites of academic departments and centers on issues related to their scholarly expertise, pressuring departments and centers to cancel lectures and other public events on issues,” The AAUP statement read.
According to Jones, the AAUP has written many letters requesting the board not to pass the resolution, and they released their September statement due to the effects of the resolution and faculty members’ concerns about the resolution.
Jane Kirtley, a media law professor at the University, said she is upset with the existence of the Board of Regents’ resolution as it has issues, such as not including details of how the University community is going to be affected when it comes to their speech.
“I’m bothered by simply the existence of the policy, but I think the other problem with it is that it’s not very clear exactly what kind of speech or scholarly activities or events would be affected by this policy,” Kirtley said.
While it is within reason to talk about whether the University should limit academic speech, it is unlikely for regents to actually make the resolution, Kirtley said.
“There’s reasonable room to debate about whether a University as a whole should be issuing institutional statements on matters of current interests but which do not directly affect the University,” Kirtley said. “Reasonable people can differ on that, but it’s very different for somebody like the Regents of the University of Minnesota to adopt that on their own.”
Carrie Walling, director of the Human Rights Program at the University, said that the administration has been restricting speech that could be seen as problematic.
“The University of Minnesota seems to be kind of caught up in this trend of trying to limit what could be interpreted as politically controversial speech coming from members of the University,” Walling said.
Walling said she urges the regents to remove the resolution, as it goes against the University’s civil duties.
“My first desire would be to see them retract this resolution so that they should just end it,” Walling said. “Because I believe that trying to mandate neutrality chills the freedom of speech and is inconsistent with a University’s responsibility toward intellectual freedom, critical thinking and enhanced debate.”