Judge Orders Utah To Redraw Congressional Maps

 

On Aug. 25, Utah State Judge Dianna Gibson ordered the Legislature to redraw Utah’s congressional districts to comply with the Better Boundaries Initiative.

The initiative, created by citizens to end gerrymandering and ensure fair boundary lines, was approved by voters as Proposition 4 in 2018. Gibson’s ruling applies only to Utah’s four congressional districts, not to legislative or school board maps.

What does the decision mean?

Matthew Burbank, a University of Utah political science professor, said the Legislature overrode the independent redistricting commission created by the ballot initiative.

“A ballot initiative has passed that created this independent redistricting commission; they would do maps and give them to the legislature,” Burbank said. “The redistricting commission went through this process, gave them maps and the state legislature essentially ignored them.” 

Judge Gibson’s ruling bars the use of Utah’s current congressional maps in future elections. Lawmakers need to draw new districts by Sept. 24, and those maps must comply with Proposition 4, the Better Boundaries initiative.

“To permit the 2021 Congressional Plan to remain in place would reward the very constitutional violation this Court has already identified and would nullify the people’s 2018 redistricting reform that they passed through Proposition 4,” Judge Gibson wrote in her decision. 

Public opinion

Judge Gibson’s decision has drawn pushback. Sen. Daniel McCay wrote on X the evening of the ruling that it ignored language in Utah’s Constitution, arguing the power to draw districts rests with the Legislature. 

However, Burbank explained that the under the Better Boundaries Initiative, Utah’s current congressional maps are drawn largely in favor toward the Republican seats. 

“The president, in particular, is criticizing this decision and he’s criticizing it without knowing a single thing about it,” Burbank said. “That then leaves Republicans feel like they’re going to have to defend those maps, because that’s what the president wants, as opposed to adapting a new set of maps and still having a good chance at winning four seats.”

Salt Lake County mayor Jenny Wilson supported Gibson’s ruling, saying that politicians need to “play by the rules.”

“Rigging the game so you never lose isn’t fair — and now, after years of legal challenges, it is clear to everyone that it is also decidedly against the rules,” Wilson said in a press conference. “This decision is a strong signal that the people’s voice cannot be brushed aside. Utahns spoke loudly when they passed Proposition 4, and the court recognized the weight of that decision today.”

What this means for the U

Juliet Carlisle, a professor in the Department of Political Science, explained gerrymandering’s impact on students at the U. “If Salt Lake City and the U are kept together in a single district, students may gain a more collective voice in Congress,” she said.

Carlisle said issues students are passionate about — such as affordable housing, climate and university funding — could gain more traction with more fair maps.

“We’d see better responsiveness to a group of voters who are currently underrepresented,” she said. 

Burbank told The Chronicle that redistricting is unlikely to dramatically change Utah politics. While Democrats are not guaranteed a seat, he said the maps could create more competitive races for both parties.

 

t.sorensen@dailyutahchronicle.com

@teannajsorensen.bsky.social

The post Judge Orders Utah To Redraw Congressional Maps first appeared on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2025/09/04/judge-orders-utah-to-redraw-congressional-maps/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=judge-orders-utah-to-redraw-congressional-maps
Copyright 2026