The internet is a fun and confusing place.
In 2024, around 68% of the world’s population logged onto this enormous network of online content, communication and chaos, uniting the globe in ways only dreamt about before the World Wide Web’s inception in 1989.
Although it changed a lot over its three decades of existence, one of the internet’s most unique features has stayed remarkably prevalent: The ability to be anonymous.
Hiding your identity behind a screen, a username or a profile is a hallmark of interacting on the internet. While this provides security from being exposed or doxxed, it also changes the social dynamic online.
University of Minnesota professor at the Institute of Child Development, Gail Ferguson, said internet anonymity provides both valuable opportunities for support and dangerous risks for social behavior.
“Social psychologists have demonstrated experimentally that people are less inhibited when they’re anonymous, both in person but also online,” Ferguson said. “They can be more rude, more aggressive and also probably less likely to help if someone needs help because of the diffusion of responsibility.”
Hate comments, insults and even slurs are unfortunately commonplace in most corners of the internet. The idea that internet users will not face any consequences because of their anonymity only fuels this hatred.
Even here on the Minnesota Daily’s website, journalists receive comments readers likely would not make in person.
Assistant professor at theHubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication, Ruth DeFoster, said internet anonymity has negatively affected how we speak online, especially within civil and political discourse.
“If you look at platforms that don’t require real names, most notably I’m thinking of Twitter and Reddit, those are often some of the worst cesspools of the internet in terms of the cruelty with which people are willing to treat each other,” DeFoster said.
When comparing these social media sites to the comment sections of media organizations requiring full names to comment, such as MinnPost, the effects of internet anonymity on people’s behavior become evident, according to DeFoster.
As the setup of the internet allows you to take limited responsibility, you may feel protected from the consequences of your actions. However, if your real identity is revealed after you indulge in this anonymity, the consequences can be life-ruining.
“We have this landscape where there’s very little accountability because you’re not putting your name to what you’re saying, and so there are a lot more avenues for cruelty and no consequences for your behavior,” DeFoster said. “There is also a sort of hyperaccountability sometimes on the internet, where we all turn on someone with such unanimity that it becomes a pop culture story.”
DeFoster said this tendency to aggressively expose or criticize people explains the online reactions to Astronomer CEO Andy Byron’s extramarital affair being revealed at a Coldplay concert.
With this culture of both no consequences and relentless online vigilantes, the internet poses even greater risks to the generations who grew up as it was booming, particularly Generation Z and Generation Alpha.
In a 2022 survey, almost half of teens reported being cyberbullied in one way or another. As internet and social media use grows, that fraction will likely grow as well, reflecting the need for increased awareness of how younger generations use and perceive the internet.
Ferguson said younger generations like Gen Z have become accustomed to the internet’s unique culture and social protocol so much that it is almost their first culture, influencing how they speak and socialize in the real world.
“There are all of these rules as well because it’s a real culture,” Ferguson said. “Culture just means a way of life, a way of being, usually having to do with a group.”
This proximity to internet culture, which was further baked into younger generations after many turned to social media for support during the COVID-19 pandemic, comes with dangers and benefits.
Ferguson said, despite its drawbacks, the internet and the anonymity that comes with it can give adolescents the ability to explore unique facets of their identities that otherwise may be neglected or unexpressed due to real-life circumstances.
“Let’s say you’re in a rural town, and you identify with a certain group that’s not well-represented in your town,” Ferguson said. “You can connect to other people who have that identification online and express some of those values.”
Internet anonymity may allow you to be crueler than you would be in the real world. But it can also allow you to be your more authentic self, protecting you from judgment or criticism you may have received if you tried to express yourself in real life.
While some of the risks of the internet are greater than the rewards due to the internet’s accessibility, resources like media literacy training and exposure to more professional socialization methods go a long way toward mitigating those risks, according to Ferguson.
“Societally and historically, there always tends to be a big concern about the ruination of youth because of the development of a new type of media,” Ferguson said. “So I think we can learn from history and not freak out. There will be risks and opportunities, but we can manage them.”
Increased access to anonymity may be a big developmental hurdle for younger generations, but it’s not an insurmountable one.
The internet is a powerful tool, and as long as we remember there are actual people behind the screens, we can harness its potential without giving in to the temptation to harm one another.