Sterilization rates among young adults in the United States have increased in recent years as abortion restrictions and access to contraception have become limited in post-Dobbs v. Jackson America.
Following the Supreme Court’s ruling, which eliminated the constitutional right to abortion, studies have shown adults ages 19-26 have sought out permanent contraception at higher rates since 2022, the year the ruling was decided.
What the data tells us
Physicians are seeing increased interest in permanent contraceptives such as vasectomies and tubal sterilizations, according to recent research published by Health Affairs, a health policy journal.
Researchers from George Washington University, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the University of Michigan found visits for both vasectomies and tubal sterilizations were higher in states likely to ban abortion among adults ages 19-26, according to data from 2021 and 2022.
Young adults living in states with a Republican majority were more likely to pursue permanent contraception than young adults living in Democrat leaning states, according to the study.
University of Minnesota professor and urologist Dr. Joshua Bodie said that while the number of vasectomies he can perform in a week is capped, which limits him from seeing an uptick in performed vasectomies, he agreed that there is “more demand and discussion” around vasectomies.
An OB-GYN and University associate professor, Dr. Jessika Ralph, said her patients have vocalized more interest around permanent contraception.
“I would say anecdotally that we’ve had more requests,” Ralph said. “I would say more requests from people who have never been pregnant and do not desire to ever be pregnant.”
Vasectomy procedures increased by 30% nationally in 2022 from July through September compared to the same period of time in 2021, according to research by Komodo Health. In states with restrictive abortion trigger laws, designed to ban or severely restrict abortions following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, vasectomies increased by 39%.
Tubal ligation procedures, where the fallopian tubes are blocked, clipped or removed, rose by 3% per month in states with abortion bans from July to December 2022, according to a JAMA Network study.
Barriers to sterilization
Younger adults are commonly discouraged from sterilization procedures from their healthcare providers and for financial reasons, according to Health Affairs.
Vasectomies can cost up to $1,000, and tubal ligations can cost up to $6,000 in Minnesota, according to Planned Parenthood.
Almost all state Medicaid policies do not cover sterilization for patients who are younger than 21, according to the National Library of Medicine.
Melissa Saftner, director of the Nurse Midwifery Program at the University School of Nursing, said she experienced healthcare professionals reluctant to offer the procedures.
“When I first started practicing as a midwife, there was still this hesitation with my physician colleagues to offer sterilization to young patients,” Saftner said. “I think now physicians are more open to providing that care because they recognize bodily autonomy and legal policies.”
Ralph also said she heard similar feedback from her own patients. Patients sought out OB-GYN care at the University because other physicians refused the same care, according to Ralph.
Doctors have used the possibility of sterilization reversal to discourage young patients from pursuing permanent contraception procedures, according to the research published by Health Affairs.
On average, only 6% of men who undergo a vasectomy seek a reversal, according to a study published by Springer Nature Link.
The interest in tubal ligation is higher compared to vasectomies, according to the research published by Health Affairs.
Tubal ligations are similarly performed at higher rates compared to vasectomies, despite vasectomies being considered “cheaper, less invasive, and lower-risk” procedures, according to the article published by Health Affairs.
Jennifer Gunn, associate professor in the History of Medicine program at the University, said this may be because women feel more responsibility when it comes to contraceptive use, and cultural fears from men surrounding vasectomies.
“Ultimately, the costs of childbearing are disproportionately borne by women, the risks for women are greater and the risks of childbearing and unwanted childbearing are greater for women,” Gunn said. “Women taking responsibility for this has always been a part of contraception, even when there were not reliable contraceptive methods.”
The future for contraceptives
The rise in interest in sterilization stems from the fear of further rights being taken away, even in blue states like Minnesota, according to Health Affairs.
Ralph said she heard a significant number of patient concerns around the time of the Dobbs decision regarding contraception access.
“We had many patients express that anxiety and say, ‘Do I consider a permanent procedure?’” Ralph said. “Because we may not have anything available to us in the future.”
Saftner said the Dobbs v. Jackson decision is eye-opening for many young adults when it comes to their reproductive health.
“It’s persuading people to make decisions that they might not have otherwise made,” Saftner said. “Maybe before they would have gone with something like an IUD or just pills, but they were concerned that if they were to get unintentionally pregnant, they wouldn’t have any choices.”
Gunn said anxieties about insurance coverage for all contraceptives could contribute to this.
“I wouldn’t necessarily say that people in states where abortion is still legal, actually, don’t worry about it,” Gunn said. “Given the current politics that everybody worries about a national ban or increasing access through things like lack of insurance like changes in insurance coverage for various kinds of procedures.”