BG Alumna Joyce deserves your support

By Sean Shapiro

No doubt we were robbed of history.

With two outs in the bottom of the ninth, Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galaragga only needed to retire one more Cleveland Indian to complete the 21st perfect game in Major League history and an unprecedented third perfect game this year.

The grounder to first was cleanly fielded and replays show Galaragga beat the runner to the bag. This should have led to a celebration that Tigers fans haven’t witnessed since Magglio Ordonnez’s home run sent them to the World Series, but it didn’t.

First base umpire Jim Joyce, a 1977 BG graduate, emphatically signaled safe, leading to an outcry from all those in attendance and the social networking world where almost everyone who cares (and a lot of those who don’t) about baseball had something to say via Facebook or Twitter.

On a night when Galaragga was perfect, Joyce wasn’t.

But, you can’t fault the man for being human.

We’ve all made mistakes and we’ve all made regrettable decisions. Unfortunately for Joyce, his mistake was made on the largest stage.

After the game, Joyce was visibly shaken and he apologized for the botched call, and it would have even been understandable if he had asked to get the next day off.

But he didn’t and the next day we witnessed healing when Galaragga presented the lineup card to Joyce and the two embraced while tears streamed down the umpire’s face.

We’ll never know whether or not Galaragga truly forgave Joyce, but either way, the umpire deserves our support.

You should support Joyce since one mistake shouldn’t define the career of an umpire who has done a consistent job ever since he entered the Major Leagues.

Or you should support Joyce since he shares a common bond with many of you as a resident of Northwest Ohio, or as a Bowling Green Falcon.

Or you simply should feel sympathy for a man who doesn’t deserve to have the rest of his life defined by a split second decision that very few people ever have to make at that speed.

So he missed one. Who hasn’t?

You can feel angry, sad, upset or whatever other feeling you have right now, but at the end of the day, it was just a baseball game.

Yes we were robbed of history, but one bad call shouldn’t rob Jim Joyce of his future.

Read more here: http://bgnews.com/sports/bg-alumna-joyce-deserves-your-support/
Copyright 2026 The BG News