Making Models Matter

Originally Posted on The Yale Herald - Medium via UWIRE

During spring break of 1967, while most Yale students returned home or chased warmth down south, 30 first-year Yale Architecture students arrived in New Zion, Kentucky. In their bags were design plans for a community center, to be built on half an acre of land owned by local families. With no subcontractors in sight, the students got down to hand-digging the septic field and foundations, installing the plumbing, and putting up the walls. At night, they went back to the homes of New Zion families, who hosted and fed them. Only eight weeks later, their final design would feature a multi-purpose room, overlooked by a partial second floor where a library, meeting room, and other functional spaces basked in bright light from clerestory and ceiling windows. This marked the beginning of the Yale Building project, and it was nothing short from revolutionary.

The Yale Building project was launched by Charles Moore, then the Dean of the Yale School of Architecture (YSoA). Described by critic Martin Filler as “the most influential architecture professor of his generation,” Moore believed in pushing students out of their studios, and into the field. Moore and fellow YSoA professor Kent Bloomer, YC ’59, ART ’61, co-wrote in the school’s Bulletin in 1967, that the architecture student must “start from the beginning, to see things and to understand the processes that give them their shape.” This teaching method clashed with the prevailing pedagogy of the time, that of l’École des Beaux-Arts, in which students drew plans of prestigious buildings such as museums or grandiose justice halls — often times never to be realized. Not only did it break with tradition for its hands-on approach, but it also kicked down the barrier between high architecture and structures considered “simple” such as standard homes. (In a review of the Beaux-Arts program, historian Donald Drew Egbert observed that “programs of buildings for commoners have been extremely rare.”) So while previous YSoA deans had already begun to move away from the classical model of teaching, Moore harnessed his students’ desire for social betterment with a sense of vigor and urgency. Together, they would unleash an architectural coup d’état. For as the 1960s neared a close, students would no longer draw up government buildings or central squares. Instead, they would drive down to a poor, rural Appalachian town, and get to work.

Turner Brooks, PC ’65, ARC ’70, now an adjunct professor at YSoA, was one of the students who participated in the New Zion project. “We were a class of overly preppy characters coming to the prestigious Yale architecture school,” he recalls. But after Moore and Bloomer grew “impatient with fancy architecture” and shook up the curriculum, the students responded with wholehearted enthusiasm. In fact, it was the students who found the site, and organized the entire New Zion project, fueled by the desire for social justice that Turner reminds took the nation by storm in the 1960s. The students wanted their buildings to matter — in Moore’s words, to “change the lives of people who used [them]” — and more importantly, they wanted the buildings to be made strictly for those in need.

Yale Building Project, New Zion, Kentucky, 1967. (Credit: James Righter)

On Oct. 15, 2018 at an open showcase, the Yale Building Project — since renamed the Jim Vlock Building Project — unveiled its 51st iteration: a two-unit house at 43 Button Street, in New Haven. The house is built on land owned by Columbus House, a non-profit which helps the homeless find shelter or independent housing. The design was conceived by one of the many six-person teams of first-year Architecture students, randomly assigned to each other in a way that equally distributes skill sets. After the students had worked on their team designs for two months, a single winner was chosen, at which point the design left the hands of the six team members, and became the entire class’s joint project. And as the rest of Yale students packed away for summer holiday and the heat waves began, all the architecture first-years put on their hard hats and headed to the construction site.

The home that now sits at 43 Button Street, although traditional in shape, is modern and sleek. Large black-framed windows adorn a grey façade surrounded by rows of ashen shrubs. Inside, the two-units are interlocked but separated: while the tenants can tell that another apartment lies on the other side of the wall, they never have to directly interact, as two different front doors provide access to the units from the backyard and side yard. The separation is made out of cross-laminated timber (CLT), a new material increasingly being used in high rises. “It’s so heavy,” team member Emily Cass, ARC ’20, explains, “so our idea was to make a CLT wall right down the middle of the house.” One panel of CLT weighs approximately 2,000 pounds, making its thermal performance and sound isolation highly effective.

When asked whether sustainability was a concern in the project’s design, the students explained that most of their materials are donated. “We take what we can get,” Cass joked. “But we do look at the material for how far it has traveled, or for its environmental cost.” The Jim Vlock Building Program director, Adam Hopfner, ARC ’99, elaborated that since the construction budget is provided by Columbus House, which works on thin margins to begin with, the students commit to meeting that exact budget. But despite operating within the constraints of little money and little time, the building team is keen to achieve sustainability wherever they can. “We talk a lot about embodied energy of materials themselves,” Hopfner commented, “which means considering the full life cycle of the materials used, like the carbon release that wood sequestration may cause, or the energy associated with the extraction of cement.”

If the embodied energy of the materials is important, the manifested energy of the dwelling is paramount: and designing a house for tenants who have experienced homelessness engenders a specific set of considerations. Before starting anything, Hopfner explained, students sat down with the clients of Columbus House to hear their concerns, aspirations, and desires. In these exchanges, two desires were most commonly expressed. The first was the wish for safety and privacy. The second was the desire not to be separated from the larger community. It was imperative that these seemingly contradictory desires, which emanate from fears of vulnerability and isolation, be incorporated into the very bones of the structure. “This was the fundamental problem that students had to reconcile,” Hopfner says.

The team’s design therefore featured limited window glazing, for the inside of the house not to be very visible from the outside. A heavy CLT wall and two separate entryways ensured that private space was prioritized, and shared space minimized. As for integrating the home into its neighborhood, sight lines were crucial. “Houses in that area are lifted four feet due to frost,” Cass explained, “so we elevated the landscape to give the building the same floor line as other houses.” In the same vein, the students used a structure to make sure that the roof hit the same height as other houses.

Open House at the completed Button Street house. (Credit: Tanay Warerkar)

The house at 43 Button Street is located in The Hill, New Haven’s southernmost neighborhood, which despite being only 1.5 miles away from Yale’s campus, had a poverty rate that exceeded 40 percent in 2012 as reported by the New Haven Register. Hopfner remarks: “the neighborhoods we build in tend to be culturally very rich, and economically very poor.” There is thus an inherent potential for tension on site, as Ivy Leaguers descending upon a disadvantaged neighborhood may be perceived as completing a perfunctory act of charity.

The team members are aware of this possibility for friction, and endeavor to make the project a collaboration rather than a donation. Students contact community organizations ahead of time to acquire their opinions as to how the structure should be integrated into its surroundings. They also work with administrators and teachers at local schools to develop small pieces of the art curriculum, working on activities like charrettes (collaborative solving of design problems) with young children. Afterwards, the students will often bring the kids along to see the construction site. And while work days are long and intense, cookouts provide breaks where students and neighbors can meet.

Building Project Site at 43 Button Street, New Haven, 2018.

Ultimately, though, it is the hard work of the students that makes the difference. “We don’t come into the neighborhood with Boola Boola flags waving and a save-the-day attitude,” Hopfner explained. “We put our heads down and get straight to digging, and often times, students acquire a certain respect for their hard work.” Hopfner himself, having been involved with the program for 15 years, has met a number of close friends through it, whether it be neighbors or former clients. In his opinion, “everybody comes in with preconceptions, some about the students, and some made by the students. These tend to quickly disappear.” In 1968, Charles Moore suggested the reason why the New Zion families had been happy to inaugurate their new community center, despite its unusual modernity: “because it was built by people [they] liked and enjoyed having amongst themselves.” Since its inception and still today, the Project doesn’t stop at building houses: it always tries to build relationships.

The Building Project moved away from Appalachia to Connecticut in the 1980s due to reduced budgets. Back in the vicinity of New Haven, students took on structures like local beach pavilions, concert stages, and camp facilities. The 1967 founding ideal of serving those in need, although never out of mind, was put on the backburner. But in 1989, Habitat for Humanity approached program director Paul Brouard, ARC ’61, suggesting that the students get involved with the housing stock in New Haven itself. Thus, the Building Project refocused its efforts to the city of New Haven, and its emphasis shifted from public structures to affordable housing.

Today, the Project continues to evolve. In 2017, a five-year collaboration with Columbus House was launched, a move which Hopfner believes has re-invigorated the way in which the students engage with social issues. “Working to address a fundamental need within this city, homelessness in particular, has brought the students back to the very roots of the project” he said. He added that it pushes them to ask the questions of “What is shelter? What is housing? What is architecture?” The Building Project, despite changing over the years, still considers the same theoretical underpinnings that motivated its inception.

Hopfner cautions that there are ways to go. “This is a drop in the bucket,” he reminds. “We are not solving the problem by building one two-family house a year.” At the same time, he recognizes that the Building Project has raised the level of consciousness within the architectural community. Team member Christine Pan, ARC ’20, echoes this opinion, explaining that there now exists a discussion about the agency that architects can have, not only in the realm of building, but in social and political realms as well. Pan remarked: “working in New Haven with specific clients like Columbus House shifts the focus from the Building Project as an act of ‘charity’, to an act of responsibility.” While in 1967, the students who arrived in New Zion were trailblazers, fired up by an unprecedented and anti-establishment drive for action, today in 2018, initiatives like the Building Project do not surprise anybody. Perhaps this is the legacy of the Project: making social action in the School of Architecture more than just a model, but rather, a norm.


Making Models Matter was originally published in The Yale Herald on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.

Read more here: https://yaleherald.com/making-models-matter-3f62284bd330?source=rss----c10413cdfba9---4
Copyright 2026 The Yale Herald - Medium