
The shop is easy to navigate, but there isn’t much to look at if you aren’t willing to get involved — and that means running, rifling, digging through the thousands of records that fill the stands and boxes. This is clearly by design: the two wide aisles invite customers to slowly amble through, and while the walls feature a spacious array of flashy posters and collectors’ records, they’re not the main event. To get a sense for the range and vibrancy of what you can find here, you have to delve.
Elm City Sounds opened its flagship store in Westville in August, and it’s already attracted an unexpected number of casual walk-ins — customers who aren’t collectors or experts, or even necessarily music buffs, but just dabbling. Chris Della Ragione, the shop’s owner, likes it that way. The shop sells “regular good music,” he says affectionately. “Marvin Gaye, Billie Holliday, Dylan, everyone loves that. Before I opened the shop, I was selling really rare [records].” He points to the records on the wall: Abdullah Ibrahim, Prince, and a slew of albums I’ve never heard of. He used to deal in “sample-based hip-hop, and crazy collector jazz, funk, soul, reggae… This was more on an international basis, because I would sell on eBay, and I would sell online to collectors.” Chris wipes down a record from the small stack in front of him while he’s explaining, and then he carefully tucks it back in its paper sleeve. You can’t call him a dabbler — but in the shop, he’s managed to foster eclecticism, without the snobbery.
And Elm City Sounds isn’t alone. As record sales have steadily increased in the U.S., writes Marc Hogan of Pitchfork Magazine, “vinyl’s comeback is no longer a quirky, look-at-those-hipsters novelty. Instead, the bustling ecosystem of turntables and records is surprisingly close to being mainstream.” That resurgence did start as a niche, though. Sales have been on the rise since as early as 2007, but most of New Haven’s record shops didn’t manage to ride out the wave.
The most notable of these was Cutler’s, a family business on Broadway, right by Yale, that opened in 1948 and was a cultural hub until its closing in 2012. “It was definitely the record store in New Haven,” Chris reflects. Dooley-O, a longtime New Haven DJ, record collector, and artist whom Chris describes as “one of New Haven’s favorite sons,” emphasizes that there were other good record shops at the time, such as Rhymes Records and Replay (which still exists, in Hamden), but the closing of Cutler’s was “a stake in the heart.” Cutler’s was not New Haven’s only record shop, but it was the longest standing. Yale University — more specifically, Yale University Properties, which was founded in only 1996 as part of Yale’s Office of New Haven and State Affairs — owns that entire block, and had been the shop’s landlord for years. According to a 2012 article in the New Haven Register, Cutler’s was not forced out of its space, but its story nevertheless resonates with Yale’s active transformation of the Broadway area over the past two decades.
Cutler’s had “a great selection,” Dooley remembers. “They normally handpicked their stuff, so you wouldn’t just go in there and get a bunch of Michael Jackson, but you would get a bunch local bands — they supported the community [and] artists in the community a lot.” That’s a tradition that Chris hopes will be able to thrive at Elm City Sounds, and he’s “grateful to be picking up the reins.”
But Chris isn’t surprised that Cutler’s closed when they did, and says he understands the motives of Phil Cutler, the last owner. “He probably felt the trajectory of the industry going down, and it was a dark scary down, like a tunnel. Nobody knew what was going on down there, and nobody knew a path out — and that goes for record stores and record labels.” For the whole of the 20th century, pressed vinyl had been at the heart of music consumption in the U.S. and beyond. Keith Richards and Mick Jagger, two estranged childhood friends waiting for the train in Dartford Station, reconnected because Jagger was carrying two records under his arm: Chuck Berry’s Rockin’ at the Hops, and The Best of Muddy Waters. Richards writes in his autobiography Life that he knew of the Muddy Waters record but had never heard it, and some recorded music was much harder to come by then. Finding and sharing new music had to be a social affair. That was the occasion that led to Keith and Mick’s musical collaboration, and eventual worldwide fame.
CDs came into play in the early 1980s, and they caught on, but the ease of CD collecting still paled in comparison to the quality of analog sound. The distribution platforms enabled by the internet were a new beast, though. The vinyl industry began plummeting in the late ’90s. “Most [record shops] disappeared,” says Chris, “[in] the early 2000’s to 2012. There were not many places left.” In the midst of immense technological and cultural upheaval, the stores where young Micks and Keiths might have bonded over shared tastes were going fast, even in cultural hubs like New York City. Because digital music didn’t need to take up physical space, record shops couldn’t afford to take it up either. “All of a sudden everything just went away, within a decade, which is really drastic when you think about,” Chris observes. They’d been so culturally important for so long, and then “the landscape completely changed. So I think the resurgence of records is a pushback to that.” The vinyl industry still hasn’t recovered, but it’s beginning to.
Even when the record industry was floundering, though, there were niches of collectors and DJs that kept the culture going — particularly in New Haven, where rappers and hip-hop artists cultivated a well-respected local sound. One of the advantages of being a collector based in New Haven, Chris says, is that it’s “the only place in the world” to find certain incredibly valuable records. He recently came across a copy of Mr. Magic’s Bebop Convention, a New Haven rap album from 1988. It’s “considered one of the best early rap records of all time,” worth several thousand dollars, and he found it in a basement among thousands of neglected records. “When I got home, I was going through everything, cleaning out the stuff that smells like cat piss… and in between these two crusty records was this one record that pays my rent for a couple months.” He’s come across it twice before, and both times he sold it. This time, he says, he’ll keep it.
Dooley-O used to run a shop of his own just down the block from where Elm City Sounds is now. True to Dooley, though, it was more of an all-encompassing culture shop, where skateboards and clothing were sold alongside the curated record collection. The vinyl DJ culture in New Haven is small but vibrant, he says, but it’s still afflicted by the relegation of vinyl to musty basements. “A lot of the guys who do have vinyl in Connecticut kinda keep it in the house.” But he and some other enthusiasts hold vinyl parties at bars and clubs around New Haven, where DJs can use the turntables to play and mix whatever genre they’re feeling.
As an avid collector, Dooley has used records in his DJ work all through the downfall of the medium, though not exclusively. He, like most careful listeners, prefers analog sound, but he also sees vinyl as a sort of extension of the recorded music he’s into — it’s the real thing. “If someone is playing a bass line or the guitar, they’re not going to be 100 percent on point. So that’s where the looseness comes in, and the funk and the soul and the swing come in, that make you go ‘Ah, this a great tune…’ And vinyl’s perfect for that.” What’s more, when the cloud inevitably crashes, all our digital MP3s will disappear without a trace, but records last much longer. Dooley routinely tells people, “you gotta have at least some sort of vinyl in your house, and a record player, because if all that shit crashes… at least have something you can play on a record player, and you can say, ‘Oh wow man, this is the shit.” At least, until you play them so many times that the plastic wears down and the sound begins to warp. That’s an inevitability that only serious collectors worry over, but it’s one that the vinyl resurgence may not be prepared for.
The new boom of the industry may be a partial product of nostalgia, but it’s caught on in new music, too. Artists from Mac Miller to the Arctic Monkeys to Taylor Swift release their albums on records that get sold at places like Urban Outfitters and Target. According to a 2014 article in BuzzFeed News, Urban Outfitters claims to be “the biggest seller of vinyl records in the world.” But data for vinyl sales is notoriously spotty, since many smaller presses, even the most well-known ones, often don’t report their sales, and since so much of this business happens in second-hand shops like Chris’s. “[Since] records started really being popular again,” Chris says, “the industry is pressing up anything and everything they can, anything they think will make money. Shit’s selling.” This includes reissues of tons of old classics, of course, and even of records that were shelved and never released — but it seems that, just two decades after the cataclysmic demise of both analog records and CDs, vinyl has secured its new place in the contemporary musical landscape. Chris is eager to get to know his customers’ tastes and start selling new releases at Elm City Sounds. Though he doesn’t resent it, he has no bias towards nostalgia in vinyl.
Chris could’ve started Elm City Sounds anywhere, but he decided to do it in Westville for a reason. Record collectors tend to be obsessive about what they do, he says, and they’ll travel; “I could have it in a secret cave somewhere and record collectors will find me — but then you would alienate all those casual buyers.” And after all, the shop is about community. Even for someone like Dooley who knows the ins and outs of vinyl and New Haven, it’s a welcome sight. “It just [feels] good to be able to go to a record store in your neighborhood, because it gives the community a different ingredient than the norm,” he says with admiration. It’s a way of letting the community in on this great secret, the secret of vinyl — though it isn’t so secret anymore.
On The Record was originally published in The Yale Herald on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.