If someone would ask about the davening in HANC High School, there would be a few things that any student of our school could answer. For example, we all know that there are two minyanim for Shacharis, the Ashkenazi minyan, which is located in the gym, and the Sephardi minyan, which is located in the library; however, the Mincha minyanim are divided by grade level into Ashkenazi minyanim. Although Mincha is much shorter than Shacharis is, it seems unfair that all of available minyanim in our school for Mincha follow the same customs. Perhaps this can change. Maybe it’s time for HANC to establish a Sephardi minyan for Mincha.
Whoa! Wouldn’t forming a Sephardi minyan for Mincha in HANC be a big change? HANC’s current Mincha system has become like a tradition. However, change from tradition can often be beneficial. I believe that Rabbi Adelman has been trying to bring more excitement to Mincha over the past few years through the evolution of his famous Mincha announcements. However, it never seemed to be powerful enough to get all of the boys to go to Mincha willingly and excitedly, yet he might be onto something. Although it can be very difficult to get so many people to be excited for Mincha, we might be on our way to a Mincha revolution. As Rabbi Adelman evolved his Mincha announcements, he’s been making an impression on more people, but there are still many people in our school who don’t feel inspired to daven Mincha. Maybe this will be the boost that our school needs.
According to a recent poll (which consisted of both Sephardi and Ashkenazi views), the presence of a Sephardi Mincha minyan would have many positive effects upon the Sephardim and, in some cases, the Ashkenazim in HANC. Through inference, observation, and analysis, I have deducted that some of the problems for the Sephardim have led to other problems which have affected the Ashkenazim! Having a daily Sephardi minyan for Mincha can fix some of these problems.
Although there are many HANC students who are fortunate enough to go to Mincha with a desire to daven, there are some students in HANC who go to and/or daven Mincha only because they feel like they’ll cause trouble for themselves if they don’t do so, and there are some students who purposefully avoid going to Mincha for a variety of reasons. Some people don’t feel comfortable going to Mincha, and some people don’t realize the need to go to Mincha. In many of these cases, there is a lack of a strong enough connection, and that can often be caused when the only available minyanim for one to daven in on a regular basis follow different customs than that individual. Many of the people who go to Mincha without davening have, unfortunately, caused distractions for the people who were davening. Although the negative categories unfortunately contain both Ashkenazim and Sephardim, the introduction of a daily Sephardi Mincha minyan has the potential to reduce these problems for both sides of the coin. Many Sephardim might feel more welcomed, comfortable, and inspired in the Sephardi minyan, and some Ashkenazim might feel more embarrassed to talk during Mincha and more pressured to daven or to at least go to Mincha (for those who have avoided attending Mincha). The attendance rates would probably improve more for Sephardim, but this separation would definitely reduce the amount of distractions in the Ashkenazi Mincha minyanim. As for the distractions that could occur in the Sephardi minyan, Sephardim might feel less of a desire to talk because they are more familiar with the Sephardi davening. Although some of those effects may seem negative to some people, they could ultimately lead to more positively oriented environments.
Although Mincha is much shorter than Shacharis is, it seems unfair that all of available minyanim in our school for Mincha follow the same customs. With the formation of a Sephardi minyan in HANC for Mincha, many positive changes can occur in the spiritual lives of many of our students. B’ezras Hashem, this should be one of many steps, and just like the ladder with the angels in Yaäkov’s famous dream, each step that we go up brings us closer to Hashem. Everyone has the capability to improve his/her habits. In order to improve your davening, you can create a personalized Mincha revolution for yourself, but it will only work if you follow through with it. Each individual improvement will add to the bigger picture, and any improvement can inspire another piece of the Mincha Revolution. Sometimes the best inspirations come from self-improvement.