As he looked at the neon sign he thought of Sophie, pressing a finger to his cheek. Her careful eye always making her do things like that. “Blow,” she would say, “Blow, Dada!” as she’d balance the crescent eyelash on her forefinger with a dexterity beyond her years. What a moment! Like on a Hallmark Card, if anyone ever sent those anymore. How young she was, how perceptive! Spotting out her father’s tiny eyelash, resting on his face after a long day at work, probably dislodged from a furtive rubbing-of-the-eyes done as he got off the train, stirring himself from the half-sleep stupor of his corporate commute. How young! How loving! Reaching across the dinner table at her Dada, practically lurching out of her boosted seat! Grabbing her father’s eyelash between chubby Gerber fingers and letting him make a wish. My only wish is you, Sophie! He wanted to tell her. You are all my wishes come true.
But no need to get sentimental. Not now. What was that, years ago? A decade? How old had she been then, three? With slight tenseness his eyes darted away from the neon sign, the A-V-O-N spread out perpendicular to the asphalt, the beaming redness of the light glimmering down onto the just-wet street, reflecting back up at itself in the puddles. It had been raining. He hadn’t even noticed.
He turned on the wipers. No need to get all up in the brain about this. No need to get sentimental. No need to be digging up memories from the Cute Years, circa 13 months to 6 years old (before then, she had looked like a blob — after, she started losing teeth). No — any memory of Sophie from that era was off-limits right now. He wouldn’t allow it. He wasn’t going to be like Steve Martin in Father of the Bride, treating his daughter like a baby at the dinner table when she most definitely was not one anymore. Thirteen years old! Last month! When did that get the chance to happen? Happened as fast as the rain did just now, he didn’t even get the chance to notice, and it already happened. Thirteen years old! But no. Stop. No more sentimentalizing. It was just a first date. A movie. A 7:15 p.m. showing of Tomb Raider 2.
Why had he turned on the wipers? He had been in park for what, eight minutes? Feeling silly, he twisted the key out of the ignition and the car turned off with a machine-like sigh. The droning voice on NPR went quiet. Goodnight, Mr. Ira Glass. He unbuckled his seatbelt and leaned back in the seat.
But no, it was not fine, it wasn’t just a first date, but a first-born daughter on a first date, a first exploration of humanly love, of reciprocal interest, a first encounter of attention that exists in that slightly skewed way, that way that finally makes one feel like Yes, the world finally sees me, someone wants me, and I am here. He remembered his first date, how he had felt just that very same way, also in a movie theater. Oh, how things changed, yet were still all the same! He was glad that he remembered his very first date back when he was seventeen — not as young as Sophie, but still probably just as naively perplexed and anxious and ready to throw up right at the popcorn counter at the sight of the Slurpees. He had gone with Mary Myer — that red-haired bombshell. Oh, how scary she was to him at the time! Her décolletage, right out there in the open air for all of Bowtie Regent Cinemas to see! And how she hadn’t wanted any Milk Duds, even though he offered twice!
It was a great first date. Robust, even. They had laughed at all the same parts, and at one point he even remembered Mary resting her red-haired head on his bony shoulder. He remembered the way she had looked at him right as the movie ended, and how between their interlocked hands there was an elixir of together-sweat, the products of their two palms intermeshing into something nervously wonderful and vulgar at the same time. It was like that poem he had read in English class a few weeks ago, what was it? The one with that skeevy seventeenth century guy, about the flea? It went like —
Mark but this flea, and mark in this,
How little that which thou deniest me is;
It sucked me first, and now sucks thee,
And in this flea our two bloods mingled be;
— and he thought, yes, it was exactly like that! Except instead of their bloods intermingling together it was their sweats.
He was beginning to shiver. Turn the car back on, maybe? Let the heat run a little bit? Listen to some more NPR? He looked across the dashboard and noticed Sophie’s tube of lip-gloss, lying there, probably left absentmindedly before hopping out. Bye, Dad, you’ll pick me up at nine thirty-five, okay? I promise to text you — Or maybe it was Marion’s? The shade of coral seemed more like a Marion color than it did a Sophie. Marion was probably already asleep by now, her days were hard, he knew that. Through the window he saw the long strides of a theater attendant, lanky-legged, crossing the parking lot with trash bag strewn across the shoulder. He half-ran, skidding through the rain, and quickly hurled the bag into the dumpster while covering himself with a skinny arm. That arm ain’t helping you, kid! Maybe eat another steak or two, ha ha! Then he wondered how much stale popcorn they throw out each week? How much they’re paying that lanky little guy in the theater vest?
He reached for his phone to Google minimum wage. Hadn’t he heard it had changed, recently? He unlocked his phone. No text from Sophie. One from John — Did you see the report I just forwarded you? Bogus. with a thumbs-down emoji. He thought the use of emojis between work colleagues was unprofessional, and also sort of uncanny, in a way? He checked his email. The report was in fact bogus, and he shot John a quick reply. He opened a few of his apps — 2,421 steps that day, O.K. for a Saturday. Except maybe he should get out of the car and take a little walk? Get an extra two-hundred or so in? Well no, it was raining — Then a look at some video clips on Facebook, one standing out most of a Chihuahua refusing to leave its late owner’s grave site, a newscaster reporting on the adorable tragedy of the forlorn little dog… would his own pup be that posthumously loyal? Paul Simon, whom he loved so much? That lanky little Rhodesian Ridgeback, who looked nothing like Paul Simon in dog-form, but was given that title because why not, he just liked the name anyway?
He remembered the Paul Simon concert he took Marion to when they had just started going out. When they exited the venue he made a joke, something like, he told Marion he could be her bodyguard, and she laughed even though he knew that was the stupidest thing he could say at the time. Out of the twenty thousand people who were at that concert, did he think he was being original? The only one to make that joke to his loved one? But Marion had laughed, and that’s when he knew she was starting to fall in love with him. Hey world, thanks for seeing me, I’m still here. This is good. Maybe the sweetness of that moment is what had subconsciously informed his dog-naming choice. It was weird, he realized at that moment, that he never really made that connection. Hadn’t he ever questioned the name he gave his own dog? Then he remembered how long ago they had gotten that dog, jeez, had it been sixteen years now? Maybe Paul Simon wouldn’t outlive him after all. So the gravesite-loyalty ordeal was kind of solved.
He was still kind of scrolling through his phone, having forgotten all about the Google thing. On his calendar, he noticed a little red notification for Monday. 2PM Meeting w/ Mrs. Stapleton. He better not forget that. He’d have to leave work early, maybe 1 p.m.? To beat traffic? The school parking lot, he knew, got crowded by 1:30 p.m. He pressed “ALERT ME ABOUT THIS EVENT,” setting the notification to “ONE HOUR BEFORE.” He was getting really worried about Charlie. And he guessed Mrs. Stapleton was on the same page. That strange little kid, nine years old and already so many problems! Complaints of nightmares, occasional bed-wetting… and then Marion, thinking herself smart, reading Moby Dick to him so he could fall asleep. “Why would you do that?” he asked her. “He’s not old enough for Moby Dick!” And Marion protesting, back at him, “It was the most boring book we had around the house!” How offended he was. He loved Moby Dick, and all of Melville for that matter. And then he remembered feeling half-proud and half-floored, as his son came up to his chair at the dinner table, a few weeks later, hugging his leg and crying for a harpoon. A harpoon? What in the name — the kid was going to poke his eye out! But Charlie complained and complained, and cried, and it went on like that for a few days. And then he thought, I can’t be the dad from A Christmas Story, depriving my son of something he wants so dearly and desperately just because it could poke his eye out. So what, if he pokes his eye out? Is it worth the psychological damage of deprivation? So he went on Amazon and did some scrolling and found a little plastic harpoon about Charlie’s height. The look on the little boy’s face when he gave it to him! So filled with love and gratitude! And now, how the kid carries that thing around like a staff! Like Neptune and his trident, Death and his scathe — Charlie and his harpoon. The harpoon thing has been a real pain in the neck for about a month now. And worrisome. he began to think, it could be harmful the impression it might be leaving on Isaac. Only eleven months old, and already taking after his older brother. The same nervous energy. The same jolty movements. Neither one of those boys as calm as Sophie — what a sweet, quiet baby she had been! He had always wanted boys, but, jeez, he had never expected these kinds of antics. He thought back to dinner last night, Isaac sitting in the same highchair that Sophie once sat in, smashing his peas with his little baby fork, which he still hadn’t learned to use right. And Charlie, at the other end of the table, waving around his harpoon, shouting. So much shouting. And then little Isaac, who, suddenly, saying his third-ever word, begins shouting back Ifma! Ifma! So much shouting between his two little sons! And Marion giving him a look, like, I can’t deal with this. And him, thinking, yeah something needs to be done. But then before doing anything, sitting for a moment and thinking to himself, well this is pretty damn cute, isn’t it? Little Isaac, unable to pronounce “Ishmael”, and screaming back, almost reverentially, at his older brother: Ifma! Ifma! Ifma!
But it was not all just havoc over literary references, which, albeit annoying, made him feel like a smart and savvy parent. No. Charlie was going through a lot — maybe anger issues, or anxiety? But wait. He stopped himself. The school guidance counselor was strict about this — she made it clear to him not to label his son’s experience, not to jump to diagnoses. But how could he not? He wanted so badly to label his son’s problem, and then fix it. Charlie cried nearly every day now. He regularly confused the words “upset” and “mad.” “I’m so mad,” he said quietly, through tears, when they buried his goldfish last month in the backyard. And how he had screamed “I’m so upset!” in the face of some mall cop who told him he couldn’t take his harpoon into the building, that day they went to the pet store to buy him a new fish. The use of upset, there, was technically all right until Charlie threw himself to the floor in the quintessential raging fashion of a public tantrum, flinging the plastic spear at the mall cop on his way down.
Sophie had handled that day well. She picked up her brother up and began stroking him on the head. “It’s okay, we can get a fish somewhere else,” she told Charlie, and that had instantly calmed him down. With another hand she picked up the plastic harpoon from the floor and apologized to the mall cop. Then, all filing back out into the parking lot, they got in the car and drove on home. Thank God she had done that.
How was Sophie doing? He looked at the dashboard. 8:20 p.m. What were they doing? Was she touching the boy? Were they kissing? He thought he saw the neon V flicker for a second on the sign above. He wondered if Sophie would tell him, if she had kissed the boy on the date. Sophie was always so close to her mother, but now with Marion being so — well, maybe Marion was still the same, he didn’t know — he couldn’t make speculations about their mother-daughter relationship, at least not right now.
Maybe he should call his own mom? There was time to kill, anyway. When was the last time they had talked? Oh right, when Dad thought he had won the lottery last week, but really the blind spot in his left eye had made him read the numbers incorrectly. He could tell, over the phone, that Mom had been so disappointed, having had that little flutter of hope. Maybe she could’ve flown the grandkids out to come see her, with the thousand dollars they had almost just won? He felt a little awkward, not knowing how to comfort her. He tried telling his mother that, with the whole tax thing, maybe it wouldn’t have amounted to enough to fly them all out anyway. And even so, the kids were pretty busy now, what with the whole Charlie thing, and Isaac starting to teethe, and Sophie, possibly about to get her first boyfriend. And of course, all the stuff with Marion.
He decided he’d call Mom tomorrow. 8:25 pm was a weird time, anyway. She could be sleeping. And they had just talked last week, although maybe it wasn’t the happiest talk. He kind of missed his mom. He thought of how much he loved her own mother when he was younger, how much he’d idolized her and always wanted to show her. And that day! He started to laugh to himself, suddenly conjuring a memory he hadn’t thought of in a while, that day in grade school, maybe when he was ten? A little older than Charlie, the year when his mother was just starting to learn to become a real estate agent and went away most nights to go to trainings. How one night, when mom was out of the house, he went into her room and snuck into her medicine cabinet and took out her tube of Chanel Rouge Coco. He had seen part of a movie, a few weeks before, where a man received a letter with a big kiss of lipstick on it and it moved him right to tears. But — tears of happiness, it appeared? Remembering that movie, that was maybe the first time he’d ever seen tears of happiness on somebody before. And how, upon seeing that man both cry and smile, he thought wanted to make somebody he loved feel that way, too. Who better than his mom? So he found the lipstick she wore every morning, took it out of its place in the medicine cabinet, and carefully applied it onto his own two lips, leaning over the sink, looking in the mirror with vertiginous satisfaction, dizzy at the thought of how happy he was going to make his mother, making her cry and all. Then how he took out the letter he had spent all of lunch period writing to her, how he had asked Mrs. Fecchi to correct the spelling for him, and how suddenly, before the mirror, he pressed his lips so tenderly and furtively onto the paper, right beside his name, BILLY. The side of his kiss mark covering a little part of the Y. But that was O.K. His very own smooch! Stamped onto that extra wide-ruled page of yellow paper for eternity, the creases of the Chanel Rouge Coco sticking out against the blue dotted line in the middle of the rulings.
His mom did not cry. But she smiled. And she hung up the letter on the fridge. That was good enough, he thought at the time. Was he disappointed? A little. But not as much as he was when the letter got taken down. He came home from school one day and noticed it was missing. Mom was away at real estate lessons. So he asked his father, “Dad, have you seen my letter to Mommy?”
To which his dad slapped him right on the jaw.
And then the next day. The speech from his mom — “Billy, you have to know that your dad did that because he loves you. He loves you so, very much. He doesn’t want you to be hurt later in life. So, I guess, he felt better in hurting you now. But that’s not what the point of this is. Billy, your father loves you very much. But can you promise me, Billy, not to wear any more lipstick? Can you promise me that, little bug?”
He had understood. Maybe not then, in that very moment, but you know, eventually he came around and got it. And now, well, he got it more than ever. What, with little Charlie, carrying that harpoon around! Wouldn’t anyone with a child going through a Queequeg phase have the homoerotic undertones of Moby Dick swimming around in the back of his head, too? Was his son gay? Could be! But, he was never going to beat him for it. He would love his son no matter what, like he loved all his kids. And they needed this love now, probably more than ever. There was a lot of emotional labor being done by him, right now, and that was O.K. He was gonna be strong for his kids.
And didn’t he remember that time with Marion? When he had been strong with the kids? He suddenly thought to himself about that ferry ride a year and a half ago, when Marion was still pregnant with Isaac. They were on the bottom floor of the ferry going to the beach. An overcast day. It had been a twenty minute ride, but what a rocky ride it had been! Almost everyone on the thing had gotten sea sick, and the ferry crew running up and down the aisles with trash bags. How disgusting! And although he’d usually characterize himself as a sympathy vomiter, a yakker right at the smell of the stuff, he remained completely resolute on that ride. He gave a look to Marion like, Just don’t vomit. And she gave a look back at him like, I will really try not to. And he held Charlie close to his chest, letting him breathe through the cotton of his shirt, rubbing his stomach so he’d calm down. And Sophie nuzzled herself into his armpit, doing the same. “We’re almost there!” he assured his kids, although he didn’t really know what was going to happen. For all he knew, the boat could tip over any second. But in retrospect, he was proud of himself. He had been strong. Marion had been strong, too.
Would Marion be able to do that kind of thing now? Then — no. He repeated no, no, no to himself. He had to let go of that thought. He wasn’t going to start blaming Marion again. He tried his hardest to stop these kinds of thoughts as soon as they entered. He looked at the clock: 9:30 p.m. The credits must be rolling right about now, no? Or was the movie already over? Was Sophie happy, he wondered? Did the date go well? Still no text from her, which worried him. He wanted to call Marion to say he was worried about Sophie not texting. But would Marion even answer? The thoughts were let back in. Would Marion___? Would Marion___?
These days, with Marion, the question always now led to: Would Marion___? She really had changed. The Marion from before loved the kids so much, maybe even more than he did. But, with Isaac, well, the birth of Isaac did something to her. Depression? Anxiety? PTSD? Well, he did not want to label her experience, but then again, she became obstinate whenever he suggested therapy. She did not want to get help, but she needed it. Did she seriously think he couldn’t hear her crying in the bathroom, that night Charlie asked for the harpoon? Whispering to herself, God what children? Did she not even think it was the tiniest bit funny that Isaac, barely a year old, already knew who Ishmael was? Did she not think it was important, at all, when he told her about the boy in Sophie’s class named George that was taking their daughter out on a date this Saturday, to the Avon Theater on Main Ave, to see a 7:15 p.m. showing of Tomb Raider 2?
And was it selfish? For him? To want his own wife to love his kids? To not think to herself, God what children? To want her to be awake when he came home, sitting up in bed, a book in her hands, Elizabeth Bishop poems maybe, waiting for him, to talk about Sophie? To ask how the date went? To ask him, jokingly: did she get back in the car with lip-gloss smeared? With hair a little frizzed? What did she seem like? Did she tell you anything? Did you catch a glimpse of the boy?
And was it fair of him, to want her to be the one who would then have to defend Sophie, as he, in his fatherly overprotective ardor, started denouncing the very same boy that sat beside her at the 7:15 p.m. showing of Tomb Raider 2? This… George, whatever the little rat’s name was? Was it fair that he wanted Marion to play that role, just for a second? Of the mother, siding with the daughter, assuaging the overprotective, yet loving dad? Was it fair? Was it fair?
Really, Marion, was any of it fair? He was raging. Was it fair that he wanted more help, that he needed more guidance, that he couldn’t be the only one figuring out Charlie, and taking the kids to the pet store, and going to parent-teacher conferences with Mrs. Stapleton, and dealing with Isaac when he teethed, and dropping off Sophie at the movies? Was any of it fair?
A knock on the car’s door-side window, so subtle. 9:40 p.m., it says on the dashboard. On the window, Sophie’s little tap tap continues, and he presses the unlock button on the door panel beside him. Getting in the car, her auburn hair a big swoop across her shoulder. He looks over at his daughter, so beautiful, so small, thin elbows at her sides, how jagged those things are! And how they used to dig into his chest when he’d pick her up! And Sophie, leaning into the rear view mirror to get a look at her own face, checking for smudged mascara crusts under her giant, almost koi-like eyes, turning over to him and suddenly, face furrowing, scrunching up those big koi eyes, starts to say,
“Dad, have you been sitting in the car this whole time? Wait — dad, are you crying?”
The Avon was originally published in The Yale Herald on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.