The college football world has been turned upside down.
Claims of the Atlantic Coast Conference taking over the entire East Coast fly left and right as U. Pittsburgh and Syracuse U. officially signed over from the Big East, moving the ACC to a total of 14 teams starting next September.
Days later, Texas A&M U. departed from the Big 12 without looking back, making headway into the Southeastern Conference.
And speculation remains of where more teams may be headed next.
Amid the talk and trade, the Big Ten Conference remains stable and quiet on realignment.
But Penn State journalism professor Malcolm Moran — who has more than 30 years of sports journalism experience for newspapers like USA Today, The New York Times, Newsday and Chicago Tribune — said his main concern with conference realignment has nothing to do the with the sports end.
It’s about the academics.
“All of that talk appears to have little or nothing to do with higher education and everything to do with expanding your broadcast for print,” Moran said. “If all of this was just about business, you could applaud them, but this is supposed to be about higher education.”
And Moran’s thoughts aren’t too far off.
This week, NCAA President Mark Emmert called the recent behaviors among college teams and conferences an example of misinterpreted interests for college athletes.
“I think what came across [with realignment] is that all we care about is money and what we can do that is to our advantage,” Emmert said. “Nobody was talking about what this is going to do for student-athletes or intercollegiate athletic programs. It was all about ‘let’s make a deal.’ ”
From turfs to term papers
Many of the athletic academic advisors at these top universities also face the same battle of pushing their students to the highest expectations in the classroom, as well as encouraging their time on the field, said Linda Caldwell, Penn State’s faculty athletics representative.
“There’s no doubt that people are saying that this is all about money because there’s no doubt that it’s about that,” Caldwell said. “But personally, we’re going to do our darndest to continue the Penn State way and the Big Ten way to put academics up there.”
The Big Ten — created in 1896 — is the oldest athletic conference in the country. And what makes the conference so unique is its corresponding academic equivalent called the Committee on Institutional Cooperation, which holds the schools to specific academic standards, CIC Executive Director Barbara McFadden Allen said.
Since the CIC’s inception in 1958, the committee has engaged in $7.5 billion in research activities, Allen said. It also connects researchers on Big Ten campuses and allows schools to share study abroad programs and a library system database.
“[Big Ten schools] recognized that they were so powerful on the athletic field and yet here they were representing some of America’s leading institutions, so it made sense to come together,” Allen said. “And it still holds true today.”
Members-only benefits
But this same committee is what also remains at the core of the conference realignment conversation, as the Big Ten doesn’t readily accept new members into the conference. Currently, the committee is made up of the 12 Big Ten schools, as well as U. Chicago.
U. Nebraska-Lincoln’s induction into the Big Ten was finalized in the summer of 2010 and was the second school the conference added in 62 years. Other schools like U. Connecticut, Rutgers U. and U. Missouri have tried to join — and have been considered all the same — but have never gotten anything more than discussion.
“Nebraska has some of the most loyal fans in the country,” said Doug Anderson, the dean of the College of Communications and a Nebraska native. “Who’s going to get up in the morning to watch these games, Nebraska versus Wisconsin or Rutgers [versus] Wisconsin? Seriously.”
As a whole, Anderson said Nebraska has been around a long time and established itself as an academic university and an athletic competitor, with 21 varsity sports and five national football championships in the last 50 years.
“If you’re looking for an institution whose pedigree most commonly aligns with the then-current members of the Big Ten, Nebraska was the best choice,” Anderson said.
At the time of Nebraska’s membership, the Big Ten conference was the only conference to include all schools who held membership in the Association of American Universities, which helps further American universities’ standings internationally as well as assistance with grant and research funding.
As of April 2011, U. Nebraska-Lincoln was removed from the AAU due to insufficient grant funds — due largely in part to the location of Nebraska’s medical school, said Faculty Athletic Representative Josephine Potuto.
Because of the medical school’s location, any funding and grant money does not count toward U. Nebraska’s overall contribution to the AAU, Potuto said. The AAU also doesn’t honor any grant money in the College of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, which is a huge program for Nebraska and home to world-renowned professors, Potuto said.
“AAU has criteria for membership and you don’t fare as well if you’re small,” she said of the university, which is home to 19,383 undergraduate students, according to College Board. “And I understand the fact they don’t count the medical school, but not to count the agricultural professors, that seems a little arbitrary, but I guess they can make their own decisions.”
As the realignment conversation continues to swirl around the conferences, the AAU may continue to hold many of the universities together on the academic and athletic fronts.
Assistant Athletic Director for Communications Jeff Nelson said there is “no doubt” that the AAU stands as an “extremely important component” of the Big Ten conference and its standards for the universities.
“That’s the reason why all the institutions exist,” Nelson said. “The goal is to provide great educational opportunities.”
A matter of ‘institutional trust’
Thankfully, Moran said, the Big Ten has established itself as a stable, secure conference and continues to hold its universities to those standards.
Despite the disputes among other conferences, Moran said the Big Ten’s “institutional trust” has helped to prevent squabbles among the teams.
“It’s not that everybody is getting along and holding hands all the time, but there’s a foundation of decade-long relationships between institutions,” he said. “There is a way to work it out without turning your back on your peers and walking away in a huff.”
After all, the universities exist to provide academic experiences for their students, while helping their athletes on the field, Nelson said.
“Across the board, all Big Ten schools are similar from that standpoint,” he said. “They’re all teams that are able to go out and compete for NCAA championships in a variety of different sports.”
Caldwell said Penn State athletes also stack up against other Penn State students in regards to their choice of majors and specific colleges. Caldwell and her colleagues looked into the numbers after a discussion at a Division I athletics meeting.
But as realignment talk continues and players attempt to keep their focus on the field, Big Ten university presidents are left to debate what to do going forward.
Nevertheless, Allen said there is nothing to worry about anytime soon.
“On the CIC’s end, we are not having those conversations and we’re not looking for new members,” Allen said. “I’m here to tell you […] the presidents of the Big Ten have always got it right.”
And it’s the relationship between athletics and academics that keeps the Big Ten strong.
“We fight on the fields on Saturday and we cooperate in the office on Monday,” Allen said. “We’re an amazingly powerful force when we work together.”