Turn to a New Yorker and ask what their favorite spot in Manhattan is. Whether it’s standing on a rooftop, underneath the Brooklyn Bridge or riding the Staten Island Ferry on a clear day, many of us will say our favorite place on the island is not actually in Manhattan at all, but just on the edge of it. It doesn’t come out of a need to escape, but out of the need to look in and see our beloved city as a whole. It is on the edge of Manhattan that New Yorkers rediscover their reason for migrating here in the first place, the city of symbols and hope that inspired them. It is from here that they get to see the impossible, almost unbearable grandness of it all. It is from here that they can see the famed New York City skyline.
It was fewer than 40 years ago that a completed World Trade Center first appeared on that horizon. Today marks the 10th year it and its counterpart have been missing from it. Considering the adoption of the Twin Towers as a treasured symbol for the resilience of New Yorkers, it is hard for us to believe that when they first appeared on the tip of Manhattan, they were not well received. Perhaps it is so hard to believe, because now all we think about is how badly we want them back.
Dr. Carol Krinsky, professor of art history and director of undergraduate studies at the New York University Institute of Fine Arts, lives in this city and has witnessed much of the evolution of its skyline. When I asked her what her reaction was when she first heard of the World Trade Center, she told me that I’m asking the wrong question. “It took a long time to build,” Krinsky said. “The citizens of New York didn’t fully understand what the point was. The point, as it turns out, was the rehabilitation of the Financial District.”
The concept of the World Trade Center grew in the 1950s, not out of the need to make New York a center of world trade, but out of the need to revamp a rapidly disappearing Wall Street. In the years following World War II, office buildings were moving out of lower Manhattan. Midtown was the new place to be. Grand Central offered an easier commute, and downtown office buildings were dated and in need of repair. They lacked the modern conveniences of the giant, metal boxes that were springing up in Midtown, and the new and exciting attitude they brought to the city. They had the appeal of air conditioning, floor space and sleek designs. The incentive to travel to Wall Street was beginning to dwindle and the area was in danger of becoming obsolete. It was David Rockefeller, William Zeckendorf and Robert Moses who came up with an idea to bring the people of New York back downtown. In 1959 that idea was officially given a name, a name to signify the power and importance they wanted to bring back to Wall Street. It would be called the World Trade Center.
The design, from the beginning, was spattered with criticism. The Port Authority’s control over the project meant the voices of New York taxpayers went unheard. New Jersey now had a say in what was being built in New York City. The citizens of New York were livid. “They wanted voter control,” Krinsky said, “and they didn’t have it.” The situation exploded when Radio Row merchants, owners of radio and electronic equipment stores located on Cortlandt Street realized they were being kicked out to make way for the new structures. The fight between small business and big finance went all the way to the Supreme Court. As we all know, Radio Row was no victor.
“The city needed development,” Krinsky said. “It needed tax revenue. It needed jobs in the construction industry. Cities cannot stagnate. They cannot simply be preserved.” Still, New Yorkers would deplore that an entire business community was being systematically destroyed. Landmarks were being bulldozed, history was being scorned. Krinsky, however, sees a greater picture of the city that most find hard to grasp.
“Radio Row might have been rendered obsolete anyway with the invention of all the gadgets we use today,” she said. “Honestly, they probably couldn’t have survived the change in technology. We lose the things that we love. The aim is to build something even better, not just to build something new.”
I asked if the World Trade Center was categorically better. “It partly did what it was supposed to do,” Krinsky said reluctantly, “but it was artificial, it was not a pair of buildings that anybody needed or that made a difference.”
Today, most of us may look back on the towers and imagine a symbol of strength. When we draw a sketch of the city, we make sure to draw four buildings: the Empire State, the Chrystler buildings and the Twin Towers. No other buildings were so identifiable. We think of the towers, and we are filled with nostalgic emotion, and maybe even patriotism. But during their construction, the collective sentiment of New Yorkers couldn’t have been more different.
The World Trade Center, under architect Minoru Yamasaki, was meant to, literally, break the skyline. At 110-stories, the Towers would be the tallest buildings in the world, until the completion of the Sears Tower in Chicago in 1973. The basic concept: a simple box.
“In those days,” Krinsky said, “a simple geometric box was considered aesthetically progressive, partly because people had tired visually of the setback skyscrapers. If you build a pure prism, that sounded cleansed of 1920s clichés. Things that were sleek and pure and uninterrupted seemed to be current.” But Yamasaki’s “geometric boxes” did not go over well with Manhattanites.
“The Mountain comes to Manhattan,” The New York Times write. “Gargantua-by-the-sea,” Architectural Forum called it. Or as architecture critic and NYU alumnus Ada Louise Huxtable so gracefully described them, “The Flat-Topped Behemoths.”
“Most people I know didn’t like it,” Krinsky remembered. “The visual aspect. It was too empty, and the buildings seemed too trivial. They didn’t have the strength that big buildings ought to have.” The feeling was certainly not unique.
“His choice of delicate detail on massive construction as a means of reconciling modern structural scale to the human scale of the viewer is often more disturbing than reassuring,” said Huxtable of Yamasaki in a 1966 New York Times article. Yamasaki’s design intricacies, meant to offset the brutal silhouette of his structures, instead created a dissonance that architects found unsettling.
Still, despite all complaints, the Trade Center was completed in 1971. As New Yorkers stood on the edge of Manhattan, in their favorite spot to look in on their city, they saw a skyline disrupted. Disrupted by two flat-topped behemoths. Then, 28 years later, the behemoths stood no more.
“I wasn’t in New York at the time and I’m glad I wasn’t,” Krinsky said, “For me the tragedy was one step removed because I wasn’t here.” Her husband, however, was. “He was interested in all kinds of transit,” Krinsky explained. “Airplanes, trains, cars, that sort of thing. He was voting that morning, and when he came out he heard an airplane in the wrong place.” After listening to the radio, he learned that, in fact he was right. The first plane had just crashed into the World Trade Center.
“I was in Louisville,” Krinsky recalled, “and my students in Louisville did a strange thing when they heard what happened, something I was not used to in New York. They prayed. Then they lined up to give blood and of course blood wasn’t needed because people were just dead.” For Krinsky, and for New York, it was not about the buildings. It was about the people in the buildings. “When people tried to describe the images, I tried not to look. I would not look at those images,” she said, trembling slightly at the recollection.
In 1966, Huxtable made a comment that would resonate through the decades. “The gamble of triumph or tragedy at this scale—and ultimatelym it is a gamble—demands an extraordinary payoff,” she said. “The Trade Center towers could be the start of a new skyscraper age or the biggest tombstones in the world.” I can only imagine how chilled Huxtable must be at such a premonitory comment.
Now, on the tenth anniversary of that infamous day, we sit in our favorite spot on the edge of our city, contemplating the gap that stood as a decade-long reminder of tragedy. But today, something is rising in their place
What does Krinsky think of the plans for One World Trade Center, formally known as the Freedom Tower, designed by Daniel Libeskind? “It’s alright,” she said, smirking. After some prodding she revealed her reasoning. “I’m not drawn to buildings that are labeled to tell you what to think.” Libeskind’s romantic design is meant to grab onto that symbolism of the city that many of us love. It is a way of honoring the buildings that stood before it. But for Krinsky, it is not about honoring the buildings. It is about honoring the people. “When I see an office building I do not think of freedom,” she said, pragmatically. “I think of commerce.” What would she put there instead? “At the moment,” she said, “there is no immediate need to re-build. But in the meantime we should honor the dead with a beautiful memorial garden where we may meditate, remember.”