“My life has changed forever. No more happiness for me,” Gisele Plancher told the jury regarding the death of her son, Ereck Plancher.
During the 11th day of the Ereck Plancher wrongful death trial against the U. Central Florida Athletics Association, Plancher’s parents testified and both parties of attorneys were the quietest they’ve been since the trial began.
Plancher, who was a wide receiver on the UCF football team, died March 18, 2008, following a team conditioning drill. The medical examiner for the case determined the cause of death to be dysrhythmia due to acute exertional rhabdomyolysis with sickle cell trait, a trait his parents testified they didn’t know he had.
In addition to the parent’s testimony, the jury saw video testimony from former quarterback Nate Tice and video testimony from head coach George O’Leary. It was the testimony from Plancher’s mother, Gisele, that elicited tears from jury members and others in the courtroom.
“That’s the worst thing in life for a mother to bury her son,” Gisele said. “That’s hurt me every day, every minute, every second.”
Plancher family attorney Steve Yerrid had both of Plancher’s parents reflect on some of the memories of their son.
“That was the best day of my life to bring Ereck home with me,” Gisele said regarding the day her oldest son was born.
Gisele said that her son, as a child, loved school so much he would’ve gone on Saturday and Sunday if he could.
Yerrid showed Gisele photos of her son from when he was elementary school age and asked her to identify the age he was in each photo and some of what she remembered.
“He liked to dress up,” Gisele said when a photo of 5-year-old Ereck in a tuxedo was displayed on the screen in the courtroom.
Many of the photos of her son as a child brought a smile to her face, but it was seeing photos of him playing football for UCF that made her start crying.
“I wanted him to have everything in life,” Gisele said.
When Yerrid asked her how her son’s death has affected her and her husband, Enock, she testified that they’ve both had trouble sleeping and Enock now has blood pressure problems.
She also said they no longer celebrate birthdays and holidays, and they took down the photos of him because they make her cry.
After that, Yerrid asked her what she remembered from his visit during spring break before he died.
Gisele said Ereck loved spending time with his younger brother, Edwin.
“When Ereck comes down, he always took Edwin with him everywhere he goes,” she said.
She also remembered cooking meals for him while he was back at their home in Naples.
“Mommy, I want you to cook for me because when you’re in college you only eat junk food,” Gisele said Ereck told her when he was hungry.
She testified that a lot of the pain she’s felt since his death is brought on from thinking about what his life could’ve been.
“If he was still living today, I would expect him to graduate from college, finish his master’s, start his own family,” Gisele said.
Ereck’s father, Enock, also testified to what his son could’ve been.
“I would like him to be a doctor or a lawyer…but he wanted to be a business man,” Enock said.
Enock also said that he feels the loss of his son every minute of every day.
“He was the best kid I’ve ever known,” Enock said. “He was polite, kind. He loved everybody.”
Enock also testified about what he remembered from the last spring break he had with his son.
He said Ereck went to his old high school very early every morning to work out.
Despite those workouts, Enock said he was unaware that his son had been given instructions as to how to stay in shape during the break.
Tice didn’t recall the instructions he and other players were given for spring break until a copy of them was shown to him, which triggered his memory.
Tice, who is currently a quarterback for the University of Wisconsin Badgers, said he and a few other players from UCF’s team spent most of their spring break at a house on the beach in Destin, Fla, relaxing and playing touch football.
Regarding workouts, Tice said that players know their bodies better than anyone else, but sometimes it takes the intervention of an athletic trainer to prevent something bad from happening when a player tries to push through the pain too much.
“Looking back, yeah, I should’ve said something. I feel like everybody should’ve said something at that point,” Tice said regarding the moment he thought Plancher might not be OK.
Prior to viewing O’Leary’s video testimony and hearing from the Plancher parents, the jury was read testimony from cardiologist Dr. Saroja Bharati, the director of Maurice Lev Congenital Heart and Conduction System Center, who medical examiner Dr. Joshua Stephany consulted about Plancher’s heart.
Bharati, who said no one has researched the impact of sickle cell trait on the heart, agreed with what Stephany determined to be the cause of death.
She stated in her report that “To the best of my knowledge the cardiac conduction system in sickle cell trait with sudden death in youngsters has not been documented in the literature. It will be useful to study the conduction system by serial section examination.”
The Plancher family attorneys rested their case at about 5 p.m. and will have about two hours and 30 minutes to present their closing arguments.