Around noon on March 5, 2015, about 80 students gathered in the swirling snow by the steps of Woodbridge Hall. Flurries dusted their hats and backpacks, an orange, felt square marked with a black Y pinned to many of them and the signs they held. The students stood in a semi-circle, facing two upturned plastic crates. Students took turns atop the makeshift stage, speaking to the crowd through a megaphone between intermittent chants of “Whose side are you on, Yale?” and “Stand with us!” These protesters were members and supporters of Fossil Free Yale, an undergraduate organization dedicated to climate justice, specifically through fossil fuel divestment.
“I felt so empowered at the rally, among throngs of talented people who are struggling for substantive change,” FFY member A. Grace Steig, SM ’16, told me in an email. “In my three and a half years at Yale, I have never felt such a surge of energy around environmental work on campus, or felt so much optimism that students can enact meaningful change.”
Providing context for the rally, Alexandra Barlowe, BR ’17, took the stage and explained how their action coincides with that of others. This spring, fossil free groups worldwide are “beginning to coordinate taking nonviolent direct action on a mass scale.”
FFY Communications Coordinator Chelsea Watson, JE ’17, called this action a “shift in strategy.” Back in Oct. 2014, the group sent 180 signed letters to University President Peter Salovey, GRD ’86, demanding divestment from fossil fuel corporations. This time, however, more has changed than the number of letters submitted. “We have tried to work within administrative channels repeatedly,” Watson said. “However, we have not been heard and the Yale Corporation has refused to engage with us. We have taken a more confrontational stance because that is the only channel available to us.”
In addition to the speeches delivered outside, the group submitted a letter to President Salovey demanding “that the Yale administration present our community with a plan of action, which will detail how Yale plans to change its investment policy to address the multiple injustices created by the fossil fuel industry.” The letter provided the administration with a deadline of April 1, 2015. Although the Yale Daily News called this deadline an “ultimatum,” Watson explained, “The deadline given by this letter is meant to express the urgency and severity of these problems, and demonstrates that this is an issue that cannot wait.”
***
Over several emails, Watson explained what FFY has done since its founding in the fall of 2012. A Nov. 2013 Yale College Council referen dum showed 83 percent of the student body in favor of divestment, and since then, FFY has engaged in talks with the Advisory Committee on Investor Responsibility. “Certainly all of us [at the ACIR] have learned a great deal [about climate change],” Law Professor and Chair of the ACIR Jonathan Macey, LAW ’82, said. “Largely to the efforts of FFY, certainly everyone on the ACIR understands one of [FFY’s] fundamental points: that climate change is a significant problem and needs to be addressed.”
But the ACIR does not have the final say. It provides recommendations to Yale’s Corporate Committee on Investor Responsibility on how it should manage its financial portfolio in accordance with The Ethical Investor, a guidebook that, since its publication by the Yale University Press in 1972, has provided a framework for Yale and other institutions to consider additional social or moral factors when making investment decisions. “By law,” Macey clarified, “the actual decision making with respect to endowment is vested in Yale Corporation and its designees.” That means that despite any receptiveness to the input of the ACIR, the CCIR may still refuse to divest. And it has.
FFY’s March 5 rally and letter was yet another attempt to overturn the CCIR’s decision. “There has been very little action taken by our universities to either acknowledge or attempt to right the wrongs of the fossil fuel industry,” Barlowe said at the rally. “And that is unacceptable. We cannot wait any longer.”
Back in February, a study commissioned by the Independent Petroleum Association of America caused a minor stir in the divestment debate by claiming divestment would have a significant negative impact on financial portfolios, ultimately causing university endowments to suffer. Daniel R. Fischel, president of the economics consulting firm Compass Lexecon and professor at the University of Chicago Law School, led the study and stated in a press release, “Every bit of economic evidence available to us today demonstrates that fossil-fuel divestment is a bad idea.”
Although brandished by the fossil fuel industry, that study raises eyebrows elsewhere. The money management firm Aperio Group conducted several analyses on the long-term performance of financial portfolios divested from oil, gas, and consumable fuels like coal. CEO Patrick Geddes explained that the studies responded to criticism surrounding the burgeoning fossil fuel divestment movement, although Aperio itself has no political or moral stake in the divestment debate.
Aperio analysts began by removing fossil fuel securities from financial portfolios and replacing those lost stocks with different investments. They looked at how these new, optimized, divested portfolios performed compared to ones that retained their fossil fuel securities. Geddes and Aperio Chief of Staff Liz Michaels found that the divested portfolios show little difference. They performed as well as invested ones over the same historical time periods.
As for the more recent IPAA study results, which came to a completely different conclusion, Michaels criticized their methods. He explained that Fischel “took some liberties with the analysis,” namely by “cherry-picking” his time period—it was shorter than Aperio’s—and failing to optimize the divested portfolios. Professor Macey didn’t pay attention Fischel’s study either; when I told him about it he responded with a surprised, rhetorical question: “Is that a big deal?”
Setting aside these studies, however, FFY maintains that eco- nomics aren’t really the point of divestment. The debate is inextricably tied to money, but Watson explained in an email that “the ideology behind the divestment movement is that morality overrides money.” FFY’s March 5 action and letter demonstrate that: “The point of divestment,” Watson wrote, “is to strip the industry of its legitimacy and bankrupt it morally.”
***
Through campaigns like fossil fuel divestment, FFY dedicates itself to what it calls environmental justice. It seeks to build solidarity and offer support for what FFY considers an integral but often overlooked component of the fossil fuel industry: namely the people who live near extraction sites or refineries. These people often have to breathe polluted air and drink toxic water tainted by fossil fuel companies. This community, which FFY members referenced in their speeches, letter, and interviews, includes racial minorities as well as people of low economic status and little political efficacy. “The fossil fuel industry harms most people in some way, but it disproportionately harms marginalized populations,” Steig told me. “This rally finally foregrounded a concern that has been central to the fossil fuel divestment movement since its inception: social justice.”
On March 5, FFY members focused on these “victims of the climate crisis,” as Barlowe called them in her speech. The letter FFY submitted to President Salovey reads: “Inherent to the business model of the fossil fuel industry is exploitation of and general disregard for the communities who live nearby. These practices inflict a direct social injury and cannot be ignored.”
While the letter they sent to Woodbridge Hall called for support for these people, outside on the steps, protestors gave voice to them more directly. Tristan Glowa, MC ’18, took the megaphone to speak about the contaminated groundwater near his hometown in Alaska. Instead of rehabilitating the land, the fossil fuel corporation shut down an oil refinery at fault and left. “It needs to be clear that the same bottom line that has screwed over my own community is the bottom line that is making this univer- sity money. Profiting off of this behavior is an endorsement of it,” he said.
Steig told about a “Holyoke, Massachusetts, largely-immigrant labor organization [that] had great success shutting down that state’s last coal plant” she wrote in an email. “The unjust siting of polluting industries near the homes of people of color and low-income people is a shameful epidemic in this country,” she shouted to the crowd.
Despite FFY’s campaigning, the Yale Corporate Committee on Investor Responsibility rejected their proposal for fossil fuel divestment on Aug. 27, 2014, in lieu of a series of sustainability initiatives. An “Update on Yale’s Sustainability Initiatives” released last week explains these, which include investment in “energy conservation and greenhouse gas reduction,” a solar panel field installation on West Campus, and Green Innovation Fellowships for student sustainability entrepreneurial ventures. Still, FFY finds these insufficient and unsatisfactory.
“Sustainability is important,” Watson told me, “however, it is not enough to force the drastic changes that must be made to combat climate change, and furthermore does not address the issues of on the ground exploitation of communities living near or around extraction sites, refineries, mines, etc.” Sustainability, FFY believes, misses the point of the divestment movement’s en- vironmental and social justice mission.
In response to FFY’s March 5 action, President Salovey sent a letter reiterating Yale’s sustainability initiatives, but did not address one of the main concerns raised at the rally. “There was no mention of the social justice issues we have clearly and repeatedly pointed out,” said Watson, which “indicates that he either does not understand fully the severity and gravity of this issue, or simply does not care.”
“We asked: which side are you on? And the administration showed us they are not on our side—yet,” Watson continued.
“We must take esca lated action in order to make them choose our side.” FFY declined to discuss open ly what form their “escalated action” will take, stating only: “We are planning a nonviolent direct action, and if people would like to take part they should contact us directly.”
As for President Salovey, GRD ’86, when I reached out for comment, University Press Secretary Tom Con roy told me in a brief email: “the president’s response seems self-explanatory.”