Deflecting blame for Tucson attack nonsensical

By Arragon Perrone

In the wake of the horrific attack on Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords (D-AZ), that killed six and injured 14, members of the political left have blamed Sarah Palin and the Tea Party for one disturbed individual’s violent act. Critics consider the right wing’s militant language, such as Palin’s comment “Don’t Retreat, Reload,” Glenn Beck’s use of emotional, doomsday rhetoric and the Tea Party’s confrontational opposition to the Democrats’ healthcare overhaul to be directly responsible for the tragedy.

Such accusations are false and off-base. The only one responsible for the shooting is Jared Loughner, the 22-year-old, mentally unstable shooter. Pundits and so-called “experts” blame society for the shooter’s deranged act, transferring responsibility away from the individual. To do so may be a natural human reaction to rationalize one disturbed man’s heinous act. Nevertheless, it is a counterproductive and dangerous because it does what the shooter would want people to do: draw criticism away from him.

Most of the criticism levied against Sarah Palin and the Tea Party comes from MSNBC and Paul Krugman, an economist and op-ed columnist for The New York Times. Krugman pointed the finger at “the saturation of our political discourse…with eliminationist rhetoric that lies behind the rising tide of violence. Where’s that toxic rhetoric coming from? Let’s not make a false pretense of balance: it’s coming…from the right.” MSNBC’s Keith Olbermann warned that “[i]f Sarah Palin…does not repudiate her own part, however tangential, in amplifying violence and violent imagery in American politics, she must be dismissed from politics.”

Whether or not militant rhetoric creates a hostile political environment or merely reflects one is irrelevant to the Tucson shooting. There is no evidence that Loughner was motivated to assassinate Giffords because of the political opinions, words or actions of Tea Party figures. Lougher is a sick, twisted, psychotic individual whose actions stem from paranoid schizophrenia, not political fervor. The facts of the case point the blame solely on him and a possible neurological disorder – no one else.

This is some of what the public now knows about Loughner’s personality: In high school, he was a socially awkward student who was nevertheless identified by friends as friendly and happy with his life. The group he hung out with smoked marijuana daily and often discussed philosophy and conspiracy theories. Loughner also engaged in frequent binge drinking. Once, when he was a junior, he was taken to the hospital and nearly died after binge drinking tequila during a lunch break. In 2008, he was rejected from the Army after he admitted to using marijuana so much that Army officials present identified him as “a habitual drug abuser.” In October 2008, he was arrested for vandalizing a sign and admitted to other acts of vandalism in the area. When he attended Pima Community College, he often disrupted class with frequent outbursts. Campus police met him for “classroom and library disruptions” five times between February and September 2010. Later, police discovered a video he had posted on YouTube that accused the college of being unconstitutional and of torturing students. Loughner left voluntarily, but college officials ordered him not to return unless he had passed a mental health examination. Lynda Sorensen, who was in Loughner’s algebra class, described him as “a mentally unstable person…that scares the living crap out of me.”

Regarding his political beliefs, Loughner had a political ideology of his own. He believed that the government was “implying mind control and brainwash on the people by controlling grammar.” In 2007, before the nation knew about Sarah Palin and before the Tea Party ever existed, Lougher attended a “Congress on Your Corner” event held by Giffords, similar to the one at which he shot her. After she refused to answer his nonsensical question, he labelled her a “fake,” according to former friend Bryce Tierney. On pieces of paper found in his house, he wrote “Giffords” and “Die bitch.” Loughner was a registered Independent and did not vote in the 2010 midterm elections. A former classmate, Caitie Parker, said that “[as] I knew him he was left wing, quite liberal and oddly obsessed with the 2012 prophecy.” Friends, with whom he later dropped out of contact, say that his philosophy was defined by nihilism and conspiracy. He believed that the U.S. government orchestrated the 9-11 attacks and feared the rise of a single international monetary system under the power of governments used to control people. CBS News’ Bob Orr diagnoses Loughner as “a man who viewed the government as a monolith. He was just against the government….and the theory is that he didn’t attack Congresswoman Giffords because she was either liberal or conservative, or even moderate. He attacked Congresswoman Giffords, [the FBI] believes, because she was the representative of government closest to him.”

Jared Loughner attempted to assassinate a member of Congress, assassinated a federal judge and killed four others including a 9-year-old girl. Arguments and accusations that intentionally try to link the Tea Party or Palin to this crime are dishonest, deplorable and delusional. Such arguments, promoted by media pundits, place blame on societies and political parties, not where it should be – on the individual who pulled the trigger. Loughner probably enjoys society wondering what it could have done to stop him. But the answer lies with his nihilism – nothing. He decided to shoot Giffords, he “planned ahead” (in his own words) and he will pay for his crime.

There is nothing wrong with a society trying to explain the unexplainable questions: why does evil exist? Why does a young man with so much promise become a brutal monster? As Jon Stewart stated after the shooting, “Boy, wouldn’t it be nice to draw a straight line of causation from this horror to something tangible, because then we could convince ourselves that if we just stop this [cause], the horrors will end.” In this case, no one is to blame except the criminal himself. An attempt to seek blame elsewhere only lets Loughner off the hook and denies justice to the man who committed an inexcusable, unjustifiable act.

Read more here: http://www.dailycampus.com/commentary/deflecting-blame-for-tucson-attack-nonsensical-1.1880767
Copyright 2026 The Daily Campus