Casting Shadows: Integration on the American Stage provides a retrospective on the history of race in American theater, and showcases those individuals who first crossed the color line by assembling and performing in integrated casts. The exhibit, which opened Fri. Jan. 16, traces that gradual integration from the Harlem Renaissance era to the 80s. The exhibition is the first of Melissa Barton’s, MC ’02, career as the Curator of Drama and Prose in the Yale Collection of Literature, and will be the last on Beinecke’s walls before it closes its doors for renovation this summer.
At an opening reception for the Beinecke’s new exhibitions on Fri., Jan. 30, Barton told me that the inspiration for Casting Shadows struck when she found a personal letter describing Robeson’s act of rebellion. Intrigued by the artifact, Barton searched for more correspondence that would illuminate the full history at which Robeson’s letter hinted.
Casting Shadows invites viewers to follow the history Barton uncovered through an as- semblage of letters, playbills, photographs, and more. Most of the material comes from the Clippings File of the Beinecke’s James Weldon Johnson Memorial Collection, compiled from materials sent by prominent figures like Carl Van Vechten and Langston Hughes. A newspaper clipping from the New York Times Sunday paper in 1973 asks “Should Black Actors Play Chekhov?” (Maya Angelou and Ed Bullins, featured in the article, wrote “yes.”) A letter from Langston Hughes, concise and typewritten, contains a postscript in green ink longer than the note itself. With an immediacy and intimacy often lost in secondary accounts, these materials document the changing role of race in American theater.
The materials rest in two wide, semi-circular cases that face each other from opposite ends of the Beinecke’s mezzanine and together encompass the full history Barton sought to display. The case on the north end provides a chronological review of racial integration from 1875 to 1985. Playbills with flourished autographs and stage notes annotated in hasty script line the shelves. In the southern case, Barton features three individuals—Robeson, director Lloyd Rich- ards, and producer Philip Rose—who, she says, “were instrumental in creating integrated casts.”
Robeson’s section, which includes the letter that inspired Casting Shadows, details the challenges and triumphs of the foremost African American actor in an era of integrated casts and still-segregated theaters. Although trained as a lawyer, Robeson left the courtroom for the stage just two years after graduating from Columbia University in 1922. Through starring roles in productions like All God’s Chillun Got Wings (postponed temporarily in 1924 after controversy erupted over his on-stage kiss with a white actress) and Othello in 1934 (of that performance, Vanity wrote “no white man should ever dare presume to play [the Moor] again”), Robeson established himself as a prominent actor unafraid to challenge conventions and pur- sue his art.
Producer Philip Rose’s papers introduce viewers to a man who, as Barton noted, “was not a household name,” but was nevertheless essential in promoting African-American arts on the American stage. “Nobody really knows much about Rose, and here we have his papers,” Barton said. Rose, a white Jewish-American, befriended a 19-year-old waitress with playwriting ambi- tions named Lorraine Hansberry in 1949. Ten years later, Rose brought her play A Raisin to the Sun to the stage for the first time.
Rose did so with the help of director Lloyd Richards who, like Robeson, left a career in law to pursue theater. When Hansberry’s play debuted on Broadway in 1959, Richards debuted as well, and became the first African American to direct a Broadway production. That success won him further involvement with Broadway musicals, at the time considered, the exhibition notes, “unprecedented roles for a black director.” One treasure within his display, however, captures his historic beginnings: a thick, yellowed book containing Richards’s personal notes for A Raisin in the Sun, scrawled in faded blue ink.
With a keen and critical eye, Barton has shed light on a complex, interesting, and often unexamined history. In her display of materials composed of clean, type-written print, adorned with inky, handwritten annotations in blue, red, and green pens, Barton shows that integration in American theater was about more than black and white. It was about adding more color, hearing different voices, and giving new life to the American stage.