What did you sing in the shower this morning? How did it sound?
If you sing like me, it was probably far from perfect. Maybe, though, you’re one of the lucky ones, someone who magically knows how to turn words into music without any help.
For the rest of us, there’s no need for that talent anymore. We’ve got machines that turn anyone, regardless of ability, into a pitch-perfect singer.
Take everyone’s favorite North Alabama news clip, for example. Antoine Dodson just wanted to get the word out to his neighbors that someone may be climbing in their windows and snatching their people up. His interview on WAFF-48 in Huntsville was funny enough as-is, but it was taken to a whole new viral level when the Gregory Brothers added a backing beat, auto-tuned Dodson’s voice, and creatively rearranged his words into a song. A classic of information-age entertainment, the “Bed Intruder Song,” was born.
What startled me was that the song peaked at #89 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart and was the most downloaded song on iTunes for what seemed like an eternity.
And that he told Katie Couric on the CBS Evening News that he wanted to do another song.
Because honestly, he never even did one.
Yet, thanks to the wonders of auto-tuning, even people who aren’t singers can sing the most popular song in the country. Everyone has the ability to be a star; it doesn’t take talent, skill, practice or even the knowledge that you’re performing anymore. You — yes, you who sang that Bruno Mars song in the shower this morning — could one day top the charts, sounding like a robot the whole time.
Instrumentally changing the pitch of one’s voice isn’t new. Back in the 1970s, guitarists such as Peter Frampton used talkboxes on their guitars. Pretty much the same thing, you’re taking an instrumental sound and using it as a voice, right?
Except Frampton and others knew the talkbox was just a gimmick. It sounded cool, but it was essentially a weird-sounding guitar effect. I even built one out of an old speaker in high school, but it wasn’t a serious instrument, and I knew it wasn’t a way to turn a terrible singer like me into a star.
We know what Frampton’s unadulterated voice sounds like, because it’s all over most of his classic talkbox songs, including “Do You Feel Like We Do?”
Do we really know how T-Pain and Justin Bieber sing without digital assistance?
When I buy a song, I want to hear a human voice. I want the singer to tell me a story, to inject some passion into it, and to leave me with some kind of emotional response. I want music that is honest and relatable, not something neat and perfect, every mistake masked by technology.
Music has often been called a universal language. It allows us to communicate emotion with more than just words. The inflection and tone of a voice often express what a song is about far better than the lyrics.
Imagine Frank Sinatra’s “My Way” robbed of its soaring intensity by digital adulteration. Imagine if the voices of a gospel choir were all robbed of their heartfelt praise by computers making every pitch perfect. Suddenly, hiding your imperfections makes the song seem less like music and more like just going through the motions and letting a producer at a computer do the art.
So when you sing in the shower, regardless of what you sing, how does it sound? Is it any less real without the producer and thousands of dollars of software? Or is it just an unfiltered, uncorrupted, beautifully imperfect rendition of how you feel?