Column: Well if you have got nothing to hide…

By Ryan Toll

Then you shouldn’t mind if we take a look. At least, that’s what those in power keep saying to justify their invasions of our privacy. They put this forward as an objective, universal principal. If that’s the case, then it should apply to them just as it applies to us. WikiLeaks has called their bluff and shown it for what it is – an excuse to abuse – and our ignoble rulers are crying foul.

The thieves and thugs that claim to represent and protect us are following a simple formula for control that’s as old as the ages. A rule is put forward as an objective, universal principal of virtue, then is immediately followed by an exception for the abuser. In fact, the abusers are often given the exact opposite rule. They are claimed to be obligated to do what is unacceptable for others to do. Through this, the victim’s own virtue is warped and used to subjugate him.

This formula is utilized in both the political sphere and the personal sphere. A clear identifying feature of this is that the power is always only one-way. The rulers should monitor our communications, but we shouldn’t monitor their communications. The rulers should subject us to invasive searches of our person, but we shouldn’t search the rulers. The rulers should impose commitments on us that we are legally obligated to follow, but we shouldn’t hold them to their commitments to us.

If they had any honor, they would abandon any rule that they aren’t willing to subject themselves to. Then again, since when have the rulers been known to be honorable men?

It is interesting to note what it is that the rulers are afraid of is being brought to light. They must not be afraid of what WikiLeaks has already released, since there were no calls for the assassination of Julian Assange months ago when the Iraq war logs were released. Sure, the logs revealed war crimes and video evidence of the murder of innocent Iraqis, including children, but the response was underwhelming. There was little public outcry and the rulers had nothing to fear. What the rulers are most likely afraid of is what might be released in the future; something that might be very damaging to those in power.

According to contemporary philosopher and podcaster Stefan Molyneux, what the rulers fear is likely the rumored Bank of America leak to be released early this year.

When the financial collapse came, there was a huge wave of mortgage defaults and as a result, many of these people had their homes foreclosed and taken by their bank. However, mortgage-backed securities were the vogue of the time, and mortgages were being sliced and diced before being scattered to the four winds.

Molyneux suspects that the coming leak will reveal that Bank of America knowingly foreclosed on homes that they did not own. In fact, it may well be legally impossible to foreclose on these homes since the ownership of the mortgages is so convoluted. He suspects that this is what will finally hit home for people and there will be a public uproar. Further, a new financial sector crisis will emerge as banks’ assets are called into question and their asset-to-debt ratios plummet.

The thieves and thugs of the ruling class have pulled the wool over our eyes, are robbing us blind and committing atrocious crimes in our name. WikiLeaks is just the latest and most visible attempt at trying to help us see this injustice.

Don’t shoot the messenger. WikiLeaks didn’t commit these crimes, nor will stopping the leaks stop the crimes. Besides, isn’t an informed public a necessary part of the democracy that everyone claims to worship?

Read more here: http://media.barometer.orst.edu/media/storage/paper854/news/2011/01/10/Forum/Well-If.You.Have.Got.Nothing.To.Hide-3968020.shtml
Copyright 2026 OSU Daily Barometer