McWilliams: Is Halloween really what you think it is?

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

Imagine someone from a different culture, arrives in the United States and asks you to explain Halloween. They want to know what it’s about, where it’s from, why we carve into giant orange squashes and how we’re able to make bunny costumes look suggestive.

“How does this all add up?” they might ask. Most of us wouldn’t be able to explain these beloved traditions on our own.

I asked students at University of Oregon what they knew about the origins of Halloween and found a variety of different guesses.

“I’m almost certain that it was originally to celebrate the devil or something pretty hardcore, said Brandon Tribble, a business administration major at UO. “That’s why there’s a lot of controversy about it.”

“It started as All Hallow’s Eve, right?” senior Stuart Adamson asked. “You’re supposed to dress up to scare away all the ghosts.”

It’s no wonder that people don’t talk much about the history of Halloween because it all sounds scary as hell.

What is now known as Halloween isn’t from a single tradition, but three. Martha Bayless, an English professor at UO who specializes in medieval studies, explained to me that “almost all of the pieces of our Halloween are traditional, just not in this combination.” She went on to explain the separate customs that make up Halloween as we know it.

The first is the Celtic festival of Samhain, and often what people assume Halloween derives from because it was “pagan” — which sounds creepy and cool. Samhain was more of a fair, containing no supernatural elements — until the culture was Christianized and introduced to All Hallows.

The second tradition is All Hallows or All Saints Day — a Catholic holiday to honor the saints. But the evening before, All Hallows Eve, was believed to be a night where the “curtain between the worlds of the living and the dead was lifted,” Bayless said. This night, ghosts and spirits could mingle on earth.

Finally, in England in the Middle Ages, children and adults alike would go about the neighborhood in search of goodies — like candy, money for the poor or donations to the church. This was seen on occasions and local holidays, and participants were dressed in scary costumes. Participants would pretend to be evil spirits asking for money so they wouldn’t bring evil to a neighbor’s house. Other times, those dressed up would offer to scare evil spirits away in exchange for a gift. The English also carved (creepy) faces on to turnips.

As people of different cultures migrated to America, the traditions combined and Halloween was born.

Of the traditions that have continued on from the Middle Ages to now, professor Bayless listed, “carving jack-o-lanterns, dressing up and playing pranks and finding ways to create light as darkness comes earlier, like bonfires.”

One Halloween tradition that is the most recent and authentically American is the sexualizing of costumes.

“That one came out of nowhere,” Bayless said. It’s true that many adults and especially college students have created their own twist on Halloween by discovering how many children’s costumes you can throw the word “sexy” in front of.

Sexy or not, costumes have certainly become the main event of many people’s Halloween festivities.

“It’s fun to have an excuse to wear a costume that you couldn’t get away with wearing any other time,” said Abigail Silva, an office and communications coordinator for the Career Center at UO.

Now Oct. 31 isn’t even the entire extent of this event. Halloween includes pumpkin patches, apple cider, haunted houses and pumpkin spiced lattes.

Tricking, treating or sexing up every animal costume imaginable, Halloween celebrators today just want to have a good time.

Human physiology major Taylor Nieri sees Halloween today as an opportunity “to dress up, be super goofy, get lots of candy and just be super unserious.”

Kerri Hilton, a senior from Astoria, Oregon, explained today’s Halloween very clearly: “Two simple words: have fun.”

Follow Lindsay McWilliams on Twitter @lindsaymacwill

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2014/10/23/is-halloween-really-what-you-think-it-is/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media