I’m afraid because I don’t know if that’s the right word. Even if I’m talking about rape as it’s legally defined, should I say sexual assault? Should I say sexual misconduct? I’m honestly still not really sure, so sometimes I’m afraid to talk about it. I’m even more afraid to write about it because a verbal misstep is one thing, but if I mess up in print, it sticks. Two weeks ago I wrote a cover story in this newspaper on this subject, and I felt myself struggling to find the right words.
This isn’t just a question of semantics. It’s actually an important debate and a conversation that demands our attention. The definitions of rape, sexual assault, and sexual misconduct are different but often overlapping. The legal differences between these terms are tough to parse through, further complicated by differing personal definitions. The connotations of the words make it even more confusing. “Rape” has violent roots—the word comes from the Latin verb “rapere,” meaning to “seize” or “take by force.” The word grabs your attention. But it also implies a violence that might instill fear or inaccurately reflect some experiences. So should we say rape?
Yes, I think—after you carefully consider what you’re trying to say. That said, I’m still afraid to say “rape,” and I’m afraid it to write it, even after I look up legal definitions and etymologies; this is part of the problem with discussions of sexual climate on campus today. I feel uncomfortable entering discussions because I’m afraid that the stakes for a verbal or written slip-up are too high. This fear isn’t just mine. It’s something I’ve observed in the conversations I’ve had about this over the past month. It leads to a reliance on abstract language that prevents us from saying what we mean. This has been particularly visible in the “It’s On Us, Yale” campaign, a White House initiative that the YCC brought to campus this fall. We’re scared of making people uncomfortable, of sounding insensitive or offensive. So we keep these thoughts to ourselves, and we lose the potential to deepen conversation. We find ourselves having repetitive discussions dominated by platitudes and language that’s often meaningless. Our maybe controversial, maybe wrong thoughts go unsaid and uncorrected.
It’s not just fear of saying the wrong word. It’s fear of expressing an idea that might be offensive. I’m complicit. I’m sometimes guilty of thoughts that border on slut-shaming. When someone makes a joke about a girl hooking up with “too many” guys on the same sports team, my split-second instinct is sometimes, “Well, why did she hook up with so many guys on the same sports team?” And my second instinct is, “Wow, did I really just think that? That’s messed up. I probably shouldn’t tell anyone.”
I believe that she should be able to do whatever she wants, with whomever she wants, as long as it’s consensual. He should be able to, too. There shouldn’t be any shame for anyone involved. My seconds of unchecked slut-shaming prove that I am a product of a negative culture where this shame still exists. But I’m afraid to say so.
This fear comes from a good place. It comes from recognizing that what we say is really, really important. That a rape joke perpetuates rape culture. That what we say can constitute sexual misconduct. That words are incredibly powerful and we should choose them thoughtfully. We should be careful and conscious when we speak and write. There are lines that we should never cross. But being overly careful and conscious inhibits conversations that could actually make a difference. When we talk about improving sexual climate, we need to be specific.
These discussions have been happening more frequently on campus, thanks in some part to the “It’s On Us” campaign. The conversations, hosted by student groups around campus, are ideal places for honest discourse, but I’m afraid that much of the discourse is affected by anxiety about verbal and written mistakes. Thirty seven student groups have posted photos on the Facebook page so far, featuring a “vision statement” and a series of concrete steps that the group plans to take towards that vision. (This newspaper posted one last week.) But the tone of the pledges tends towards the abstract—cautiously edited affirmations of “supportive community” and “empowerment.” The word “rape” has yet to appear in any of them.
Maybe it doesn’t need to. You could argue that, as a community, we recognize that rape is wrong and that the word actually alienates people or scares people, instead of working towards an ideal—which is the point of “It’s On Us, Yale.” But I would argue that the abstractions can be alienating too. They lack specificity; they’re difficult to unpack and understand. They also confine the discussion to a limited window of terminology, a reliance on the cliché—“constructive conversations,” “looking out for each other,” “empowerment.”
But what does “empowerment” actually mean? It comes up 14 times in the pledges. The “We Will” section, which is supposed to be concrete—and in the case of some pledges, it succeeds in that goal—falls more often into abstract territory. Even though I Iooked up its definition, I still don’t know what the term “empowerment” points to besides a notion of confidence. How do we achieve “empowerment” for a community or individual? What does it look like? I don’t know. Still, I say it and I write it because I know it’s a good, safe word. I know it’s a word that knowledgeable, socially conscious people use.
We can’t change anything if there’s a linguistic barrier to participation in conversations about sexual climate, especially if people are afraid to express themselves and fall back on terms that they know are safe. If, in conversations that are supposed to be open, we’re censoring ourselves into obscurity before we speak or write, we lose the opportunity to let others edit us. We lose the opportunity to have our thoughts challenged and our minds and culture changed.
So, next time you’re talking about sexual culture, be conscious but don’t censor yourself. If you think that rape is the right term, don’t be afraid to say it. Don’t be afraid to ask if it’s the right term. If it’s the wrong term, you can learn why it’s wrong, and if it’s the right term you can use it without being afraid to. When you think, “I definitely couldn’t say that out loud,” say it out loud and ask people what they think. Allow people to challenge you, and challenge other people. Don’t use a word that seems safe just because it’s safe. Using the right words is important, but don’t be afraid to use the wrong words first.
That’s what I’m trying to do now. In writing this piece, I struggled a lot with my words. I wasn’t sure how to communicate which conversations can stimulate change and which ones are regressive. I wasn’t sure which language I could use. I found myself slipping into vague terms because I was afraid to mess up. But I’m doing my best to push back against that fear. I’m still not sure I used the right words, but I’m going to try.