A toxic asset

Originally Posted on The Yale Herald via UWIRE

“A substantial threat,” the Coast Guard said in a statement on Tues., Sept. 30 concerning an oil spill leaking into New Haven’s Mill River. The contamination he referred to stems from English Station in Fair Haven, an abandoned toxic power plant that has afflicted the environment, government, and community for the past two decades. Backed by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Connecticut’s Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP), Coast Guard boats have been patrolling the river for the past two weeks, attempting to clean the waters and assess damage.

But the Coast Guard’s latest warnings merely echo the many about the plant that have accumulated over the years. City officials, state agencies, environmental activists, and New Haven locals alike have been advocating for action for decades, but unreliable and irresponsible owners have repeatedly prevented the cleanup and redevelopment of the site.

Situated in Fair Haven just one and a half miles east of Cross Campus on a small island in the middle of the Mill River, English Station has been the focal point of New Haven’s industrial transformation and decline, the formation of an environmental justice movement, and decades of clashes among the interests of the local community, the Connecticut state government, and predatory real estate companies. Right now, the plant is a vacant “weapon of mass contamination,” according to local environmental activist Aaron Goode, a member of the executive board of the Downtown and Wooster Square Community Management Team.

Currently, the plant can be classified as a “mothballed brownfield,” a contaminated industrial site whose owners refuse to adopt a feasible plan for reuse. A potentially unstable structure, the plant is susceptible to severe weather patterns—one major storm could jeopardize water quality, public health, and the city’s economy. Unless the current web of litigation is resolved or more accountable owners take over the site, the degradation of English Station could potentially prove disastrous for the larger Fair Haven area and the surrounding environment.

***

“Somber, huge, mysterious—seen only from a distance beyond locked gates—this building towers over the dark river. Futurist fantasies, reveries of medieval strongholds, and electric minarets in a white cloud of smoke produce one of the city’s most haunting architectural images,” reads an excerpt from Elizabeth Mills Brown’s 1976 book New Haven: A Guide to Architecture and Urban Design. Despite the nearly 40-year gap separating its publication and the moment when I stood on Grand Avenue gazing at English Station last Wednesday, this description still applies.

Brown captured the essence of the now abandoned power plant, built in the 1920s and in operation until 1991. As I stood facing the plant’s home, Ball Island, on a weed-lined sidewalk littered with broken glass and disintegrating food wrappers, I tried to imagine English Station in its prime, when United Illuminating (UI) operated it for powering the city’s factories.

In 1881, a group of local businessmen founded UI, originally named the New Haven Electric Light Company. New Haven soon became one of the first cities in America to be lit by electricity. To accommodate the increased post-war demand for electricity, UI built English Station on an island in the center of Mill River. The area was initially a fishing village situated over marshland, but the neighborhood soon expanded and urbanized. With a steady power supply, factories operated more efficiently, and streetcar lines brought residents directly from their homes to the Winchester Repeating Arms Factory, a major employment hub. According to Corsets and Clocks, Carriages and Locks, a book about the industrial history of New Haven, English Station provided power to more than 120,000 individuals, businesses, and industrial customers within a year of its construction. Over the course of the next decade, UI continued to expand the capacity of the station and build up the landmass at Ball Island.

The plant was initially fired by coal until UI converted it into a gas plant in the 1940s. English Station continued to provide power to the city of New Haven until the early 1990s, when the outdated equipment made the plant no longer economically feasible to run. The amount of power it could produce wasn’t worth the cost of fuel combined with the polluting impacts of burning diesel. Decades of coal sludge, metals, and cancerous PCBs accumulated on the site, seeping into the structure of the building and the surrounding soil. Other companies must have realized this, too. Failing to find a buyer, UI sat on this unwieldy, toxic asset for several years. Eventually, in 2000, UI paid the company Quinnipiac Energy 4.25 million dollars to take the plant off its hands.

***

The EPA defines environmental justice as “the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people…with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.” Across the United States, the placement of transfer stations, polluting industries, and waste management facilities frequently leads to environmental injustice. Often, policies force low-income neighborhoods to suffer the burden of environmental costs from proximity to toxic plants like English Station. Quinnipiac Energy’s plans for the site fit this trajectory of violating this ideal of a shared environmental hazard burden.

Quinnipiac Energy’s first and only attempt to make the plant economically viable triggered mass community action and the formation of an environmental justice movement in New Haven. When Quinnipiac Energy assumed the property, they planned to convert English Station into a peaking plant. Peaking plants produce energy only at times of highest demand—the height of the summer, for example, when businesses and homes run air conditioners. Quinnipiac Energy planned to provide this power to upper-middle class areas in Fairfield County and Long Island, rather than the surrounding working class, low-income neighborhood of Fair Haven.

Christel Manning, the former president of the New Haven Environmental Justice Network (NHEJN), described that it would aggravate New Haven air quality, making it among the worst in the nation during the summer. At the time that Quinnipiac Energy took over, child asthma rates in New Haven were three times the national average. Manning said, “This neighborhood was going to suffer so that people in Long Island could get cheap power.” Lee Cruz, the community outreach director at the Community Foundation for Greater New Haven, added to this picture. “Many Fair Haven residents can’t afford air conditioning, so in the summer they’re opening up their windows and breathing in the toxins,” he said.

In response, these activists, alongside other citizens-turned-activists, mounted a campaign to stop Quinnipiac Energy from converting English Station to a peaking plant. Local environmentalists joined a group of Fair Haven residents to form the NHEJN. “The regulatory process gives the public the opportunity to partake in community decisions,” said Lynne Bonnett, a board member of the Greater New Haven Green Fund and former chair of the NHEJN. “We can educate ourselves and get polluting facilities to pay attention to what they are doing, and how they can help.”

As a result of their efforts to call attention to the situation in Fair Haven, the organization connected with the national environmental movement, seeking to illustrate how poor people end up bearing the brunt of pollution and environmental hazards. Manning cited zoning codes that have contributed in part to this trend—because cities tend to have industrial zoning rights, it’s easier for companies to build polluting plants in urban centers. But government regulation isn’t fully responsible for environmental injustice. People with resources can better defend themselves and their property, triggering a recurring cluster of trash incinerators, dumps, and other polluters in poorer communities. No one wants an environmental hazard in their backyard, but low-income neighborhoods often lack the time, funding, or resources to combat these decisions.

Despite these systemic hurdles, the NHEJN held meetings, staged rallies, and attended hearings to push their message and mission. Bonnett explained that the NHEJN made the movement easy for people to understand and ultimately support. The odds weren’t exactly stacked in their favor, though. Manning explained the basic premise behind environmental regulation—when a company wants to open a polluting facility, their permit must fall within the state’s pollution guidelines. But these regulations don’t account for clustered facilities or peaking plants, which typically fall well below the limit of the allotted energy use per year. At the state environmental hearings, overseen by the DEP, the agency then in charge, Quinnipiac Energy’s measurements continued to meet the necessary criteria. The committee recommended approval for the peaking plant permits.

But then Richard Blumenthal, LAW ’73, the Connecticut attorney general at the time, intervened: he threatened to sue the DEP if they upheld their own committee’s findings. This action thrust the DEP Commissioner, Arthur Roque, into the spotlight of what had turned into an impending legal and environmental mess. Roque, with an eye towards upcoming changes in national EPA regulations, overturned the committee’s ruling on the proposal. “The commissioner has the power to accept or modify proposals,” said Dennis Schain, the current spokesperson for DEEP, the agency that replaced DEP. “To totally deny it is unusual. To this date, that doesn’t happen often.” In the final decision, Roque wrote, “I believe that the costs or impacts, both real and potential, of reopening a power plant that could have a detrimental impact on the health of the residents of New Haven outweigh the proposed benefits the small amount of electric power the plant will provide to the New England grid.” He added, “Solutions to real societal needs or problems, be they energy shortages or air pollution, are only indirectly served and the most environmentally sound solution is even more tangential.” The tenets of environmental justice had formed the basis of the language of his decision.

Bonnett, of the NHEJN, commented on the personal consequences of the decision, calling it a fluke: “Art Roque took a tremendous amount of heat from the industry doing what he did.” Roque retired within the year. Depending who you ask, his decision either led to the downfall of his career or it represents his parting gift to the State of Connecticut. Both the environmental activists and the former New Haven city government officials I spoke with reflected on this ruling with gratitude. “The DEP Commissioner had a lot of credit. He didn’t get a lot of support from his boss, but he did it. It was a big victory for New Haven,” said Robert Smuts, SM ’01, the city chief administrative officer in John DeStefano’s mayoral administration.

Despite this initial victory, it soon became clear that finding a solution for English Station would continue to present a formidable challenge for the community and New Haven at large.

***

Once the Fair Haven neighborhood and the statewide environmental justice movement finished celebrating, remediation for English Station stagnated. Over 10 years have passed now, but the power plant still sits empty, haunting Ball Island and towering over the Mill River District. The legal disputes, environment hazards, and government interventions, however, haven’t ceased.

A few years after Roque denied their permits, Quinnipiac Energy sold the plant to two companies, Asnat Realty and Evergreen Power. Since then, the record of responsible ownership has not improved. Granted, touching the property requires a serious investment in decontamination procedures, because the site is practically a toxic bomb from the asbestos, PCBs, and almost a century of oil and coal contaminants that have soaked into the soil and lace the plant’s entire structure. “The current owners are pursuing a demolition by neglect strategy,” Smuts said. Power stations are built substantially, with internal steel structures, but the lack of maintenance and its exposed position on the island leave it vulnerable to potential collapse. Neither residents living and working down the street nor people driving down the heavily trafficked Interstate-91 can neglect its presence, or its impact on the space.

Asnat and Evergreen in turn tried to hand off the property to another company, also called Ball Island, in 2010. The closing kept getting delayed. During this time, Asnat and Evergreen, without filing for permission, tried to sell some of the oil from the old transformers in the plant to an oil recycling facility, which ended up reporting the incident to the EPA. The oil was 99 percent contaminated by PCBs, cancer causing toxins that have been banned by the EPA since 1979. “Oil from old transformers is going to have PCBs. You don’t need a PhD from the Yale Forestry School to know that,” said Aaron Goode, of the Downtown and Wooster Square Development Team. When Ball Island heard about this incident, and the subsequent investigations by the EPA and DEEP, they attempted to drop the deal. They hoped to evade the burden of these mounting legal problems and possession of the toxic property.

While this case has been pending, the tensions between ownership, environmental damage, and Connecticut’s regulatory powers have continued in full force. In the spring of 2013, the Connecticut attorney general’s office and DEEP issued an administrative order calling for a cleanup of the site. In compliance with environmental policy, all owners, previous and current, have responsibility to address the contamination. Britton Rogers, ARC ’14, who studied Environmental Design at the Yale School of Architecture and serves on the board of directors of the Urban Resources Initiative at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, summed up the situation: “It’s intended to be confusing. No one wants to take possession.”

Consistent with previous attempts to evade accountability for the property, the owners contested the order. According to DEEP spokesperson Dennis Schain, it’s currently wrapped up in court. “Because of the costs involved in cleanup, people are not eagerly stepping in and assuming them,” Shain said. “It often takes time and pressure and lots of legal wrangling on some sites to get cleanup underway.” All signs point to more time, increased pressure, and extended legal wrangling for all parties involved in English Station.

As I learned more about the impossibly complicated and dangerously neglected property, I wondered if there is any end in sight to the stagnation. New Haven’s Economic Development Administrator Matthew Nemerson, SOM ’81, offered a different perspective, countering the voices that lauded the peaking plant decision as a victory. He argued that the reopening of English Station as a peaking plant would have necessarily spurred the same actions that environmentalists are now asking for. “It was a metaphoric concern,” Nemerson said. “These neighborhoods tend to get treated badly by industries. People pollute and walk away. But it probably would have resulted in cleanup and brought in taxes and jobs.” In fact, according to Nemerson, most of the pollution that affects Connecticut actually comes from Ohio.

The current reality of legal and political entrenchment is daunting. UI still carries some of the liability in their accounts, but the question of what portion of cleanup each past and present owner should assume is unclear and contentious. Stewardship of the property has been neglectful at best and deleterious at worst, not only for the property, but also for Fair Haven, the Mill River, and New Haven as a whole.

At one point, Asnat and Evergreen pursued an ill-conceived demolition strategy that the city halted because it endangered the environment, according to Smuts. Recently the two companies discussed a preliminary plan to convert the station into residences, but power plants rarely translate well into homes or offices, because, unlike factories, they aren’t built for a human scale.

For most involved parties, the most attractive solution would entail the preservation of the historic structure, not its demolition. The building’s Gothic arches, high windows, and intricate detailing along the upper brickwork serve as physical reminders of the plant’s significance to the city’s history. In a rare moment of clarity in an otherwise entangled affair, the economic, environmental, and historical interests might just intersect. The question remains exactly how.

***

The day after visiting English Station I walked down tree-lined State Street to the offices of the New Haven Preservation Trust. The offices fill a converted Victorian home that bears the oval blue plaque that signifies its designation on the National Register of Historic Places. If English Station were added to this registry, remediation could be potentially sped up. I meet with Preservation Services Officer John Herzan in a simple, light-filled room. Herzan pulled one of the Historic Resources Inventory volumes from the shelves. Connecticut amassed this list of historical and architectural properties in the 1980s. “The state regards it as a historic place even though it hasn’t been officially listed. Connecticut has a wealth of these industrial sites,” Herzan said.

According to Anstress Farwell, the President of the New Haven Urban Design League, the State Historic Preservation Office has indicated interest in designating a district of the city that would include the power station and a nearby trolley barn, thematically connecting its industrial and architectural history. At this point, English Station has not been formally nominated. Trying to untangle the legal struggles, determine ownership, and assign responsibility for cleanup seems to supercede concerns regarding its historic status.

At the same time, the historic weight of the property is evident, as is its central role in New Haven’s history. The grand Art Deco style plays on its identity as a power station, and self-referential motifs such as lightning bolts represent this idea. Farwell said that during the 1920s, when English Station was under construction, factories, streetcar owners, and power companies jumpstarted the use of electric power in cities around Connecticut and around the country. They faced public concern over electricity; many people thought it would be dangerous in the home. To combat this image, “A lot of power companies built something that suggested a larger civic purpose,” Farwell told me. “They could be put into plain sheds, but what they did was create something with enormous weight and gravity and design that was really a civic presence, an institution on par with others in the city.” Britton Rogers similarly praised the physical presence of the plant: “It’s a cathedral of power generation.” Throughout the 1920s, Farwell said that companies invested in architecture to establish faith and goodwill in a community, while simultaneously combating skepticism and fear regarding urban industrialization.

These themes of community faith and goodwill eroded over the course of the century. The abandoned power plant stands as a constant, looming portent of future environmental calamities, a corrosive vacuum where remediation could provide the key to the economic betterment of Fair Haven. Examples of successfully redeveloped and cleaned up power plants provide hope for this site. In London, Bankside Power Station was transformed into the Tate Modern. In Seattle in the 1970s, the architect Richard Haag executed a plan that converted the property around a rusting and decrepit power plant into a public space, called Gasworks Park. He left the plant standing as a sculptural civic element, fencing the actual structure off but covering the ground in new soil to seal off the toxicity. Now, visitors can explore the landscaped hills and children can play in a piece of the structure that has been converted into a play barn. Seattle bought the property for park purposes in the sixties, so the community never dealt with the ongoing ownership battles that English Station has faced.

Rogers, who graduated this past spring, enrolled in Wild Urbanism, a School of Architecture course, in which he envisioned an alternate future for English Station. The class focused on reclaiming abandoned industrial sites, and the students had to identify locations in New Haven to “reuse, rejuvenate, and remediate,” Rogers said. He chose English Station for his project, proposing the use of green space and plants to remediate the soil and transform the station into a biofuel power generator. The plants used for cleaning the soil could then be burned in the station for fuel, establishing a cycle of sustainability. “I thought that with the towers and roof lines, the smoke stacks on top of the plant could be used as a bird sanctuary. It’s right on the river, situated on a corridor for bird migration.” Siding with the historic preservation contingent, Rogers is firmly against demolition: “It’s the best thing on the skyline.”

***

City officials seem inclined to agree with Rogers’ desire to preserve the structure. As I was exploring the area around English Station, I came across several fresh white street signs branded with a black image of the power station, designed to fuse the historic and the futurist. The title “Mill River District” sits on top of the graphic; the bottom reads “Made in New Haven.” At first, it seems ironic that this recently conceived rebranding strategy would showcase the symbol of the neighborhood’s decline and subsequent inertia, but at the same time, that image signifies a reimagined future for the plant.

DeStefano’s administration commissioned the Mill River District Planning Study and Redevelopment Framework in 2014, which laid plans for job growth, a build up of coastal resiliency, and expanding industrial and commercial bases. Mike Piscitelli, New Haven’s deputy economic development administrator, said, “One of the real insights we got from the study was that the Mill River lacked identity. We tasked design consultants to create identity for the district, to find something to capture it. You can see the plant anywhere from the district, and it has a deeper symbolism in that visual identity for the area.”

Matthew Nemerson, another New Haven economic administrator, added, “When you have a massive box with huge smokestacks in the middle of an island in the middle of town, you become iconic for good and for bad.” The proliferation of that image in rebranding the neighborhood serves as a subtle reminder for the work left ahead, particularly in light of the recent oil leak and the ongoing ownership litigation. While Goode called the plant “the linchpin of reactivating the area,” Nemerson recognized the difficulties that this reality represents. “Obviously we will be doing lots of reimaging and reinvesting in Mill River before we start getting to the power plant,” he said.

But with the ongoing oil leak threat, English Station may not be able to wait another 23 years. On Tuesday, after hearing about this latest development in the perpetual saga on the Mill River, I contacted Nemerson again. He offered some words of assurance, “It’s clear what our powers are in terms of regulatory enforcement and what the mayor’s powers are from the bully pulpit. We’ll be on top of this.”

It’s unclear if this latest disaster will finally urge the owners into action, or if English Station will continue to poison the environment and threaten the safety of the Mill River District. Without a change in ownership, progress seems unattainable. When I asked Mayor John DeStefano about the future of the site, he responded, “It’s a puzzle. This may be a piece of property whose future doesn’t get resolved for a number of years. Keep an eye on what happens between I-91 and the Mill River.”

 

-Graphic by Zachary Schiller

Read more here: http://yaleherald.com/news-and-features/a-toxic-asset/
Copyright 2026 The Yale Herald