There are bans that protect us from ourselves, and then there are those that impose regulations that far surpass the law’s jurisdiction. U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood claims motorists are distracted by any use of mobile devices while driving, including hands-free calls, as the department begins discussion of a broader ban. This will only lead to unreasonable bans on in-car aid systems and unnecessary fines for drivers across the nation.
LaHood, who has already enforced tougher restriction in 30 states, said his concerns extend to entertainment systems and driver’s aides such as Ford’s Sync and General Motors’ OnStar, according to bloomberg.com. These system, however, have successfully aided drivers with their safety by making most functions hands-free. OnStar, for example, even alerts the authorities wirelessly of an accident that may have occurred with the driver. Rather than making driving more dangerous, theses systems provide the convenience of hands-free control of car electronics.
The fact of the matter is that the tools, which LaHood is trying to restrict these useful utilities, there are many other distractions that should be banned – or ones that are just as “dangerous” as hands-free talking on a phone. The radio is just one of many distractions that alter drivers’ capabilities. Singing along perhaps, should be banned as well. Talking to a passenger can be considered even more dangerous as the driver turns to look at the person or simply gets too involved in the conversation. There are simply too many other distractions – as the DOT calls them.
“I don’t want people talking on phones, having them up to their ear or texting while they’re driving,” LaHood said in an interview this week. “We need a lot better research on other distractions,” including Bluetooth-enabled hands-free calls and the in-car systems, he said.
LaHood simply doesn’t get it. Banning hands-free devices – let alone the ones that serve the driver more than they affect his ability to drive – does not solve the problems of bad drivers. Strengthening the process of receiving a driver’s license is only one of many other methods of decreasing accidents on the road. Navigation systems, for example, help drivers reach their destinations more safely instead of forcing them to swerve for an exit at the last second. The problem isn’t the devices we use – it is in the drivers we let on the road. LaHood should examine this problem rather than limiting trivial “distractions.”