Food for thought

Originally Posted on The Yale Herald via UWIRE

‘There is no militancy in this room!’ ‘Who cares about your iPhones and blog posts?’ ‘What is this resistance?’” Justine Appel, ES ’15, recites back to me some of the things she recently heard at Black Farmers and Urban Gardeners, a conference organized by a group called Black Urban Growers. Appel’s trip to the Brooklyn meeting was recommended by her professor as a supplement to her course, “Social Justice in the Food System.”

It’s a volunteer day on the Yale Farm, just off of Prospect on Edwards Street, where Appel interns as a farm manager. She consults the whiteboard of weekly tasks: the start of the winter season is traditionally marked with planting garlic, so boxes of the pungent cloves sit patiently in the propagation house, waiting to be planted. Appel’s priorities are with the volunteers, as they tend to Hakurei turnips and Chioggia beets. “We’re putting the turnips to bed,” she proclaims as she blankets the row with fabric.

Appel is an Environmental Studies ma- jor concentrating in Food and Agriculture. She credits her time on the farm and her connections with the Yale Sustainable Food Project (YSFP) for sparking her interest in learning about farming in the classroom— her coursework includes the requirements of the major, but she has creatively woven a few classes from the School of Forestry and Environmental Studies into her curriculum like the one she is taking right now.

As soon as next year, the Blue Book might contain a new section for the Food Studies Undergraduate Scholars program. The pro- gram was recently proposed in an effort to bring an organized means of studying food, like Appel’s, to anyone in any major. But now she has exercised caution with choosing her academic path. “Recently, I’ve been thinking a lot about why I shouldn’t be studying food, but embedding myself in a community and enacting change that way.” The aforementioned militancy that one conference-goer urged struck a chord with Appel: is the best way to help an ailing food system one that comes from direct action, or is it actually worth studying academically? Whatever the case, Appel’s Yale education will be defined by her study of food.

***

Course selection period at Yale requires a bit of creativity in choosing which classes to “shop.” While the suggested concentration of “Food and Agriculture”—one of six explicitly designated concentrations— lives in the Environmental Studies major, other majors allow for a more informal focus, like Psychology, American Studies, and some language majors. Among different departments there are many classes about food, and “Women, Food, and Culture” is one such class, taught by Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Professor Maria Trumpler, GRD ‘92.

For the past five years, Trumpler has noticed that students who complete her course were hungry for more. “When I started teaching ‘Women, Food, and Culture,’ students started to say, ‘Well, what can I take next?’” The on- line version of the Blue Book has made it eas- ier to answer this question with a simple key- word search, replacing the meticulous perusal that finding such courses used to require in the print form of the Programs of Study.

Search results might turn up the following. Classes like Paul Freedman’s “History of Cuisine” evolved from small seminar to large lecture course due to popularity. Professor Kelly Brownell, who recently left Yale to pursue a deanship at Duke University, taught “Psychology, Biology and Politics of Food,” which was always well attended. This semester, Karen Seto is teaching an Environmental Studies seminar titled “Urbanization, Food Systems, and the Environment.”

As it stands, all of these chances to study food remain unlinked in any formal way; determined students have constructed creative food-centric curricula outside of the Environmental Studies major, where the abundance of pre-existing possible concentrations reflects openness in defining one’s specialization. “Some students on their own started putting together interesting combinations of courses and doing interesting senior projects in a variety of departments,” explained Trumpler.

Enter Emily Farr, BK ‘14. A Geology and Geophysics major, her studies have centered around a way for agriculture to mitigate the negative effects of climate change and reduce carbon emissions. As a senior adviser for the YSFP, she participates in monthly meet- ings where the organization crowd-sources student input on the future direction of the YSFP. Given her background in studying food and farming within her major, she had the idea to host a panel on exactly that.

The panel, taking place Nov. 16, will showcase methods of studying food—independent study, extracurricular activity, or summer research fellowships, for example—at an institution that lacks any formal regimen. The event’s goal is to inform freshmen and sophomores about opportunities to learn about food, makeshift as they may be. “It’s important to have some sort of framework so they know it’s possible,” Farr said. If students know their options earlier on, they might choose different paths.

***

The proposal for a program in food studies is the work of professors and leaders across various schools, disciplines and organizations. Trumpler cited YSFP Director Mark Bomford’s 2011 arrival at Yale as the impetus to bring food from the Yale Farm into the classroom. As members of the search committee for a new YSFP director, Trumpler and her colleagues were excited to bring someone who would import the practicum the YSFP provided into a more academic context.

As students started crafting their own food-related paths, professors tangentially connected to food merely bumped shoulders, but in the semesters following Bomford’s appointment, the group of about 112 faculty members have started a conversation about how to structure collaboration from even the farthest corners of the University. Now, the School of Management finally had an excuse to talk with the School of Public Health about nutrition research where it may not had necessarily before.

With the successful passage of the inherently interdisciplinary Energy Studies Under- graduate Scholars program last semester, it established a model that the proposed Food Studies program now seeks to emulate. “A number of us who teach these classes would see each other casually and say, ‘Hey, we really ought to do this,’” Trumpler said. And they did. A food systems studies proposal was created and submitted over the summer to Dean of Yale College Mary Miller, GRD ’81, for faculty approval. A decision is expected to be made as early as this winter.

The proposal is straightforward: three courses related to food, a relevant summer experience (suggesting opportunities at the Yale Farm or Rudd Center), a seminar on research and practice in food studies, meetings about internship and “career-building” opportunities, and privileges to dine at events with speakers and at conferences in the field. The YSFP would provide some of the administrative backbone of the program.

Last semester, Miller convened an ad- hoc committee to establish a framework that would standardize existing and future special programs. The programs, all with different focuses, are first defined by the fact that they are separate from any major that a student can select.

Exemplified by the energy studies pro- gram—the first to be created in this framework—all future special programs will now operate following this model. Even the pre-existing Education Studies Scholars program was revised to conform to these new standards.

As it stands, the Yale College Dean’s Office officially recognizes two somewhat analogous special programs: the Yale Jour- nalism Initiative (YJI) and the Global Health Scholars Program. These programs have been grandfathered into the purview of the Dean’s Office without having to conform to the new mold.

All of these programs exhibit a tendency towards pre-professionalism in that they seek to prepare students for specific ca- reers, like one in journalism or teaching.

According to an 1828 Report by the Yale College Faculty, “A liberal, is obviously distinct from a professional, education.” As the story goes, students try out a variety of disciplines; in the process, they develop the creativity and problem-solving skills that might be demanded of any career. Pre-professionalism is much more limited in scope. Yale College has a longstanding history of upholding the values of a liberal arts education. “In laying the foundation of a thorough education, it is necessary that all the important faculties be brought into exercise…a costly edifice ought not to be left to rest upon a single pillar,” continues the report.

Ironically, when Yale received reaccreditation in 2009, the University was commended by the New England Association of Schools and Colleges (NEASC) for the exchange between its professional schools and the College. According to Dean Miller, “One of the things that NEASC pointed to about the Yale undergraduate curriculum was the success of taking advantage of having such strong and diverse professional schools.”

This is especially true for majors that are closely aligned with professional schools; notably art or architecture, whose established professional schools on campus provide vital resources for undergraduate programs. However, Yale’s graduate programs are limited. For example, students with an interest in journalism participate in the YJI because it offers resources that otherwise might be provided by a journalism school if Yale had one.

At the surface, these programs—smaller than majors, but important enough to warrant a title—look like what most other academic institutions call minors. But Yale’s present academic philosophy doesn’t seem all that different from that of 1828. In a 2010 report issued by the Committee on Majors, the faculty decided the introduction of minors would undermine Yale’s educational philosophy and resources.

“By emphasizing credentials,” explains the report, “Minors might discourage the free-ranging approach to a liberal education traditionally encouraged at Yale.”

On Mon., Apr. 29, 2013, an ad hoc com- mittee of the Dean’s Office released a report that established the requirements of these special programs. Conscious of the conflu- ence between these special programs and minors, this document set out to distinguish the differences. “We see these programs not as minors—that is, less intensive versions of existing majors—nor as trial balloons for new majors, but rather as interdisciplinary or interdepartmental programs not feasible within a single major, enriching the academ- ic opportunities available to Yale students.”

Even with special programs, students must take 36 courses, fulfill distributional requirements, and complete the requisites of a major—still completing a liberal arts education. Special programs are designed to add to the educational experience without necessarily detracting from it.

For instance, a cornerstone of these programs is a fall seminar that allows students to digest and reflect upon their summer experiences in the discipline, instead of letting the experience remain unexamined. These secondary tracks are changing the academic landscape of a Yale education, smoothing out a potentially abrupt transition between summer and academic year.

These programs allow students to structure their liberal arts educations around central questions facing our world today. “The way I think of these special programs is not that they’re fields of study, but they’re re- ally big problems that are facing our world,” Trumpler said. They answer the big questions: how do we revitalize the free press when journalism is declining? How do you solve the crisis in our schools? What do we do when we run out of fossil fuels?

For food studies, the question is, how are we going to feed everybody and do it in a healthy and sustainable way?

***

Near the farm on Prospect Street stands Kroon Hall, a central hub of the School of Forestry and Environmental Studies. On the second floor of the building sits the office of the executive director of the Yale Climate and Energy Institute (YCEI)— but this is one of few designated physical spaces for this “virtual” institute.

According to YCEI Executive Director Mike Oristaglio, BR ‘74, in 2008, a group of faculty members got together and decided to establish an interdisciplinary institute to look at the multifaceted issues of energy and climate. Thus, they created the YCEI as an institute to foster an academic dialogue. Initially, two seniors approached then-Deputy Director Gary Brudvig in order to introduce the institute’s offerings into Yale College. After about four years of planning, the proposal for the Energy Studies Undergraduate Scholars program was ready for formal approval by the faculty.

“There were a lot of energy courses they could see that were popping up in different departments,” Oristaglio said. When students realized the breadth of courses offered, they went so far as to suggest the possibility of a potential new major. That’s a lot of paperwork—an entirely new department would need to be founded to house a program of that rigor. But beyond these practical difficulties, pedagogically speaking, Oristaglio said, “You don’t want to have it as a major.”

Now the model for forthcoming special programs, including the proposed one in food studies, the program requires six courses distributed among three categories (the sciences, social sciences and the environ- mental implications) and a final “capstone” project. This inaugural semester has been, according to Oristaglio, so far so good.

“We expected 25 to 30 students,” he said, but last spring nearly twice that num- ber applied. About 50 students are cur- rently enrolled in the program. High interest has been met with high proactivity. “Many students requested advisors that were dis- tinctly not in their major,” Oristaglio said, an explicit example of the different perspectives from the fledgling program.

“Interdisciplinary tracks like this are the wave of the future everywhere,” continued Oristaglio. “Once you get out of university, you’re in an interdisciplinary setting working with people in different fields. More and more, I think that’s going to become an important component of the educational system.”

***

“When I tell people I’m studying food, a common reaction I’ll get is, ‘Oh, that’s cute,’” said Hallie Meyer, SM ’15, who introduced herself as an English major. “It’s seen as fluffy. Food is ubiquitous, so people never take the chance to think about it critically.”

This semester, Meyer is working with Freedman on an independent study of the history and politics of school food—more specifically, of the school lunch program in the United States. If the food studies program were to become a reality, it would look a lot like what she’s doing right now.

“Thinking critically about food is so important,” Meyer said. “Food is a lens to look at so many subjects.” Her own project is no exception. It combines political science, economics, and lots of history to tell a story.

Bomford agrees. “You find food everywhere,” he said. “In the arts, the sciences, the humanities, the social sciences. It is such a great convener, is such a common ground, and such a source of horribly cheesy metaphors, and because of that it means that it gives you a fresh, ready and relevant perspective for the study of almost anything you can find in Yale’s majors.”

Much like Meyer’s independent project, Bomford envisions a holistic approach to the study of something that does not fit neatly within the domain of any single department. “I would like the study of food systems not to be constrained by disciplinary boundaries,” he said. “I feel that the most proper approach to an introduction to complex food systems is to have the breadth that allows you to understand the intersections between food systems and pretty much every discipline of study that you would find in a liberal arts environment like Yale College.”

Meyer’s independent study consists of a few papers in the classroom and organizing scholarly speakers to come to campus and discuss their experiences studying food. On Nov. 19, she will host Simone Cinotto, a historian at the University of Gastronomic Sciences in Italy, who focuses on Italian food. As an added perk that comes with the study of food, Meyer’s catering operation will be serving treats at this event.

While Meyer enjoys studying food, she also loves making it, which she does through her company, the Northern Greening. Bringing food into the academy, she fears, might strip the fundamentally tangible aspect of food and turn it into hard-to-grasp theory. “Academia can tend to over-theorize anything,” Meyer said. “Students will go through the program and learn a lot of concepts, but at the end of the day may not know what to do with a butternut squash.”

***

Given the success of Eli Whitney, YC 1792, the inventor of the cotton gin, you might imagine a deep history between the University and the study of agriculture. But in reality, it was the land grants, founded by the Morrill Acts of the 1860s, that gave rise to agriculture’s place in higher education.

Land-grant institutions were—and still are—the institutions of higher learning that teach agriculture. Private universities, such as those in the Ivy League, that sought to provide a liberal arts education, were not. As the name suggests, land-grant colleges are defined by the federal government’s granting of plenty of physical land. Agriculture could actually be practiced at these institutions, where it was impossible in more urban setting.

Cornell University is the only Ivy League institution with an agricultural program, its College of Agriculture and Life Sciences. However, its existence does not attest to its pedagogical difference from its peer institutions, but instead expresses its origins as a land-grant institution. The teaching of of food and agriculture at a university like Yale, without the historical underpinnings of its land-grant peer, is less obvious given its own institutional history.

“Coming to Yale, with the complete absence of an agricultural school, has actually been incredibly freeing and has opened up a big opportunity, as far as I can see,” explained Bomford. “We have the opportunity to study food right, because we didn’t start out by creating a food, food science, or agricultural science department.”

If the conventional way of studying food is wrong—in a focused, pre-professional, vocational way—then Yale doesn’t want to be right: it’s the breadth in educational experience surrounding agriculture and food that Bomford hopes the food studies program can provide.

“If you look at—to me—what the biggest problems in the food system are today, it’s what I think is the deficit of broadminded leadership and the ability to connect and synthesize all of these different elements,” Bomford said. “If you look at what the food system needs the most and what Yale pro- duces the best, to me it’s just a wonderful match.” Maybe Yale’s role in agriculture, though initially unclear, can fill a niche that the field lacks.

Other liberal arts schools are finding their way into what purpose they will serve to food and agriculture. “Middlebury is trying to hire a senior person to develop a food studies curriculum there,” Trumpler said. Otherwise, inspiration for a food studies program at Yale has come mainly from graduate programs.

***

If the undergraduate Environmental Studies program has a food studies concentration then it would logical to assume that the School of Forestry and Environmental Studies would have one.

However, this is quite the opposite. Founded at the beginning of the 20th century, school aims to prepare students for careers in forestry and related environmental fields. The incorporation of food into the curriculum at FES is an underwhelm- ing phenomenon—and one only of the very recent past.

Zoe VanGelder, FES ‘14, wondered where the food was. “At a school that focuses on the environment, it would make sense that food would be a major component.” But student demand seemed to outpace the faculty’s supply of food-related opportunities in the classroom.

VanGelder is one of three leaders of the Coalition on Agriculture, Food and the Environment (CAFE), a student interest group dedicated to linking the environmental is- sues of agriculture and the school’s curriculum of ecosystem studies and management. Composed entirely of FES students, the group most recently put on the Yale Food Systems Symposium, which was held from Oct. 18 to Oct. 19 to bring a combination of practitioners, academics, and experts to de- bate and discuss the intricacies of complex food systems.

“[The symposium] is the product of mo- mentum that’s been building for the last 8 years,” VanGelder said, referring to CAFE’s founding nearly a decade ago. “The idea garnered quite a bit of momentum because there was support across Yale.” The orga- nizers realized there were plenty of voices that had simply not taken the opportunity to converse at Yale, and the symposium could provide that platform. They reached out to the YSFP, the International Studies program at the MacMillan Center, the School of Public Health, the Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity—all voices with different takes on the food system.

VanGelder, who staffed an earlier conference from Sept. 14 to Sept. 15 entitled “Food Sovereignty: A Critical Dialogue,” said that at the conference she saw a meaningful discourse between different critical perspectives on the same issues— an interaction similar to those that would occur in a more established discipline. Together, these meetings realize Bomford’s philosophy: “You need to have some theoretical backing in order to make any practical difference.” These conversations lay the foundation of food system theory that is so influential and impactful to the practice in which Appel and Meyer are eager to immerse themselves.

“My motivation for the symposium was to set the tone for what food studies should look like at Yale,” VanGelder said. Organiz- ers are hopeful that the symposium will be- come an annual affair, and this tone would be influential given the relative youth of food studies at Yale.

***

Special programs are a harbinger of a changing Yale experience; one where students are driving the curricular offerings. These programs only add to the Yale College experience, as they provide a source of practical skills without inhibiting a comprehensive liberal arts education. The programs centralize resources that are otherwise scattered and hard to find. With more meaning- fully examined summer work, the education- al landscape is smoothed, but will continue to evolve as professors develop courses with these programs in mind.

Providing a framework with which faculty members can work with will bring forth new proposals. Miller foresees a revitalization of a dormant urban studies program or some combination of courses that would specifically take advantage of the museum collections on campus.

Because these scholarly tracks are not major specific, they bring together students from all academic interests—English majors and Engineering majors might talk in the dining hall, but rarely do they get to interact in the classroom. “The [energy] industry used to be siloed—geologists working together and economists working together and engineers working together, but they didn’t communicate very much,” Oristaglio said. “That’s changed dramatically in the last two decades.” Specialization is important, but then again, the real world is interdisciplinary. These interactions in fact enhance a liberal education.

Bringing practical, real-world problems into academia might at the surface seem counter to encouraging the intended culture of learning for the sake of learning—this could be misconstrued as a dangerous deviation from the liberal arts into pre-professionalism. Conversely, some may believe only theorizing about these pressing issues can mean fewer boots on the ground work- ing to actually solve them.

Special programs promote favor of these arguments and alleviate both of these fears. The happy medium of practice and theory so important to complex systems like food is embedded into the structures of these programs; Appel’s initial dilemma of whether to choose between theory and practice shouldn’t cause concern so long as she is doing both.

The future of the proposed Food Studies Undergraduate Scholars program will be uncertain until it is voted on. With the departure of Brownell, Miller said she is unsure that right now is the best time to go through with it. But if the faculty votes to approve it, the program will cultivate an academic experience unlike any other.

Read more here: http://yaleherald.com/news-and-features/food-for-thought/
Copyright 2026 The Yale Herald