Your mother may have told you to eat your veggies when you were younger, but now she may be telling you to drink them instead. One of the major trends in health, juice diets, has been accredited for preventing illnesses like cancer, improving overall health and being an easy and fast method for weight loss.
With celebrities and health enthusiasts supporting the liquid concoctions, juicing has gained popularity and not only from the hippie yoga instructor. Despite the acclaimed benefits of either fasting or drinking a juice once a week, skeptics argue health concerns and the lack of scientific and beneficial evidence.
Pressing, shoving or squeezing vegetables and fruits into the juicer allow you to consume more of these foods. The quantity of fruits and vegetables are actually increased when juiced (10 cups of spinach will produce 1 cup of spinach juice).
However, some don’t believe these small portions are satisfying.
“It didn’t fill me up and that’s what made my roommate and I stop,” University of Oregon student Kelcie Goetsch said. “I remember going through the school day and having a headache and then we just went to Chipotle the same day we started it.”
For some juice dieters like Goetsch, the primary reason for juicing may be the desire to slim down.
“I did it to lose weight, and I also heard that it boosts your metabolism and cleanses your body,” Goetsch said.
The perception that weight loss leads to a slimmer body is a myth, according to nutrition counselor at PeaceHealth Medical Group Kathleen Brandt.
“Juice diets promote over-nutrition and today, people do not need over-nutrition,” Brandt said. “People need under-nutrition.”
In a study called “Examining College Students’ Daily Consumption of Fresh Fruits and Vegetables,” conducted by the Food Distribution Research Society, 25 percent of 17-to-24-year olds are overweight, and only 23.1 percent of the US population intakes five or more servings of fruits and vegetables daily.
Just because juicing means eating a vast amount of “superfoods” doesn’t mean it’s always a healthy option. For example, when we juice, fibers are extracted from the fruits and vegetables. This absence of fiber causes your body to absorb more fructose sugar, which in turn, can result in higher levels of blood sugar.
An increased level of blood sugar is one example of the negative effects of juicing. For example, the Food and Drug Administration believes juicing can be susceptible to foodborne illnesses like vomiting and diarrhea due to pathogens in the vegetables and fruits. Thus, some dietitians suggest consuming the juice directly after it is made to avoid the possibility of unsanitary foods.
The Mayo Clinic believes that juicing is not healthier than eating the food itself but takes into consideration that people are eating less than the required amount of vegetables and fruits. If you don’t enjoy eating fresh fruits and vegetables, juicing may be a way to add them to your diet or try fruits and vegetables you normally wouldn’t eat.
Whether you create your own juice at home or buy the concoctions made ready, the trend of juicing has no scientific evidence of being healthier than eating solid fruits and vegetables. However, a juice every so often may help enhance your vegetable and fruit intake.