GameDay: Only time will tell how the NCAA’s new rule on targeting will change college football

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

The sport of football has, undoubtedly, always been a physical game. Due to medical studies done on former football players who have suffered head injuries and the impact it has on players’ lives off the field, player safety has been making headlines for a long time.

Following the NFL’s $765 million settlement with ex-players who have experienced brain injuries and encouragement for youth football for coaches to become Heads Up certified, steps and rules have been implemented with the hopes that life-altering head injuries will be minimized in the future.

The NCAA’s new rule on targeting, which was put into effect to prevent head injuries in football, made waves in the opening week of the 2013 season.

The rule prohibits players from targeting opponents or initiating contact with the crown of their helmets.Players are also prohibited from initiating contact with the heads or necks of a defenseless opponent. Players penalized for targeting are ejected from the game.

The Ducks experienced the implications of the new rule firsthand against Nicholls State.

In a game where Oregon gave up only three points, one of the biggest stories from that day was the ejection of cornerback Terrance Mitchell.

With only a minute left in the first quarter, Mitchell had a brutal hit on Colonels quarterback Beaux Hebert, which resulted in Hebert never returning to the field and later being diagnosed with a concussion.

Mitchell was not the only Pac-12 player ejected for targeting that weekend. In Cal’s 44-30 loss to Northwestern, Golden Bears defensive end Chris McCain was removed from the game after his hit on Wildcat quarterback Trevor Siemian. However, the call was later reversed because of a failure in the instant replay process during the game.

“From my understanding, the foul itself is not reviewable. The ejection is reviewable and the criteria to eject is the part where there is a little bit of a gray area,” Oregon head coach Mark Helfrich said during a press conference after the 66-3 win over the Colonels.

Helfrich’s point is one of the main reasons the new rule has caused such controversy: Will each referee have a different opinion in terms of what is targeting and what isn’t?

From the game’s spectators to analysts, questions arise in regard to whether or not there’s a clear-cut way to identify targeting or not. Many question if this new rule will ultimately change football, where brutal hits are a seemingly instrumental part of the game.

“I don’t want my guys to play the game to hurt anybody, but on defense you have to be aggressive and you want your guys to hit,” defensive coordinator Nick Aliotti said during the same press conference. “On the field you want to be violent and aggressive.”

Aliotti’s thoughts also outline why the rule is controversial. Yes, hard hits are a part of the game. But some will ask where to draw the line on the risk football players endure.

According to the American Association of Neurological Surgeons, in 2009 there were 46,948 documented emergency room cases of football-related head injuries. That is the second highest number of injuries reported out of all sports or recreational activities. The first was cycling.

With all of the controversy surrounding the new rule, as well as its potential to alter games, it will be interesting to document its impact.

After Monday’s practice, Helfrich said the targeting rule was something the team went over that day.

“In a situation like that, to tell you how we practice … we talk about never targeting to the head — when sliding never make contact with their head,” Helfrich said.

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2013/09/05/gameday-only-time-will-tell-how-the-ncaas-new-rule-on-targeting-will-change-college-football/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media