In all the speculation about whether the President of the United States is a secret Muslim — a concern matched only be the pre-election fear that his Chicago pastor made him a secret black nationalist — we sometimes forget another possibility: That he secretly subscribes to no religion at all.
Obviously, when you’re publicly speculating on a man’s deeply-held beliefs, you can’t just accept what he says. Until we devise some sort of test for determining whether someone is actually a Christian, possibly involving a very large wheel, or an Iron Maiden we’ll have to rely on two means of discerning the truth, our primal “gut” instincts and textual analysis.
During the President’s famous “folks haven’t been reading their Bibles” speech from 2006, Obama points out that government, following scripture, would restore slavery and ban shellfish. This suggesst that the President finds religion a useful force for uniting people and inspiring them to good but also might not believe that an actual god wrote the actual Bible, which serves as a blueprint for the ideal society in both 2010 and 3000 B.C. but was withheld from humanity for the first 95,000 years.
It sounds kind of stupid when you put it that way, doesn’t it? Obama reminded us of our willingness to ignore certain portions of Leviticus, Deuteronomy and the Sermon on the Mount to expose the absurdity of employing religious politics in a secular democracy.
When Obama said, in the same speech, “Democracy demands that the religiously motivated translate their concerns into universal — rather than religion-specific — values.
It requires that their proposals be subject to argument, and amenable to reason,” he was essentially arguing for the principles western culture adopted in the Enlightenment.
While such a stance might not have been controversial in the past, the profoundly radicalized American right is quick to expose his heresy and bludgeon him into conformity with the convictions of Reagan Jesus.
Reagan Jesus is a fickle deity, whose idea of the Golden Rule is “whoever has the gold, makes the rules” and regards “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s” as a redundant statement.
If Reagan Jesus had his way, he would do everything in his power to make men like King Herod and Pontius Pilot as rich as possible so that their wealth might “trickle down” to people like John the Baptist or Mary Magdeline.
Reagan Jesus would have still brought Lazarus back to life, but he would have charged a hefty fee as well because free health care is for socialists. He would have cut his long hippie hair and pasted a “Support our Roman Troops” sticker to the back of his donkey.
Reagan Jesus’ disciples were positively pervasive at Glenn Beck’s rally last week, and counted among them was Becky Benson, who said she drove up from Orlando because “we believe in Jesus Christ,” and said that Jesus would not have agreed with welfare. “You cannot sit and expect someone to hand out to you,” Benson said.
I bring up this grotesque inversion of the values expressed by Jesus in the New Testament to point out the degree to which, in America, a certain type of Christianity has become a brand name for a certain social politics. Ironically, it is the Christianity commonly professed by the most devout among us.
The earthly arbiters of this divine law invoke the teachings of Christ at every turn, yet are also pro-war and anti-welfare.
It is a self-jusitfying, rich man’s religion — the Sunday morning gesture of a George H.W. Bush, the oil millionaire who ran the CIA and orchestrated the Iran-Contra Affair, yet had the audacity to publicly declare “I don’t know that atheists should be considered as citizens, nor should they be considered as patriots.”
In other words, it’s Republicanism, and it resorts to Scripture only when it runs out of justifications. It is the collar around the neck of the faithful that makes vast economic inequality, continual war and a State morality dictated by asexual flagellants look like look like paradise.
Which brings us back to the question of whether the President believes in God. In “The Audacity of Hope,” he discusses his a-religious upbringing, and how he brought that agnosticism to his work as a community organizer in his 20s. It was there that he encountered a problem:
“The Christians with whom I worked recognized themselves in me … but they sensed that a part of me remained removed, detached, an observer among them. I came to realize that without an unequivocal commitment to a particular community of faith, I would be consigned at some level to always remain apart, free in the way that my mother was free, but also alone in the same ways she was ultimately alone.”
Obama is not talking about the existence of an omnipotent entity that created the universe. He is not talking about a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, a moment when God tells him to put down the bottle like he did for George W. Bush and Beck. Barack Obama is talking about the church, about the organization of people around faith to take action in this world. In other words, he’s talking about politics.
The difference between Obama’s politics and Reagan Jesus’ of course, is that he doesn’t expect you to roll over and do what he says every time he finds a relevant verse in the Bible.
Obama seems to see his Christianity as a tool for leadership rather than control. Whether it is a real Christianity — whether he has God in his heart, or whether he just likes people getting together to help each other and throw potlucks — seems like the second most interesting question in the argument.
The first is, in 2010, in an America where the vast majority of Bible-believing Christians vote the same way, what does being religious really mean?