UO researcher’s ‘pro-sociality’ theory says religion promotes charity despite personal costs

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

The god factor.

Some people choose to have faith in a being that controls everything in the universe while others believe we’re put here by chance and that it’s up to us to make our own destiny. Faith allows believers to adhere to a certain moral standard, even when it’s costly.

Assistant professor of religion, morality, cultural and evolutionary psychology Azim Shariff calls this religious pro-sociality, and it’s the hypothesis he used as the base for a study aimed to test whether religious concepts encourage people to act as a positive influence in society.

One of the studies conducted to test his theory started with a group of strangers separated into different rooms. The strangers didn’t meet each other and were told that they never would meet, allowing for zero personal connection between participants. One stranger would be given $10 in one room, while the other was given nothing in another.

“This is a classic game from experimental economics called the dictator game,” Shariff said. “The self-interested thing to do, especially when one needn’t worry about one’s reputation, is to keep all the money, and this is actually what most people do.”

The majority of participants who decided to split the $10 50/50 were the ones who were “implicitly primed” with god concepts, meaning that these were people who unconsciously evoked to think about god.

“So, from the study we were able to conclude that thinking about god really does make people more pro-social,” Shariff said. “One important thing to note about it, and our theory more generally, is that we are not suggesting that religion is the only path to moral behavior.”

What needed to be deducted after that was what kind of god makes people behave in a pro-social matter.

“We predicted that the belief in an angry and punishing god would be more likely to scare people into acting ethically, than the belief in a loving and forgiving god,” Shariff said. “People who believe that god is more punishing and generally harsh are less likely to cheat, whereas people who believe god is forgiving are actually more likely to cheat. In fact, when you prime people to think about a forgiving god, they are more likely to cheat and steal than if they weren’t thinking about religion at all.”

Shariff concluded through his studies that countries that generally believe in heaven but don’t have much belief in hell have higher crime rates.

“The fact that forgiving god beliefs actually have negative effects on moral behavior is one of those things that really did surprise us the first time we found it, but in retrospect, it sort of makes sense,” Shariff said.

According to Shariff’s studies, he also concluded that people who fear a god are consider to be trusted more by people of any belief while those who consider themselves atheists were looked upon as distrusting.

“If your morality is based on the fact that you are being morally evaluated by a god, then people who don’t believe in god would seem morally unmoored and unpredictable,” Shariff said. “So our prediction was that the massive dislike for atheists, who are routinely found to be the least liked group in America, is driven by a deep moral distrust. We ran several studies here, which found consistent support for that.”

Some anecdotal evidence supports Shariff’s claims.

“Yeah, that actually definitely makes sense to me,” said Scott Nolen, a student at the UO who was as a church-goer but considers himself to be agnostic, meaning he’s open to the idea that there could be a God, but doesn’t believe there is one. “Some of the most honest people I’ve met have been from my church when I was growing up. I’m not sure they’re all necessarily nice though because they’re afraid to be punished if they’re not. I think it’s more of a ‘be a good example’ type thing.”

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2013/07/26/uo-researchers-pro-sociality-theory-says-religion-promotes-charity-despite-personal-costs/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media