Leading 24-21 with only three seconds left in regulation, Utah head coach Kyle Whittingham opted to call timeout just as Pittsburgh snapped the ball to their kicker, Dan Hutchins, who made the would-be 30-yard field goal attempt.
The effectiveness of icing the kicker, as this practice is called, has been debated in the past few years. However, the 45,730 people at Rice-Eccles Stadium—the third largest crowd in Utah history—erupted, as the plan worked and Hutchins missed on attempt number two. Game over—or so it seemed.
As it turned out, Whittingham had opted to ice Hutchins again. One more try.
With his potential game-loser behind him, Hutchins lined up once more and nailed the field goal to send the game into overtime.
Utah won the coin toss and opted to take possession second. Little did they know how short of a wait its offense would have.
On Pitt’s first play in overtime, sophomore quarterback Tino Sunseri, who was starting in his first career game, attempted to hit wide out Mike Shanahan when freshman safety Brian Blechen cut off the passing lane and picked off the pass.
“(Sunseri) will get better and better,” said Pitt head coach Dave Wannstedt. “He’ll get better and better. This is a tough place to play.”
Needing only a field goal to add yet another BCS team to the list of teams knocked off by the Utes, bruising back Matt Asiata rushed for 16 yards, which set up the game-clinching 21-yard field goal by Joe Phillips.
“Hope you got your money’s worth,” Whittingham said about the dramatic finish. “Bottom line, we made one more play than the Pitt Panthers tonight.”
Heading into Thursday’s matchup, Pitt was the favored team, in part because of their dynamic sophomore running back Dion Lewis, who prior to the game had rushed for more than 100 yards in 10 consecutive games.
Adding to the thought that Lewis was in store for a big game was the fact that the Utes’ defense had lost seven starters and many questioned if their replacements would be able to step up.
After holding Lewis to only 83 rushing yards—50 of which came in the first quarter—and 266 total yards as a team, the Utes’ defense was able to keep their team in this game despite three turnovers on offense and a blocked punt inside their own 10 yard line.
“I’m very proud of the young defense,” Whittingham said. “They stepped up and made a lot of plays. They got put in some bad situations and some tough spots and responded very well.”
The Utes’ offense twice turned the ball over in the first half within their own territory, the second of which led to a 3-yard touchdown run by Lewis that put Pitt up 7-0 early in the second quarter.
However, not about to roll over, the Utes responded with a touchdown of their own on the following drive on a 19-yard hookup by quarterback Jordan Wynn to senior receiver Jereme Brooks, who had a career night with five receptions for 87 yards and two touchdowns. Brooks’ second touchdown came less than a minute later, as Utes’ kickoff specialist Nick Marsh recovered a fumble on the Pitt 35-yard line on the proceeding kickoff, giving the Utes a 14-7 lead they held going into halftime.
The Utes’ defense was once again put into a tough situation midway through the third quarter, when Sean Selwood’s punt was blocked by Pitt corner Antwuan Reed. Reed also recovered a fumble on the Utes’ 8-yard line, leading to a Hutchins field goal.
With 7 minutes and 59 seconds remaining in the fourth quarter and the score 17-13, Jordan Wynn found Devonte Christopher, who in his first career start also saw career numbers, for a 61-yard touchdown.
Pitt matched, when Sunseri was finally able to hook up with star receiver Jon Baldwin, who was smothered most of the night by corner Brandon Burton, for a 44-yard touchdown and a subsequent two-point conversion, bringing them back into the game 24-21.
However, it ultimately wasn’t enough, and now Pitt heads back home 0-1.
“The defense kept us in the game,” Wynn said. “Hopefully we, as an offense, can try to help them out.”
Despite the turnovers, along with Christopher and Brooks, there were some bright spots to the offense. Matt Asiata and Eddie Wide combined for 112 yards on 25 carries, and fullback freshman Shawn Asiata, Matt’s brother, opened up some big holes throughout, giving the Utes a new aspect to their running attack.
“We had a good gameplan going in, and it was being called,” Wynn said. “We just need to cut down on penalties and turnovers.”
Utah now turns its attention to its MWC opener next week when the Utes host UNLV.