Column: Drawn out quarterback selection process hurts Penn State

By Andrew J. Cassavell

At this point, it doesn’t even matter who the winner is.

It doesn’t matter whether Kevin Newsome, Matt McGloin or Robert Bolden takes the first snap under center when Penn State kicks off its 2010 season Saturday against Youngstown State.

It just needs to be someone. It needed to be someone weeks ago.

At his press conference today, Joe Paterno may very well announce his choice for starting quarterback. By then, it will already be too late.

In waiting until four days before the opener to announce a final decision, the coaching staff is doing no one a favor.

First, let’s get one thing straight: Joe owes no one in the media any answers. But this isn’t about letting the public know. This is about giving the winner of the job vital reps in practice, when in two weeks he-who-must-not-be-named enters a frenzied atmosphere in Tuscaloosa to take on defending champion and current No. 1 Alabama.

Typically, during game-week practice, the first-string quarterback wears baby blue, while the backup wears green. When the Lions trotted onto the practice field outside Holuba Hall on Monday for their first game-week practice of the 2010 season, all three wore red.

Aside from the confusion, that means all three quarterbacks took turns directing the first-team offense. That also means the eventual starter took one-third as many snaps as he should have with the offense.

For the winner, the lack of snaps will only add to his rawness. Newsome has the most experience (if you can call it that) throwing 11 passes last season. McGloin tossed two incompletions last year, and Bolden, a true freshman, was busy shaking defenders at St. Mary’s prep in Michigan.

And for the losers — especially if Bolden gets the job, and sources say he has looked very impressive this preseason — it’s months of false hope and the likelihood of a transfer and a bitter end to a Penn State career.

Word out of camp is that the quarterbacks are getting impatient on a decision, and why shouldn’t they be? Two people will leave fall practice disappointed, no matter who wins. The waiting only augments that frustration. A negative answer is better than no answer — especially since there eventually has to be a conclusion.

Even Daryll Clark wants answers. The former quarterback tweeted Monday, “Man somebody better keep me in the loop!!! I haven’t been gone that long.. Who is the trigger man this year I NEED ANSWERS lol.”

In the Big Ten right now, there are two quarterback races without the much-desired conclusion — one in Happy Valley and one in Ann Arbor. Like Penn State, Michigan has two sophomores and a true freshman competing for the job, and like Joe Paterno, Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez has yet to make a decision.

But even the much-maligned Rodriguez has the upper hand on Paterno on this one.

Tate Forcier and Denard Robinson saw significant time in important games last season. Newsome and McGloin only saw significant time in April’s Blue-White scrimmage.

“I wish it was decided a week ago,” McGloin said 19 days ago. “It does take a lot out of you, mentally.”

Somehow, instead of trimming down the race, the coaching staff muddied it more, adding Robert Bolden to the top line of Sunday’s most recent depth chart with Newsome and McGloin.

Four days before the season, the competition is even murkier than it was in January at Joe Paterno’s postseason press conference.

It was the focal point of Paterno’s presser during spring practice. It was the biggest topic discussed at media day. Now, in the week leading up to the opener, “Who will be starting quarterback?” is the most asked question in Happy Valley.

There is also the potential of this dragging out longer, with the Youngstown State game serving as another scrimmage. But we will get an answer, eventually.

Whoever that answer is, he’ll have a lot of catching up to do.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/08/30/drawn_out_quarterback_selectio.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian