Heaps of data about for-profit colleges have gotten attention in recent months as Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, pushes to increase oversight on the industry — spurred by allegations of misleading recruiting and lackluster employment rates among for-profit school graduates. Last week marked a deadline for some proprietary institutions to disclose previously private information to the senator.
While the details of those disclosures aren’t yet available, Harkin’s staff said information will likely spur further hearings in the fall.
“Our goal remains the same: to ensure that students and the American taxpayer are getting what they are promised,” a Harkin spokeswoman told The Daily Iowan.
As that investigation continues, experts say the federal government’s pursuit of more regulation could have farther-reaching effects — bearing consequences even on nonprofit colleges such as the University of Iowa.
“Higher education is already experiencing problems with the public in terms of the perception of whether we are a suitable use of public dollars,” said Christopher Morphew, the head of the U. Iowa educational policy and leadership studies department. “Questions about whether the higher education institutions are preparing their graduates are questions, when brought to the forefront, that call into question some of the nonprofits as well.”
For-profit institutions only enroll around 10 percent of U.S. college students but those students receive almost a quarter of federal financial-aid dollars — more than $20 billion annually.
Additionally, Pell Grant totals at nonprofit schools have declined while for-profit colleges’ students are seeing more Pell Grant dollars.
Students at both for-profit and nonprofit schools draw federal aid from the same limited funds.
Even outside higher education, the for-profit sector’s burden might weigh on the entire economy.
For starters, 40 percent of students at for-profit schools default on their loans within 15 years of graduation, according to a report from the Chronicle of Higher Education last month.
“It’s taxpayer money going to corporations, and that’s money we’re not going to get back. There’s an economic interest that goes way beyond consumer protection,” said Alisa Hicklin Fryar, a political-science professor who studies education and public policy at the University of Oklahoma.
Fryar also points out the possible long-term implications of a federal solution for for-profit college issues.
“For the most part, higher education is governed by state bodies so the entrance of the federal government at least raises questions to what does that mean down the road,” she said in an interview last week.