UPDATE:
ASUO President Laura Hinman, on behalf of the ASUO Executive and Election Board Coordinator Pat Chaney, reported there will not be an election next week.
“At this point, the Constitution Court is interpreting state laws and not constitutional laws. Until more communication occurs, there will not be an election next week; we will not be having DuckWeb active,” she said. “We will be keeping the results from last week.”
ASUO Constitution Court announced Saturday the Elections Board must schedule a new week of ASUO elections due to a recent grievance filed against the United Oregon campaign regarding bribery.
The original grievance, filed by Ducks for a Difference campaign manager Andrew Rogers, accused members of the United Oregon campaign of withholding t-shirts for votes.
Just after 3:30 p.m. on Friday, the last day of the election, the student court issued a judicial order postponing the results of the election until it could review the grievance.
In response to the grievance, ASUO presidential candidate Sam Dotters-Katz mentioned there was little evidence to prove the campaign had bribed voters.
“Because (United Oregon) does not know who is being accused, it cannot produce evidence or testimony to disprove the allegations by (Andrew Rogers),” he wrote. “Except with the testimony of Amy Jones regarding Nicholas Seymour.”
A Findings of Fact submitted by Chaney reports that Seymour denied the testimony given by Jones.
“He stated that he did not remember the specific voter interaction Ms. Jones witnessed,” Chaney wrote, “but that he was certain he said no such thing to any voter.”
In the court opinion, it was concluded there were three important points suggested in Chaney’s Findings of Fact. First, there was evidence United Oregon had a campaign policy not to offer t-shirts in return for a vote. Second, there was evidence United Oregon offered t-shirts but only to increase voter turnout. Third, there was enough evidence to suggest that isolated incidents of representatives from United Oregon were violating their own campaign policy.
Chaney also testified that representatives from United Oregon contacted him to ask whether t-shirts could be offered to voters to encourage voting as long as requesting the voter to vote a specific way was not demanded.
“I immediately offered both campaigns the same advise,” he wrote. “In my opinion the Rules forbade giving, or promising, T-shirts in return for a vote for any specific candidate, but that offering T-shirts as an incitement to vote without demanding a specific vote was acceptable.”
The court was not satisfied with Chaney’s advice.
“Unfortunately, the ASUO Elections Coordinator erred in offering this advice,” the court’s opinion read. “Elections Rule 6.2 (PDF) clearly states the ‘members of the Elections Board … will not provide explanations, offer interpretations, or give advice regarding state and federal laws.’”
It also found that while the grievance was filed by a representative of Ducks for a Difference, both campaigns were distributing t-shirts to get students to vote. Because of these findings, the court ruled both campaigns had violated the rules.
“The Court concludes that both campaigns have violated the ASUO Election Rules because they have failed to comply with Oregon election laws,” the court wrote in its opinion.
ORS 260.665 states “a person, acting either alone or with or through any other person, may not directly or indirectly subject any person to undue influence,” including, “giving or promising to give money, employment or other thing of value.”
The court summarized this law to mean that nothing of value can be given to an individual with the intent to influence how that individual votes — or whether that individual votes at all.
To remedy the violations, it ordered the Elections Board to “schedule and administer a new election in whatever timeframe in deemed appropriate.”