Diversity plan stays the same: Borough opts not to expand Human Relations Commission

By Casey McDerrmott

The State College Borough Council’s Human Relations Commission has gone three years without receiving any complaints of discrimination, and council members at Monday night’s meeting opted not to expand the commission’s role to address issues of diversity in other ways.

The borough council established the Human Relations Commission in 2007 as part of its Anti-Discrimination Ordinance, Borough Manager Tom Fountaine said.

The commission’s director, Penn State professor Charles Dumas, told council he would like to expand the commission to include opportunities for discussions on diversity and meetings with the public.

Council member Don Hahn said the borough was reluctant to expand the commission’s role because it might detract from its original purpose.

“We were concerned about the perceived objectivity of a commission that is charged with adjudicating a violation of the ordinance also taking a more proactive role in terms of trying to find cases of discrimination,” Hahn said.

According to the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC) Annual Report for 2007-2008, Centre County had 25 filed cases of discrimination during that year — 23 employment-related claims, 1 education-related claim and 1 housing-related claim.

That report was the most recent one on file on the PHRC website, and the report did not specify whether any of the claims were filed within the State College Borough.

Though the State College Anti-Discrimination Ordinance includes provisions for discrimination based on a range of factors, the legislation specifically aimed to include sexual orientation and gender expression among protected classes, Fountaine said, as neither are covered in state laws.

“Generally, there have not been a large number of cases,” Fountaine said. “But that does not mean that discrimination has not occurred — it just means that the cases have not been filed either way.”

Hahn also said some instances of discrimination probably go unreported, and if they are reported it’s usually with a higher level of government.

“Certainly the state commission probably has broader jurisdiction, as well as broader enforcement powers than our local board,” he said.

Another meeting will be organized to discuss some of the concerns Dumas voiced regarding the commission, Hahn said.

Fountaine said the borough will also try to better coordinate its efforts with other groups in the area like the Centre County Advisory Committee to the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission and the Community Diversity Group.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/08/11/diversity_plan_stays_the_same.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian