Smeal targets essays

By Paul Osolnick

In an effort to deter plagiarism in admission essays, the Smeal College of Business will now use Turnitin for Admissions — an Internet plagiarism checker — in the college’s MBA program.

The program’s use of the anti-plagiarism service was put in place after 30 applicants for the 2009-2010 program plagiarized from published articles — that were recently published at the time — on the same topic as the admission essay, said Carrie Marcinkevage, MBA program admissions director.

The applications were one page long and about “principled leadership,” Marcinkevage said. The plagiarism ranged from unattributed paraphrasing to copying and pasting of three whole paragraphs, she said.

After it was determined the application essays contained plagiarism, 15 applicants were denied admission, nine interviews were canceled and one admission was rescinded, Marcinkevage said. Four of the applications were determined to be “borderline plagiarism” and the applicants were invited to re-write their essays.

Marcinkevage said the program has seen plagiarism only on a very limited basis before, but never to the extent that emerged in 2009-2010.

“We think of it kind of as the perfect storm of plagiarism,” Marcinkevage said.

Marcinkevage said the MBA program admissions will use Turnitin for Admissions for the upcoming 2010-2011 program year.

Even though the Turnitin academic program — which is used for class papers — has received some criticism from students about its reliance on computers to check the papers for matches, Marcinkevage said the final decision on application essays will always be done by actual people checking the essays.

While the Turnitin for Admissions program charges a fee based on the number of applications processed, Marcinkevage said Turnitin waived the fee for the first year to get Penn State involved with the program.

Jeff Lortin, Turnitin for Admissions product and business development manager, said the admission version is different from the academic edition of Turnitin in that it was specifically designed to check over application essays.

Lortin said the program checks essays against Internet content, major library databases, textbooks, encyclopedias, 130 million student-written papers and Turnitin’s separate application essay database to produce a similarity report with the submitted essay.

Lortin said that because the admissions plagiarism program was launched in December, there are still only a few universities that have started to use the program. Still, he said, several have shown interest.

Marcinkevage said the Turnitin software is the last resort as the MBA admissions program will try to educate people about the standards for plagiarism prior to the application process to help prevent the problem.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/08/10/smeal_targets_essays.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian