Up until this point, I’d been losing hope in our legal system. It was becoming increasingly focused on imposing personal political and religious beliefs rather than focusing on what is just.
Proposition 8 is an example of this. The ballot initiative proclaimed gay marriage in California to be illegal. It encouraged these oppressive bans in other states. This made the haughty Californians who voted for the initiative act justified, as if their beliefs were indeed superior to those whose only sin was falling in love against societal norms. Many other supporters of Prop. 8 across the nation echoed this. Meanwhile, believers in gay marriage grew angry, frustrated and depressed.
But on August 4, Prop. 8 was overturned. A federal judge struck down the initiative saying that it was unconstitutional and unjust. The (mainly) religious beliefs that had caused many people to oppose gay marriage wouldn’t be forced upon the rest of the nation.
A lot of people consider religion to be a guide for their beliefs. However, the government isn’t here to tell us which beliefs of which religion is correct. We don’t live in a theocracy. Our government is supposed to defend our freedom and our lives. No matter what some people claim, gay marriage does nothing to hinder either and supports both.
However, Family Research Council President Tony Perkins was cited on CNN as saying that “This is the age of the Tea Party, where you have people saying government is not listening, and here you have a judge saying seven million people (who supported California’s Proposition 8 ) don’t matter.”
This isn’t quite true. The ruling doesn’t say that these people don’t matter; it says that they have no right to impose their own beliefs on those who don’t necessarily agree.
I realize we live in a republic, and the people and people’s representatives are meant to hold the power, but I believe the decision to overturn Prop. 8 is an example of one of the greatest things about the United States. Our laws fight to keep the majority from oppressing the minority (and vice versa).
The other thing that happened to give me faith in our legal system was the swearing in of Supreme Court Justice, Elena Kagan.
Recently, we’ve seen Supreme Court decisions split almost right along political lines with one or two judges making up a swing vote. This isn’t the way it’s supposed to be. Justices are supposed to consider the constitutionality of decisions and laws on a case-by-case basis. If they truly did this, they would likely vote both for and against things they personally believe in, depending on the case. We almost never see this. It isn’t their job to impose their own political beliefs. They are supposed to be above politics.
On August 7, Elena Kagan was sworn in. Although the wires report that she is expected to vote along Democratic lines, I believe she represents the beginning of a change. During her hearings, she didn’t say things like “I would vote this way” or “I would vote that way,” she said that she would defend laws if she had constitutional reason to do so and fight them for constitutional reasons. This gives me hope that she may be able to bring back some of the idealism and justice that the Court is supposed to represent.
I’ve said for a while that I feel like our nation is in decline. We’re too polarized. We’re more focused on what we want, what we believe, than what is actually best for our country. Now, I’ve seen some sparks of justice. I have hope again.